- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper tries to solve the text-based image editing task and proposes EditGRN that leverages the external GRN (Generative Refinement Networks) to refine the sampling process by mitigating the trajectory inconsistency. The experimental results with extensive ablatioons support its effectiveness for this task.
Critical strengths
- This paper shows significant improvement in both user-provided and attention-derived mask settings.
- Ablations across Synchronized Corruption Schedule, Protected Region Writeback, Synchronized Reference, Trajectory-Decoupled Source, and Initial Retention Ratio support the method design with more mechanistic analysis.
- External refinement incorporation is new in this area and aligns quite well with the recent hot agent tool style.
Critical weaknesses
- Lack of implementation details for baseline reproductions. For example, in Table 1, FlowEdit shows non-competitive performance compared with most methods. However, from the community's experience, FlowEdit is a strong baseline and usually shows at least competitive performance in most of the text-based image editing datasets. Moreover, FlowEdit does not provide results on PIE-Bench; thus, a reproduction implementation is more important to ensure the comparisons are fair.
- Lack of ablation on GRN models.
- The external, pretrained GRN incorporation looks like an engineering trick, while it serves as an inconsistency mitigation tool, making the method show limited generalization.
Questions for authors
- The GRN ablations and baselines reproduction problems are quite important for this submission; please add an explanation and discussion of these two parts.
- An external tool can be incorporated; what's the advantage of this image editing method compared with instruction-based VLM editing models like Qwen-Image?