- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses editing with coarse masks through global and local branches. It learns binary gates that switch the coordinates of local tokens between two sets of positional encodings. The method is implemented on Qwen and FLUX.2 and evaluated for local generation quality, background preservation, and performance across benchmarks.
Critical strengths
Using positional encoding routing to coordinate local generation and background blending is a design worth investigating. Comparisons using the same backbone support the benefits of gating for local quality, and some coarse-mask editing examples demonstrate natural object shapes and integration with the surrounding scene.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper attributes its gains to mitigating “mask shape bias,” but the default pipeline first converts the mask into a bounding box, already removing the original contour information. Table 4 supports the benefits of gating for generation quality, and Appendix G.6 demonstrates adaptability to mask variations. However, these results do not sufficiently distinguish the respective contributions of bounding-box preprocessing and gating to mitigating shape bias.
- The main FLUX.2 comparisons use rewritten prompts, while the baseline scores come from the original evaluation. The rewriting process also accesses the source image, mask, and reference image, potentially affecting task difficulty. Particularly when the reported margins are small, the differences cannot be directly attributed to BRIDGE.
Questions for authors
Do the main improvements persist when prompts and input processing are matched? Which specific shape errors that remain after bounding-box preprocessing does the gating mechanism correct?
EMU3.5 is not a mask edit model
Although Emu3.5 scores slightly higher on BRIDGE's five trained task types (0.6104 vs. 0.6080), it does not reliably constrain edits to the supplied mask in our evaluation.
FLUX.2 Base [2] has no mask input and received none in our test. The evaluated official Emu3.5 [10] scripts also provide no dedicated mask-input procedure. We therefore supplied the mask as an additional image alongside the source image and optional subject reference. We appended a single sentence to the original rewritten prompt: "Picture 2 is the mask" or, when a subject reference was included, "Picture 3 is the mask." We then passed this augmented prompt and the input images to Emu3.5.
Full ICE-Bench task scores ↑. We report the recorded scores for all nine tasks (1,976 examples), including subject removal and tasks absent from BRIDGE's training. The mean gives equal weight to Tasks 19, 21, 22, 29, and 30 (805 examples). LB denotes latent blending [9]; ACE++ [12] uses rewritten prompts.
Emu3.5 exceeds BRIDGE Sparse by 0.00246 (0.40%) on this five-task mean. Unmasked Base also scores higher. Task scores alone therefore do not establish mask control.
Background preservation and edit localization: equal means over the same five tasks. Background L1 is the mean smoothed RGB difference outside the target mask on a common grid, normalized by 255.
Despite receiving a mask, Emu3.5 has IoU close to unmasked Base (0.3330 vs. 0.3190), with more outside-mask changed area (11.82% vs. 7.07%) and higher background L1 (0.04793 vs. 0.03278). For subject addition, only 36.19% of Emu3.5's detected changes lie inside the mask, versus 91.10% for BRIDGE. A mask editor must control where content is generated and reduce edits outside the requested region. The tested Emu3.5 interface does not meet this requirement reliably.
Relative to Emu3.5, BRIDGE improves IoU by 41.7%, reduces outside-mask changed area by 97.1%, and lowers background L1 by 78.3%.
How we extract the edit masks. Target masks are ICE-Bench annotations [1]. We adapt SR-Edit's region-identification pipeline (ECCV 2026) [11]: align source and output to a common grid (longest side at most 512 pixels), compute mean absolute RGB differences, apply Gaussian smoothing, threshold at 16/255, perform morphological opening/closing, and remove small connected components. We retain all remaining components, including those outside the target mask. Our fixed threshold replaces SR-Edit's Otsu threshold. These are detected change regions, not semantic object masks. Inside fractions exclude empty detections; IoU counts them as zero.
References
[1] Pan et al. ICE-Bench: A Unified and Comprehensive Benchmark for Image Creating and Editing. ICCV, 2025.
[2] Black Forest Labs. FLUX.2 [klein] 9B Base Model Card. 2026.
[9] Avrahami, Fried, and Lischinski. Blended Latent Diffusion. ACM Transactions on Graphics, 2023.
[10] Cui et al. Emu3.5: Native Multimodal Models are World Learners. 2025.
[11] Wang, Chen, Jiang, and Zhu. SR-Edit: Region-Aware Image Editing via Self-Refinement. ECCV, 2026, pp. 226-244.
[12] Mao et al. ACE++: Instruction-Based Image Creation and Editing via Context-Aware Content Filling. ICCV Workshops, 2025.