- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
PaRDi studies content preservation and repeated revision in discrete image editing. It adapts pretrained model using LoRA and a time-conditioning module, starting editing directly from the source token canvas. The method constructs a MASK-hub Markov process and conditions it on source–target endpoints to derive intermediate training states and transition supervision, while assigning constant paths to unchanged positions. The model predicts target-token probabilities, which an analytic mapping converts into keep, remask, and reveal transitions. Experiments evaluate image editing, background preservation, and visual reasoning.
Critical strengths
The paper unifies intermediate training states, transition supervision, and inference rules within a single bridge process, forming a coherent methodological contribution. Ablations of transition structure, state construction, and training objectives under shared training settings, together with revision-budget experiments under a fixed update schedule, provide useful evidence for the individual components. The appendix also visualizes actual revision actions and sampling trajectories, helping explain how the model progressively modifies the source canvas.
Critical weaknesses
-
The ImgEdit training subset, benchmark exclusions, and deduplication procedure are unspecified, leaving evaluation independence unclear.
-
The fraction of residual MASK tokens and the effect of terminal completion—which excludes source tokens—on editing quality and preservation are not reported.
Questions for authors
-
The training–evaluation data split is insufficiently documented. The paper trains on ImgEdit and evaluates on ImgEdit-Bench Basic, but does not specify the exact training subset, benchmark exclusions, or deduplication procedure. These details are needed to confirm evaluation independence; there is currently no evidence of data leakage.
-
The impact of terminal completion is unclear. After 30 updates, the method fills remaining MASK tokens while excluding the original source token at each position. However, the proportion of tokens requiring completion and its effect on the results are not reported. Please quantify this proportion and clarify whether the rule affects editing quality and background preservation.
3 comments
I thank the authors for their detailed response, which has satisfactorily addressed my concerns.
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for revisiting our response and confirming that your concerns have been satisfactorily addressed. We appreciate your recognition of PaRDi’s unified derivation of training states, transition supervision, and inference rules, supported by controlled ablations.
Your feedback helped us clarify our use of the full publicly released ImgEdit training set and official benchmarks to support reproducible evaluation. The additional audit supports training–evaluation independence, while the completion experiments show stable editing quality and content preservation across completion settings. We will incorporate these details and analyses into the final manuscript.
Thank you again for your careful evaluation and constructive feedback.
Best regards,
The Authors
Authors' Response to Reviewer 7Wwv
Thank you for recognizing the coherent unification of training states, transition supervision, and inference rules, as well as the controlled ablations and sampling visualizations. We address the two documentation gaps with explicit data-use details, an image-overlap audit, and direct terminal-completion experiments.
To ensure reproducibility, we train on the full publicly released ImgEdit training set and evaluate on the official ImgEdit-Bench Basic, reported as ImgEdit-Bench in the original ImgEdit paper's main results table.
ImgEdit [1] appeared in the NeurIPS 2025 Datasets and Benchmarks Track.
Sections 3.2 and 4.1describe the construction of its official training set and benchmark. We follow the official training/evaluation separation without additional benchmark-specific deduplication.We further audited image overlap using the publicly available, widely used Python ImageHash library. No duplicates were detected under the pixel-SHA or pHash-distance ≤4 checks. We compared source and raw target images from the ImgEdit training set against the original source images of ImgEdit-Bench, GEdit-EN, and PIE-Bench. Exact matching uses the Secure Hash Algorithm (SHA) on pixel data obtained using a consistent decoding procedure and on image dimensions; perceptual hashing (pHash) screens image similarity.
Even under permissive crop-hash screening, ImgEdit-Bench has a candidate-match rate comparable to those of GEdit-EN and PIE.
[1] Ye et al., ImgEdit, NeurIPS Datasets and Benchmarks Track (2025).
After 30 updates, residual MASK tokens account for 2.4385% of all image tokens pooled across GEdit, ImgEdit, and PIE. Allowing source tokens in terminal completion, or continuing until no MASK remains, yields editing quality and background preservation close to the original method.
We use a fixed 30 steps to enable fair comparisons under a common inference budget. Terminal completion fills only the remaining MASK positions, selecting the highest-probability token after excluding MASK and the position's original source value.
Continuing to sample until no MASK remains provides no clear performance gain but requires more sampling steps.
When source values are allowed, substantially more source-valued completions occur in the editing region than in the non-editing region. We therefore exclude both MASK and source values, rather than MASK alone, to favor editing at residual positions. Both columns pool token counts across PIE samples and divide by the total number of image tokens:
We use the full official ImgEdit training set and evaluate on official ImgEdit-Bench; our audit finds no pixel-exact or pHash-distance ≤4 matches. See
response to R 7Wwv W1for the official split, evaluation scope, and audit results.The completion fraction is 2.4385% across the three benchmarks; allowing source tokens in terminal completion or continuing sampling until no MASK remains yields aggregate scores close to the original method. Please see
response to R 7Wwv W2for the exact denominator, PIE region breakdown, and editing/preservation comparisons.