acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Replay the Seeds, Store the Remainder: Compressing Persistent Diffusion Inversion State

Abstract

Inversion-based diffusion editors retain dense stochastic controls to support repeated text-guided edits from a single inversion, imposing severe storage and bandwidth bottlenecks. We observe that a substantial component of each materialized control is deterministically governed by the inversion solver and its generating random draws. Leveraging this insight, we introduce *replay factorization*, a denoiser-free representation that reconstructs an analytical predictor directly from recorded provenance, projects the remainder onto solver-prescribed stochastic carrier directions, and compactly codes the residual defect alongside endpoint and metadata. We formally establish the *stencil-consistency condition* under which explicit source-latent terms vanish, derive exact replay coordinates for first- and second-order stochastic solvers, and generalize the construction to shifted paths and optimized noise. Evaluated on all 700 PIE-Bench tasks across four U-Net configurations (Edit-Friendly and LEDITS++), replay factorization achieves 35.77–47.04% median complete-file savings over optimized generic codecs while preserving edit fidelity (median LPIPS 0.00023–0.0023 to raw-state edits). Without per-source fitting, parameter-free analytical predictors retain the majority of these gains. On the PixArt- diffusion Transformer, our lossy format saves 45.25% storage, while an exact-state variant achieves bitwise input restoration with 14.21% median savings over native-lossless baselines. The exact framework similarly compresses four-step ReNoise and TurboEdit states without loss. By transforming generating provenance into reproducible structure at the decoder, replay factorization substantially reduces persistent editing state without evaluating neural denoisers.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
diffusion models, diffusion inversion, image editing, diffusion solvers, state compression, storage efficiency, error-bounded compression, seed replay, rate-distortion

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_rsmjOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies compression of persistent inversion states for repeated diffusion-based image editing. It regenerates the original random draws from a recorded seed and uses solver coefficients to predict the stored stochastic controls. Rather than storing the full prediction, it stores a compressed residual and the information needed to regenerate the prediction when loading the state. The complete file also includes the endpoint, metadata, boundary rows, and, in the fitted variant, a small number of coefficients. The analysis identifies when explicit source-latent terms cancel and derives predictors for several state-generation procedures. Across 700 PIE-Bench tasks, the method reports 35.77–47.04% median complete-file savings over optimized generic codecs for four U-Net configurations, with small deviations from raw-state edits. An exact-state PixArt variant reports 14.21% savings, and additional studies examine four-step editors and the choice of retained object.

Critical strengths
  1. Substantial additional compression against strong baselines. The reported reductions are relative to optimized generic codecs, with endpoints and metadata included in the complete-file accounting. The tolerance studies, fidelity measurements, and exact-state restoration checks make the storage results considerably more convincing than comparisons against uncompressed tensors alone. Preserving compatibility with the existing editor and the low measured overhead in complete warm queries support the intended repeated-editing use case.

  2. Useful evidence for the role of generating provenance. Analytical predictors retain most of the fitted savings, and comparisons with original-draw regression, unrelated draws, and altered solver alignment help identify where the predictive information comes from. These controls support the proposed explanation of the compression gains, while the exact and shifted-path studies clarify the conditions under which replay can be used.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The workload requiring substantial persistent inversion storage is insufficiently characterized. Reusing an inversion avoids repeated computation, and the additional 35.77–47.04% reduction over generic compression is a demonstrated storage benefit with small measured warm-query overhead. The open question is how many source-specific states need to remain cached, for how long, and how often they are reused. If a source is edited once or explored only briefly, its state can be discarded after the session; substantial persistent storage then depends on the number and lifetime of retained assets rather than merely on the existence of inversion-based editing. The introductory EF/SD1.5 example saves approximately 0.69 MB per asset over generic compression. The three-prompt experiments validate reuse of a state but do not characterize actual reuse frequency or retention requirements. A representative workload model incorporating these factors and an expiration or eviction policy would make the claimed severe storage and bandwidth bottleneck more convincing. This concern does not dispute the compression gains or require a latency improvement.

  2. The methodological advance appears limited. The central idea is to replay the random draws used to generate the state, construct a predictor using solver coefficients, and compress the difference between the predictor and the actual state. The source-cancellation condition follows by substituting the auxiliary path into the affine solver update and comparing coefficients of the source latent. The analytical predictors for EF and LEDITS++ are constructed by replacing model noise predictions in this expansion with the draws used to generate the auxiliary path. The fitted variant uses standard least-squares regression on solver-selected draws to approximate the remainder after subtracting the replayable skeleton, and the final residual is compressed with existing tensor codecs. I recognize the useful observation that the generating draws provide an effective predictor, as well as the demonstrated compression gains. However, the method primarily uses state-generation information to construct a predictor within the established predictive residual coding framework, and I find the resulting methodological advance insufficiently substantial.

Questions for authors
  1. Clarification of the target workload: Can the authors provide a representative workload model specifying how many source-specific inversion states remain cached, their retention times, the frequency of subsequent edits from the same source, and an expiration or eviction policy? In that setting, how much storage or transfer pressure does factorization remove beyond generic compression? Please distinguish reuse of one original source from successive edits that treat the preceding output as a new source. A quantitative example would suffice; the benefit of inversion reuse and the small warm-query overhead are already established.
Reviewer_V43gOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

TL;DR: “We compressed something because it was technically compressible, but didn't bother considering if anyone’s actual system was bottlenecked by it.”

Diffusion inversion has been around for a while, since it promises reproducible edits to real, as well as generated, source images. Although, broadly, the inversion is an unsolved problem, and it would great to get a robust solution for Diffusion inversion, instead this paper proposes a method (not for inverting diffusion, but) for compressing the generation-state output by diffusion inversion methods. This largely includes the source noise that generated the image in the first place, and method dependent stepwise corrections, RNG internals, etc.

The proposed approach to doing this can be summarized as: For each generation timestep,

  1. Regenerate a small set of known noise tensors
  2. Fit one or two scalar coefficients using ordinary least squares
  3. Compute the remaining prediction error (called Defect by the authors)
  4. Instead of storing full tensors per timestep, store: coefficients, small residual sparse tensors compressed in a lossy manner, exceptional boundary rows, than can't be compressed in residuals, and replay metadata (actual timesteps etc.)

Yes, right, this does sound outdated, because the authors actually use the older DDPM models for inversion, from two-three years ago; and not the SOTA Flow-Matching models.

Critical strengths

In spite of being heavily AI written (hallucinated), this paper interestingly gives more details than the some of the (ai generated) papers that I am reviewing. This helps clearly convey why the paper should be rejected.

Critical weaknesses
  1. As alluded to in the summary, the main problem of the paper is: it neither considers, nor demonstrates exactly which real-world systems are actually bottlenecked by the inversion states. To the best of my knowledge, due to not being fully robust (optimization based inversion being slow), inversion is not really being used heavily in the industry for Generative Image editing workflows. Modern consumer products increasingly use: instruction-tuned editors, inpainting, ControlNet-like conditioning, Flux editing variants, and proprietary editing pipelines. So, without this paper duly and diligently showing where the states of the inverted generations/real images are actually a bottleneck, it's impossible to gauge and evaluate the utility of the proposed approach.

  2. Okay, even if we assume for a moment, as in 1, that this is a relevant problem, and that we should care about it, the numbers that the authors quote in introduction (Line 45 - 46) point otherwise. On an average, the raw state of their representative baseline EF [1], which they build their compression on top of, is 4.3MB. I do not see which modern day hardware (including hand-held mobile devices) can struggle to hold these asset-sizes. The raw images clicked by digital cameras can be well over 100s of MB. Also, as the authors mention that generic codecs can compress this size down to 1.46MB losslessly.

  3. Apart from these glaring positioning issues, and unjustified motivation of the paper, there are problems with the experiments: These are described as follows: a. Why is LPIPS being used as the comparison metric? This problem is certainly more "signal-preservation" than semantics preservation. LPIPS should probably be included, but PSNR/SSIM are the missing first-class metrics here. b. Practical gain is unclear. The key question is not how much storage is saved relative to the raw state, but how much additional storage is saved beyond what strong off-the-shelf lossless compressors already achieve. Without these results in the main table, the incremental benefit of the proposed representation is difficult to assess. Also it looks like their worst performance comes on the newer SOTA DiT based PixArt-α\alpha model. c. Missing generic-compression baseline. Table 1 reports savings only relative to the raw uncompressed state, even though the paper previously states that a "best generic codec" already reduces EF/SD1.5 assets substantially (4.3 MB → 1.46 MB). Including standard codecs such as ZIP/DEFLATE, GZIP, Zstandard (zstd), Brotli, and LZMA/XZ in Table 1 would provide a more meaningful baseline.

  4. It's good that the authors have provided qualitative samples in the supplementary, unlike other papers I am reviewing, this really helps point out biggest limitations of the proposed approach. For instance, fig. 10 second last example of the woman holding the umbrella. As we can notice, the reconstructed edit does not reproduce the smile, and even worse the identity, of the woman. In my opinion this error is a cardinal sin for a paper as niche as this. There are various other subtle issues in rest of the examples as well, but perhaps this one is the most prominent and most easily noticeable. Given no guarantees of reproducible edits, the complexity, and the need of the proposed paper is not justified.

References: [1] Huberman-Spiegelglas, I., Kulikov, V., & Michaeli, T. (2024, June). An edit friendly ddpm noise space: Inversion and manipulations. In 2024 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR) (pp. 12469-12478). IEEE.

Justification: This paper is not just a sloppy work, but totally unjustified in any scientific sense. I do not believe the authors have invested efforts in understanding this line of research and grounding a motivation for solving an impactful problem. Accepting this paper will set a very wrong precedent in the research community, and that is why I propose a rejection.

Questions for authors

None

Reviewer_iTbsOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the problem of compressing persistent diffusion inversion states for repeated image editing. The authors propose replay factorization, which uses the original random seeds and diffusion solver structure to reconstruct predictable components of the stored controls, projects the remaining information onto solver-prescribed noise directions, and compresses the residuals. The method does not require denoiser evaluations during decoding or modifications to the downstream editor. The paper derives the conditions for source-latent cancellation and extends the approach to different stochastic solvers and editing methods. Experiments on PIE-Bench across several diffusion editors and model architectures show substantial storage savings over generic compression methods while largely preserving editing fidelity. Additional analyses examine the role of generating noise, exact-state reconstruction, generalization across datasets, and the cost of reusing compressed states.

Critical strengths
  1. A well-motivated approach with clear technical reasoning. The paper identifies reproducible structure in diffusion inversion states and uses the solver equations to derive a compact representation. The source-cancellation analysis and solver-specific predictors provide a clear explanation of why the approach works, rather than relying only on empirical compression results.

  2. Consistent storage savings with reasonably thorough experimental validation. The method achieves substantial reductions in complete-file size over optimized generic codecs across multiple editors and model architectures. The experiments also examine editing fidelity, analytical versus fitted predictors, and original versus unrelated random draws. These results support the effectiveness of the proposed representation and help explain where the compression gains come from.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The technical novelty is somewhat limited. The overall approach follows a familiar predictive coding framework, combining analytically derived predictors, linear projection, and residual compression using existing codecs. While the solver-specific derivations are useful, the main contribution lies in adapting these techniques to diffusion inversion states.

  2. The practical benefits of the proposed framework appear to be editor-dependent. The method relies on solver-specific structures and may require additional derivations to support different inversion methods. Moreover, the TurboEdit experiments show that simply caching the source latent and seed is substantially more storage-efficient than retaining the factorized state, with nearly identical query latency. While replay factorization provides clear storage benefits for other evaluated editors, clearer criteria are needed to determine when the proposed representation offers meaningful advantages over simpler reusable states.

Questions for authors
  1. What are the main limitations of extending replay factorization to inversion methods with solver structures beyond those evaluated?

  2. When is storing factorized inversion states more beneficial than simply caching the source latent and seed?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.