- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a mask-guided framework for regional image editing. It incorporates regional constraints into the probability path and training loss, and uses Poisson blending during sampling to refine boundaries. Experiments cover natural scenes and infographics, with evaluations on two backbone models.
Critical strengths
The method specifically addresses three practical challenges: localization, background preservation, and boundary continuity. Comparisons using the same data and number of training steps, together with consistent gains across two backbones, support the effectiveness of the overall method.
Critical weaknesses
Seamless blending is a central contribution, but the quantitative experiments do not directly evaluate boundary continuity. Figure 6 provides qualitative support, whereas the CLIP and FID scores in Table 2 cannot establish whether textures and lines connect naturally across boundaries. The nearly perfect background preservation scores also partly reflect explicit restoration of the source image. Consequently, the benefits of boundary blending and background restoration remain insufficiently distinguished.
Questions for authors
Which existing results distinguish SPD’s improvement in boundary blending from the effects of simply restoring the background?
Boundary Continuity Evaluation of SPD
Thanks for the suggestions and questions.
W1&Q1: We apologize for the lack of quantitative results for SPD improvement and we supplement it in paper Section 5.2 Table 3. SPD refines the boundary during training and inference to maintain train-test consistency by solving the mask-aware Poisson equation. Figure 6 provides a qualitative comparison of the finetuned baseline, MaskFlow w/o SPD, and the full model. The comparison between MaskFlow w/o SPD and the full model directly illustrates the incremental effect of SPD on boundary continuity. To evaluate the quantitative results, we supplement BDS[1] metric to evaluate the boundary continuity, which quantifies boundary discontinuity between inner and outer transition bands of the masked region. Here we present the results, where lower BDS value supports better continuity.
The results show that MaskFlow obtains the lowest BDS, which supports the contribution of SPD method. We supplement the results in paper Section 5.2 Table 3 and will claim the contribution more clearly.
References:
[1] Liu, Delong, et al. "Inter-Edit: First Benchmark for Interactive Instruction-Based Image Editing." Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. 2026.