- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents a new self-supervised approach for denoising diffusion MRI 4D data, which extends the blind spot/splitting framework (which relies on splitting the noisy data in two subsets with noise realizations that are independent of each other) to diffusion MRI, taking into account the fact that noise is typically correlated in the spatial axes (due to parallel/accelerated imaging) and not on the angle axis. The paper also proposes using an additional branch network that improves the reconstructions further. Experiments on diffusion MRI data (denoising a single 4D instance at a time) show better performance than similar algorithms such as Patch2Self.
Critical strengths
- The paper shows better performance than other self-supervised denoising frameworks specific to diffusion MRI data
Critical weaknesses
-
I find the paper extremely hard to follow. Having both significant experience in self-supervised denoising methods and in MRI reconstruction algorithms (albeit I'm not an expert on the specific case of diffusion MRI), I'm really struggling to understand the contributions.
- The abstract needs an almost full rewrite: it is overly specific and fails to communicate in simpler terms that do not require the reader to have read the paper already (eg "tensor-guided framework", "FA-guided spatio-angular shuffling", etc.), uses unexplained acronyms, and is very hard to follow.
- Many diffusion-MRI-specific points are not introduced ("FA", subfigures of Fig. 3, does "dataset" entail a single patient or a set of patients?)
- The mathematical notation is unnecessarily dense, with a large number of symbols and a complex handling of subindices and subscrits on every symbol. The math formulations require an almost full rewrite, trying to focus on the essential symbols and simplifying the indexing logic. I believe that the main idea of the paper, ie wisely choosing the splitting strategy for diffusion MRI data, should be explainable without that level of complexity.
- Equation 11 is not very clear, what is there? What are the various indices?
- There are multiple flawed sentences, e.g., "Simulation dataset under Self-supervised performance also depends critically on how training observations are constructed."
- I did not understand the role of from section 3.3 - how does it differ from the main blind spot branch?
-
The paper seems to imply a few times that correlation between two pixels of the clean signal means having similar values or a low-lipschitz constant, e.g., "This tension is particularly important in dMRI because signal variation depends on both spatial location and diffusion direction" - in any image, signal variations are spatially correlated (for example, in natural images two neighbouring pixels might be strongly correlated without necessarily having similar values)?
Questions for authors
- How does the computational time of your method compare with other baselines? Given the large scale of the 4D data, I would expect this to be a major factor when choosing an algorithm
- Why do you train a network on one patient (a 4D dataset) at a time? Most splitting/blind spot methods are trained across a large number of subjects/patients/scenes and then simply evaluated on new ones.
3 comments
Response to Reviewer xbcy
We hope that our clarifications and additional experiments have addressed your main concerns. We would greatly appreciate your further feedback and welcome any remaining questions during the discussion period. We also hope that the new evidence and discussions will be taken into account in your final assessment.
Response to Reviewer xbcy
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for your constructive feedback. We have taken your concerns seriously and made substantial revisions, including extensive additional experiments and theoretical clarification. We would like to briefly summarize our major efforts:
-
Validation under spatially correlated noise: We added experiments with explicitly correlated Rician and nc-chi noise across multiple correlation levels. Our method consistently achieves the highest PSNR, outperforming the strongest baseline by 1.30 dB under the highest correlation level. We also added quantitative SNR evaluations on real dMRI data.
-
Theoretical clarification and validation: We revised the error analysis to align with the actual self-supervised training objective, clarified the conditions for bias reduction, and provided empirical evidence supporting these conditions.
-
Additional experiments and improved clarity: We conducted FA threshold sensitivity analyses, direction-exclusion ablations, and computational efficiency comparisons. We also substantially simplified the mathematical notation and improved the methodological explanations.
These revisions represent considerable experimental and analytical effort, undertaken specifically to address the concerns raised in the reviews. We sincerely hope that this new evidence will receive the careful consideration it deserves.
We would also like to respectfully emphasize that active participation in the discussion phase is an important responsibility of ICLR reviewers. The ICLR reviewing guidelines explicitly recognize responding to author rebuttals as a core part of reviewers' responsibilities. We believe that carefully considering and engaging with substantive author responses is essential to a fair and constructive review process, as well as a reflection of mutual respect between reviewers and authors.
We fully respect your right to maintain your original assessment. However, we would greatly appreciate a substantive response indicating whether our additional experiments and clarifications have addressed your concerns and, if not, which specific issues remain unresolved.
Thank you for your time and consideration. We look forward to your feedback.
Response to Reviewer xbcy
W1: Our method is specifically designed for diffusion MRI denoising and exploits the directional dependence of diffusion signals. We therefore consider it necessary to retain established concepts such as the diffusion tensor and diffusion anisotropy to accurately explain the method’s rationale and theoretical contribution. However, we agree that their roles should be clear without requiring prior knowledge of the proposed framework. Accordingly, we have revised the abstract to explain how diffusion tensor information guides data perturbations, replaced “spatio-angular shuffling” with a direct description of shuffling across spatial locations and diffusion directions, and simplified the explanation of how the two views interact. We have also expanded FA, DW at their first occurrence. These revisions improve accessibility while preserving the technical precision and central contributions of the work.
Regarding dataset, it is the dataset of a single subject. This is common for self-supervised denoising in diffusion MRI, the well-established method such as Patch2Self, they also used the dataset of one subject to denoise.
As for mathematical notation, we agree that the notation and indexing in the original manuscript could be simplified. We also wish to clarify that our contribution extends beyond selecting a data-splitting strategy. Our theoretical analysis explains the trade-off between noise decorrelation and signal distortion induced by perturbations, providing a principled basis for anisotropy-guided shuffling. The complementary tensor-reconstructed view addresses residual noise dependence while introducing a distinct source of model-related error. Distinguishing these mechanisms clarifies why each component is needed and how they work together. Accordingly, we have removed unnecessary notation, standardized subscripts and superscripts, simplified indexing, and improved transitions between subsections. Detailed diffusion MRI formulations have been moved to the appendix so that the main text focuses on the essential analysis and methodological rationale. The original Eq. (11) describes tensor-based signal reconstruction: the diffusion tensor is estimated from measurements excluding the target direction and then used to reconstruct the target signal. We have revised this formulation to explicitly define the variables and indices specifying the directions used for tensor estimation and relocated the detailed calculation to the appendix.
During LaTeX editing, “Simulation dataset under” was inadvertently inserted into the sentence “Self-supervised performance also depends critically on how training observations are constructed.” This error has been corrected.
faux predicts one view from another using Noise2Noise-inspired supervision, whereas the main blind-spot branch predicts each voxel from its surrounding context, excluding its own measurement. Cross-view prediction provides complementary information.
W2: We agree that statistical correlation does not imply signal similarity or a small Lipschitz constant. Our Lipschitz condition is instead a local regularity assumption used to bound the clean-signal perturbation caused by shuffling in terms of the local Lipschitz constant and shuffling distance. While spatial correlation is also common in natural images, our statement emphasizes that shuffling in dMRI involves both spatial and diffusion-directional variations, without equating statistical correlation with local smoothness.
Q1: We have added a computational efficiency comparison with five representative baselines, reporting inference time, model parameters, and FLOPs, as shown in Table 1, page 7. Our method requires 237.86 s for inference, which is approximately 4.56× faster than MPPCA (1084.41 s), 9.10× faster than Patch2Self (2164.77 s), and 5.4% faster than Replace2Self (251.39 s). Although SAN2N (7.69 s) and UP2-MAE (155.60 s) achieve shorter inference times, our method maintains a competitive computational cost, with 3.677M parameters and 355.32G FLOPs. These results provide a quantitative assessment of the computational efficiency of our method and clarify its trade-off between denoising performance and inference cost for large-scale 4D dMRI processing.
Q2: Our method adopts a subject-specific self-supervised training strategy, as commonly used in dMRI denoising methods such as Patch2Self. It exploits the spatial and angular redundancy within each 4D dMRI dataset to learn directly from noisy measurements, without requiring external training data or clean references. This strategy allows the model to adapt to subject-specific signal characteristics and acquisition-dependent noise properties, particularly when diffusion-encoding schemes, b-values, and imaging protocols vary across datasets.