- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MatchEdit, a training-free and inversion-free image editing method built on pretrained flow models. Through a controlled state-prompt decomposition, this paper analyzes how state-prompt changes affect the conventional FlowEdit direction. MatchEdit combines prompt contrasts evaluated at matched states and introduces spatially adaptive, bounded target guidance to balance source preservation and editing strength. Experiments on PIE-Bench, DNA-Bench, and MSE-Bench show promising results.
Critical strengths
-
The controlled state-prompt analysis provides useful insights into how the additive state effect influences semantic alignment, source preservation, and spatial selectivity of inversion-free image editing.
-
The method shows consistently strong source preservation with competitive semantic alignment across PIE-Bench, DNA-Bench, and sequential multi-turn editing on MSE-Bench.
Critical weaknesses
-
The technical contribution is not clearly distinguished from prior work. WSSC [1], CVC [2], and FlowSlider [3] have similar matched-state prompt comparisons or velocity decompositions. Experimental comparisons with WSSC and CVC are missing, while FlowSlider should at least be discussed. These comparisons and a more explicit related-work discussion are necessary to clarify MatchEdit’s novelty.
-
The connection between the analysis in Section 4 and the design in Section 5 is not fully convincing. The analysis shows that the state effect contributes to the preservation-editability trade-off. However, it does not establish why this component should be removed entirely from the base direction rather than selectively retained through a spatial gate. The subsequent choice to recover editing strength using target CFG is also insufficiently motivated.
-
The experiments are limited to SD3.5. It is unclear whether the state-prompt analysis and editing improvements also hold on other backbones, such as FLUX. This is important for establishing whether the findings generalize across flow models or depend on the tested backbone.
[1] Wavelet-Guided Semantic Signal Compensation for Inversion-Free Image Editing. ECCV 2026.
[2] On Exact Editing of Flow-Based Diffusion Models. arXiv 2025.
[3] FlowSlider: Training-Free Continuous Image Editing via Fidelity-Steering Decomposition. arXiv 2026.
Questions for authors
-
MatchEdit requires additional velocity predictions, but Table 9 reports only a small runtime increase over FlowEdit (5.28 vs. 5.63 seconds). How are model evaluations counted, and are the sampling and timing settings consistent across methods?
-
What is the purpose of the additional term in Eq. 19? This term is absent from the standard FlowEdit update. Is it also included in the baseline and ablation experiments?
6 comments
Thank you again for your thoughtful and insightful comments. We understand the considerable time and effort involved in the reviewing process and sincerely appreciate your constructive suggestions.
Following your suggestions, we have:
- clarified the differences in technical approaches from concurrent works
- explained the exclusion of the state effect and evaluated its spatially gated alternative
- extended MatchEdit to FLUX
- re-evaluated the computational cost and corrected the corresponding results
- examined the effect of the term in Eq. (19)
Given the limited rebuttal period, we sincerely hope to have further discussions if you have any remaining questions or concerns. We would greatly appreciate any further feedback you may have, as it would help us further improve our work.
Thank you again for your time and valuable feedback.
Thank you for the responses. My concerns about excluding the state effect and using target CFG, generalization to FLUX, and the additional noise term have been addressed.
The corrected timings and the fewer-step experiments provided to Reviewer EWp9 clarify the computational cost and show a reasonable efficiency–quality trade-off. However, the original timing error still affects my confidence in the experimental evaluation, particularly since runtime close to FlowEdit was identified as a strength by another reviewer zStQ.
My main concern remains the novelty and comparison with prior work. The key question is whether WSSC and CVC already use matched-state prompt comparisons or separate state and prompt changes, and what new conclusions or insights MatchEdit provides beyond them. Pointing to differences in subsequent compensation or correction modules does not sufficiently answer this question.
The WSSC comparison does not establish a clear overall advantage. WSSC achieves higher CLIP scores and better LPIPS and SSIM, while MatchEdit improves Structure, PSNR, and MSE. The better average rank depends on the baseline set and the resulting rank gaps, and does not resolve this preservation–alignment trade-off. Under the same criterion, CVC’s reported FLUX results would also be favored on the shared metrics, with better scores on all reported source-preservation metrics. The additional experiments addressing W2 and W3 are more convincing because they improve preservation while maintaining or improving semantic alignment.
Response to Reviewer HTh8
Thank you for recognizing (i) the insightful state-prompt analysis and (ii) competitive performance across benchmarks. Our responses are provided below.
W1: Distinction with concurrent work
A1: Thank you for bringing these concurrent works to our attention. Upon careful examination, we find that WSSC (ECCV, 2026), CVC (arXiv, 2025), and FlowSlider (arXiv, 2026) follow different technical approaches from MatchEdit. In particular,
We will cite these concurrent works and discuss them in the revision.
We emphasis that different from these concurrent work, MatchEdit is theoretically grounded with our state-prompt decomposition.
We added WSSC's reported SD3.5 results to the PIE-Bench main table. MatchEdit achieves better overall performance.
W2: Excluding the State Effect and Choosing Target CFG over Spatially Gated State Effect
A2: Although the State Effect enhances target semantics, its global inclusion in the base direction introduces a prompt-independent shift. This can cause excessive changes in non-target regions. We therefore exclude the explicit State Effect while retaining state–prompt interactions.
We compared spatially gated State Effect with Target CFG on all 700 PIE-Bench images. Our Target CFG reduces Structure by 40.8% and reduces LPIPS by 20.5%, with minimal changes in CLIP Whole and CLIP Edited (26.058 → 26.029; 22.722 → 22.710).
These results show that spatially gated State Effect still introduces greater background changes than Target CFG.
W3: Generalize to FLUX
A3: We extended MatchEdit to FLUX.1-dev and evaluated it on all 700 PIE-Bench samples. Results are reported below.
Q1: Computational Cost
A1: Thanks for your helpful feedback. We apologize that, due to an oversight before the deadline, our original timing protocol was inconsistent. We re-run all methods using a consistent protocol. Runtime covers the full per-image pipeline of each method. We updated the manuscript and will release the code for reproducibility.
Q2: Purpose of τiϵi in Eq. (19)
A2: We initially adopted the term from FIA-Edit in our implementation. It introduces a noise-dependent perturbation into the Euler update. It was consistently included in all ablations. We evaluated its effect on all 700 PIE-Bench images by removing only this term, with other settings unchanged. Interestingly, the results show minor changes: Structure Distance (0.007445→0.007041), MSE (0.001914→0.001821), and SSIM (0.903189→0.909547), while changing Edited CLIP by only 0.011. Thus, this term is nonessential to MatchEdit's performance, and can be removed.