- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces GRAPE, a training-free and inversion-free editing method, a method that improves FlowEdit by combining gradient-aligned field that evaluates the source and target branches of the current edit state at a shared noisy observation, which is proportional to the target-to-source log-density-ratio gradient. The paper also proposes progress adaptive integration, which compensates the mismatch between noise-schedule progression and clean-state progress. The method is evaluated on 3 different backbones on the PIE-Bench dataset, and demonstrates that they achieve a better source-alignment and text-adherence tradeoff, under reduced inference budget.
Critical strengths
- The paper is written clearly.
- The qualitative results are quite impressive and emphasize the method's ability to edit only the intended areas.
- Extensive ablations have been conducted.
Critical weaknesses
- Comparison against non-inversion-free methods is missing, such as FireFlow [1] and UniEdit [2], as well as against inversion-free methods such as FlowCycle [3].
- A user study is missing.
- The qualitative comparisons seem to be compressed and have artifacts, for example the cat -> tiger example (3rd row) in Figure 6.
- Evaluations on datasets with higher dimensions, such as provided by FlowEdit to show that the method and hyperparameters are robust to other dimensions as well would be beneficial.
- As demonstrated in the FlowEdit paper, as is closer to , the less fidelity to the source image. It would be beneficial to assess the method’s ability to preserve the source even with higher value which is close to to achieve more difficult edits, such as style transfer, changes in color palette, etc.
Minor Issues
- The caption of Figure 3 is not clear - please describe it in more detail.
- In Eq. 8 the motivation is not clear why replacing the unknown with and not with the estimated .
- In the related work non-inversion methods is missing, e.g. FlowOpt [4] and SONIC [5].
Final Note
Despite these weaknesses, I find the paper overall good. I would be willing to raise my score if the authors address my concerns.
[1] Deng, Yingying, et al. "Fireflow: Fast inversion of rectified flow for image semantic editing." (ICML’25)
[2] Jiao, Guanlong, et al. "Uniedit-flow: Unleashing inversion and editing in the era of flow models." (ICLR’26)
[3] Wang, Yanghao, et al. "FlowCycle: Target-Aware Image Editing via Cycle-Consistent Constraints." (ECCV’26)
[4] Ronai, Or, et al. "FlowOpt: Fast Optimization Through Whole Flow Processes for Training-Free Editing." (arXiv’25)
[5] Baek, Seungyeon, et al. "SONIC: spectral optimization of noise for inpainting with consistency." (ECCV'26)
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
3 comments
I appreciate the authors detailed response and clarifications, which resolved my concerns. I'm quite positive about this paper, therefore I'd raise my score to Weak Acceptance.
Thank you for the response
Thank you for following up. We are glad that our response addressed your concerns. Your suggestions on additional baselines and robustness tests helped us strengthen the evaluation and clarify where the method works well.
Response to Reviewer oKuY
We appreciate the reviewer's constructive feedback. The suggestions helped us strengthen the empirical evidence through additional method comparisons, a human preference study, higher-resolution evaluation, and experiments with higher starting noise levels.
1. Additional methods (W1)
We evaluated FireFlow, UniEdit-Flow, and FlowCycle on all 700 PIE-Bench examples using settings supported by their official implementations. We include GRAPE at comparable inference budgets and report CLIP-T explicitly, since matching NFE does not necessarily match editing strength. SD is in units of 10−3.
On SD3, GRAPE achieves higher CLIP-T and lower SD than UniEdit-Flow at similar NFE. FlowCycle's official configuration requires 13,398 evaluations, so this is not an NFE-matched comparison. On FLUX at 18 NFE, GRAPE achieves higher CLIP-T and lower SD than FireFlow. At 28 NFE, GRAPE has 0.39 higher CLIP-T and higher EditHF preservation and visual-quality scores than UniEdit-Flow, but 1.34 higher SD. This does not establish a preservation ranking at matched editing strength. Appendix E.3 and Tables 10–11 report the additional metrics and configurations.
2. Human evaluation (W2)
Twenty-one non-author participants each assessed 20 anonymized pairs, yielding 420 judgments. They viewed the source image, instruction, and two outputs, and selected the result that better performs the requested edit while preserving unrelated content, or "Not sure." Cases were selected with method identities hidden and restricted to those for which all compared methods received a VLM instruction-following score of at least 4.
Overall, 70.5% of responses preferred GRAPE, 17.9% preferred the baseline, and 11.7% were neutral. GRAPE preference rates were 72.4% against FlowEdit, 57.1% against FlowAlign, and 76.2% against both DRFS and DNAEdit. Section 4.2 describes the protocol, and Figure 7 reports the distributions including neutral responses.
3. Figure 6 image quality (W3)
We inspected the original outputs for the cat-to-tiger example but could not identify the specific artifact mentioned. To preserve image quality in the PDF, we reconstructed Figure 6 from the original outputs and inserted it as a high-resolution PNG. If a particular region remains problematic in the revised figure, we would appreciate clarification so that we can inspect it directly.
4. Higher-resolution evaluation (W4)
We evaluated the unmodified real-image benchmark released by FlowEdit, containing 77 images and 280 prompt pairs at 1024×1024. We retained the SD3 editing settings used for PIE-Bench and selected target CFG to obtain similar CLIP-T. Since masks are unavailable, preservation metrics use the full image. SD and LPIPS are in units of 10−3, and SSIM is multiplied by 100.
GRAPE achieves the lowest SD and LPIPS and the highest PSNR, while FlowAlign has slightly higher SSIM. DNAEdit has lower CLIP-T at the reported operating point. Section 4.2 and Figure 8 present the guidance-sweep comparisons, and Figure 24 provides qualitative examples.
5. Higher starting noise levels (W5)
On SD3, we fixed T=50 and increased nmax from 33 to 50. The table reports selected operating points, with CLIP-T shown to make differences in editing strength explicit. SD is in units of 10−3.
GRAPE has lower SD with comparable or higher CLIP-T at every reported setting. At nmax=T=50, CLIP-T is nearly identical, yet SD is 85.60 for FlowEdit and 19.12 for GRAPE. Appendix E.4 and Table 12 report this analysis.
6. Other revisions
We expanded Figure 3's caption to explain the progress measure and normalization. We clarified Eq. (8) by distinguishing the unknown target endpoint xtgt from its estimate xtgt,i and using the latter to construct the progress reference. We also added FlowOpt and SONIC to Related Work in Appendix A.