- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Overall, this is an industry application focussed paper where the authors propose a framework for ad image generation, performance estimation, and auction to optimize for ad revenue. The author's clearly outline the challenges in this setup (i.e., controlling the share of each brand in terms of real estate/prominence in the image, estimating clicks, and optimizing revenue). The proposed approach includes heuristics in the prompt for image generation (making it senstive to target shares), a VLM evaluator for click propensity, and an auction mechanism in sync with their setup (showing theoretical guarantees, e.g., dominant strategy incentive compatibility and individual rationality). The authors share postiive results on synthetic data, validating claims around revenue maximization. In terms of shortcomings, the paper is limited in terms of (1) modeling contributions (mostly has heuristics and straightforward LLM/VLM applications except the auction design part where proving guarantees is not trivial) and (2) validation on real advertising data/acceptance from advertisers and ad platforms.
Critical strengths
-
One of the core strengths in this paper is the clean decomposition of challenges in a real world product setting. The proposed framework has separate blocks for share sensitive prompting, VLM based click propensity estimation and auction design for revenue maximization.
-
Authors have shared theoretical guarantees around dominant strategy incentive compatibility and individual rationality
-
Positive results on synthetic data.
Critical weaknesses
-
Modeling novelty/contributions are limited. Except the auction design part, the framework mostly involves prompting heuristics and direct applications of existing models.
-
Experiments are on synthetic data. There is no evidence around how well it will work on real world advertising data, and if advertisers/ad platforms will actually adopt this approach.
-
Real world ad platforms and advertiser expectations are more complex than in the paper's setting. For example, there may be errors in click propensity estimation or an advertiser may not get the desired ROI. How will the proposed framework handle such situations - this is where experiments in an actual ad platform would have meaningfully strengthened the paper.
Questions for authors
- Have the authors experimented with any datasets from real advertising platforms?
4 comments
For Weakness 2 & 3:
Experiments are on synthetic data. There is no evidence around how well it will work on real world advertising data, and if advertisers/ad platforms will actually adopt this approach.
Thank you for your suggestion. We acknowledge the importance of real-world platform validation and would like to clarify the research positioning and empirical foundations of our work.
First, validating mechanisms through constructed scenarios, simulated feedback, or model-based evaluation is an approach widely adopted by related studies. For example, Dütting et al. (2024) and MOSAIC (Soumalias et al., 2025) use fictitious advertisers or synthetic instances. Sun et al. (2025) evaluate image auctions using constructed prompt scenarios and CLIP alignment scores. LLM-Auction (Zhao et al., 2025), although using real advertising materials, still relies on simulated click feedback and bids. IAMFM (Liu et al., 2026) and Neuron Auctions (Yun et al., 2026) also employ model-based evaluations of utility or click intention. Turner-Smith et al. (2026) explicitly identify the unavailability of behavioral logs and use agent-based simulations to construct click-intention supervision. Since these business models are still emerging, existing platform data often cannot provide actual feedback, such as CTR and conversion rates, for specific combinations of generated content and allocation mechanisms.
Therefore, few studies in this field use real-world platform data, but this does not diminish their value. Rather, these studies offer diverse approaches and insights into emerging economic models in the AI era, making them valuable research contributions.
Consequently, these studies primarily investigate how generative capabilities can be translated into allocatable and priceable auction items, establishing methodological foundations for practical deployment.
Our work focuses on transforming product exposure in generated images into controllable, evaluable, and priceable auction items, which is a fundamental prerequisite for implementing this business model. We achieve controllable product exposure generation through the combination of RSC and SCP, and verify the monotonic relationship between target exposure shares and CTI. In the absence of real-world advertising CTR data, we further compare predicted CTI with independently reported human click intentions and observe an obvious correlation, providing human-based evidence for evaluating the effectiveness of generated images. Building on this, we develop a configuration-based auction mechanism with DSIC and IR guarantees, providing a concrete implementation for the allocation and pricing of shared generated images. Together, these experiments and theoretical analyses provide preliminary evidence for the feasibility of introducing image generation into auction-based advertising. The proposed exposure control method, CTI evaluation metric, and auction mechanism provide methodological guidance and technical foundations for future practical applications.
Online validation of this emerging advertising format requires not only building a platform that supports shared image generation and auctions, but also recruiting real advertisers and conducting actual advertising campaigns. Such validation cannot be readily achieved through existing platform APIs or historical logs. It requires substantial infrastructure development and commercial partnerships, which are beyond the scope of what we can currently undertake. Therefore, we first focus on establishing and validating the key methods necessary to support this business model.
For Question 1:
Have the authors experimented with any datasets from real advertising platforms?
To evaluate our method on real user requests, we selected 100 prompts suitable for product placement from DiffusionDB. We preserved the original scene descriptions and paired each scene with two contextually relevant branded products. We then generated images using RSC and Share-Conditioned Prompting (SCP) under different target shares and evaluated the monotonic relationship between target shares and CTI.
| Evaluation Setting | Pearson ↑ | Spearman ↑ | Pairwise ↑ | Kendall’s ↑ | Isotonic ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Real user prompts from DiffusionDB (100 prompts) | 0.7406 | 0.7776 | 0.8029 | 0.6300 | 0.8485 |
These results indicate that our method maintains effective share control in test scenarios derived from real user prompts.
Furthermore, when predicting CTI, we asked multiple annotators to provide scores based on their actual willingness to click and evaluated the agreement between model predictions and human ratings, with the results reported in Appendix 3. We therefore validated, to the extent feasible, the alignment between model predictions and human preferences, and evaluated share control using real user prompts.
We hope these explanations can address your concerns and sincerely look forward to your response.
Dear Reviewer Zxxs,
Thank you again for your thoughtful feedback. We would appreciate the opportunity to hear your thoughts on our responses and additional evaluation. To briefly summarize:
- W1: We clarified how RSC intervenes in the diffusion model’s internal computation and highlighted controlled ablations demonstrating its contribution beyond prompting, alongside the reported 1.91–4.58× per-step inference speedup.
- W2 and W3: We explained the methodological scope of our work, discussed the challenges of validating this emerging advertising format on deployed platforms, and clarified the evidence provided by our controlled experiments and human click-intent evaluation.
- Q1: We added an evaluation using 100 real user prompts from DiffusionDB, showing that share control remains effective in these scenarios. It extends our evaluation to scenes derived from real user requests.
We would appreciate your feedback on whether our clarifications and additional evaluation address your main concerns. If any concerns remain, it would be helpful to know which aspects require further discussion so that we can respond more precisely. We hope you will consider this additional evidence when reassessing our work.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Best regards,
The Authors
Thank you for recognizing the clear decomposition of the problem and the incentive guarantees provided by our work. Below, we will address your questions point by point.
For Weakness 1:
We would like to clarify that our generation method involves more than prompt engineering: it also intervenes in the internal computational process of diffusion models. Residual Share Calibration (RSC) decomposes the joint-attention outputs into product-specific residual contributions and normalizes and reweights their magnitudes according to the target exposure shares. This process requires only a single model forward pass per denoising step. Share-Conditioned Prompting (SCP) complements this internal control mechanism by adjusting viewpoints and composition.
Beyond intervening in the generation process, the combination of RSC and SCP provides effective complementary control. RSC is effective at responding to continuous changes in exposure shares and adjusting product exposure accordingly. However, the generated viewpoints remain constrained by the prompts. We therefore introduce SCP, which assigns different prompts to different share configurations, overcoming the limitations imposed by fixed viewpoints on share control.
We conduct controlled ablation studies to distinguish the contributions of RSC from those of prompt-based strategies. With the same SCP configuration, RSC + SCP achieves a Spearman correlation of 0.8346 between target exposure shares and CTI, outperforming the baseline method + SCP (0.7837, Table 2). RSC also outperforms direct residual scaling, achieving a correlation of 0.8346 compared with 0.7705 (Table 12). These results demonstrate that the performance improvements cannot be attributed solely to prompt engineering.
Furthermore, across the evaluated numbers of products, our method achieves 1.91–4.58× faster per-step inference than the baseline (Table 3).
Our contributions also include turning generated images into allocatable auction items and designing corresponding CTI estimation and pricing mechanisms. While prior work has primarily studied auctions in LLM settings, we focus on auctions in image generation and address controllable generation, generation efficiency, CTI estimation, and pricing. We believe these contributions help advance research in this field.