- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Inversion-based image editing consists of inversion and denoising stages, both of which require many network evaluations. Existing caching methods typically handle these stages separately, without jointly optimizing their shared computational budget, potentially leading to inefficient resource allocation. This paper proposes DARTCache, a training-free framework for jointly planning caching across both stages. It extends conventional single-stage caching optimization to joint computational resource planning, using a unified metric to determine both when to refresh cached features and how many network evaluations to allocate to each stage. Among the acceleration methods evaluated, the results demonstrate a favorable trade-off between efficiency and fidelity. The paper further validates its applicability to U-Net-based editing frameworks.
Critical strengths
The method requires neither image-quality evaluation through replay for each candidate nor an online predictor. The calibration curves computed on the given test dataset provide a good balance between quality and speed.
Critical weaknesses
Generalizability remains insufficiently validated. Although the paper reports that the calibration curves remain relatively stable as coverage varies across the 700 test cases, this does not establish what regularities govern these curves. Their behavior across different models and datasets has not been verified.
Questions for authors
Could you provide more evidence supporting generalizability?
3 comments
Response to Reviewer 7zpq(Part 1/2): Temporal Regularities and TVE Predictiveness
We thank the reviewer for highlighting the need to characterize temporal variation regularities beyond calibration-coverage stability. We conduct new experiments on MagicBrush, additional profile and objective-ranking analyses on SD1.5-based U-Net editors, and revisit the U-Net component ablations reported in our original submission. Together, these experiments examine temporal variation structure, TVE predictiveness, and practical planning effectiveness across datasets and editing frameworks.
1. Temporal Variation Regularities Across Datasets and Editing Frameworks
Cross-dataset consistency. We independently extract temporal variation profiles from PIE-Bench (70 calibration cases) and MagicBrush (50 cases) using FLUX.1-dev with RF-Inversion. The stage-normalized profiles exhibit high Spearman correlations of 0.9515 (inversion) and 0.9719 (denoising). Their denoising-to-inversion variation ratios are also similar (3.98 vs. 3.84), with both independently selecting a 6/14 allocation at .
Cross-framework characteristics. We further analyze archived 10-case calibration profiles from four editing configurations: FLUX.1-dev with RF-Inversion/OT-RF and SD1.5 U-Net with MasaCtrl/EDICT. Even within the same backbone, different editing pipelines exhibit substantially different temporal profiles. For example, the inversion-profile correlation between MasaCtrl and EDICT is −0.5738, while the denoising-profile correlation between RF-Inversion and OT-RF is −0.0353. Nevertheless, across all four configurations, the highest-variation 20% of intervals account for approximately 36%–58% of total variation.
These descriptive results reveal a common empirical property: temporal variation is strongly nonuniform, while its detailed structure is host-dependent. DARTCache therefore does not assume a universal temporal profile, but instead adapts its planning decisions through host-specific calibration.
2. Cross-Dataset and Cross-Architecture TVE Objective Validation
To investigate whether TVE remains predictive of actual caching degradation, we extend our original objective-ranking evaluation to 200 candidate schedules on 50 held-out MagicBrush edits and 30 schedules on 30 SD1.5/EDICT cases. Both experiments use independently calibrated profiles and fixed stage allocations (10/10 and 15/17, respectively), isolating refresh-placement ranking.
Table R2-1: Spearman correlation between offline objectives and empirical LPIPS degradation.
| Objective | PIE-Bench | MagicBrush | SD1.5 / EDICT |
|---|---|---|---|
| Endpoint | 0.6433 | 0.5355 | 0.6609 |
| Integrated | 0.7695 | 0.7266 | 0.7070 |
| Lexi-Minimax | 0.9316 | 0.6428 | 0.4843 |
| Quadratic TVE | 0.9637 | 0.8624 | 0.8061 |
Quadratic TVE achieves the highest observed correlation among the four objectives in all three settings. It also yields the lowest Top-1 LPIPS regret on MagicBrush (0.0094) and EDICT (0.00307).
On EDICT, Quadratic TVE achieves a correlation of 0.8061 (95% CI [0.7374, 0.8661]), compared with 0.7070 [0.6209, 0.7722] for Integrated. We report this as an observed advantage rather than a statistically established superiority.
Since candidate pools and evaluation sizes differ across settings, these correlations demonstrate within-setting predictive usefulness, rather than a controlled comparison of architecture-induced differences. Importantly, the original Quadratic TVE objective retains substantial schedule-ranking ability despite different datasets and temporal profile structures.
Response to Reviewer 7zpq (Part 2/2): Planning Effectiveness and Schedule Transfer
3. Generalization of TVE Allocation and Refresh Placement
We further examine whether these scheduling signals translate into practical fidelity improvements across editing frameworks.
Cross-dataset ablation. On MagicBrush, we evaluate 450 session-disjoint held-out edits using FLUX.1-dev with RF-Inversion and OT-RF, independently calibrated on 50 cases. Both pipelines use the original TVE formulation and the same online budget.
Table R2-2: Component ablation on MagicBrush (LPIPSAll ↓).
| Allocation + Placement | RF-Inversion | OT-RF |
|---|---|---|
| Equal + Uniform | 0.32024 | 0.35093 |
| TVE + Uniform | 0.18531 | 0.28883 |
| Equal + TVE | 0.13061 | 0.20776 |
| TVE + TVE (DARTCache) | 0.08888 | 0.19919 |
DARTCache achieves the lowest mean LPIPSAll on both hosts, with measured speedups of 2.56× and 2.72×, respectively (measured on a fixed 10-case timing subset). Compared with EEdit SLoC+ISS under its native configuration, DARTCache also achieves lower LPIPSAll (0.08888 vs. 0.11421 on RF-Inversion; 0.19919 vs. 0.35138 on OT-RF) and higher speedups (2.56× vs. 2.28×; 2.72× vs. 2.35×). This external comparison does not assume matched fresh-NFE budgets.
Cross-architecture ablation. We also revisit the complete 2×2 component ablations on the SD1.5-based MasaCtrl and EDICT frameworks from our original Appendix D.
Table R2-3: TVE component ablation on U-Net editors.
| Allocation + Placement | MasaCtrl I/D | LPIPS ↓ | PSNR ↑ | EDICT I/D | LPIPS ↓ | PSNR ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Equal + Uniform | 30/30 | 0.4866 | 11.08 | 16/16 | 0.2326 | 23.09 |
| Equal + TVE | 30/30 | 0.4639 | 11.99 | 16/16 | 0.1694 | 24.43 |
| TVE + Uniform | 40/20 | 0.1346 | 19.87 | 15/17 | 0.2273 | 23.29 |
| TVE + TVE | 40/20 | 0.0365 | 28.84 | 15/17 | 0.1517 | 25.12 |
Under identical TVE-selected stage allocations, TVE-guided placement reduces LPIPS by 72.9% on MasaCtrl and 33.3% on EDICT relative to uniform placement. The complete configurations achieve reported speedups of approximately 1.72× and 2.48×, respectively.
Host-dependent component contributions. The relative benefit of allocation and placement varies substantially across editing frameworks. With TVE placement fixed, introducing TVE-guided allocation reduces LPIPS by 92.1% on MasaCtrl, compared with 10.4% on EDICT. Similar differences appear on MagicBrush: 31.9% on RF-Inversion versus 4.1% on OT-RF. These are conditional mean improvements; notably, the additional masked-LPIPS benefit of allocation on OT-RF is not statistically established.
Thus, TVE-guided placement consistently improves mean fidelity across the four evaluated hosts, while the incremental benefit of stage allocation is host-dependent. These findings support jointly adapting placement and allocation to host-specific temporal dynamics rather than relying on fixed scheduling rules.
4. Frozen-Schedule Transfer Without Target-Dataset Recalibration
Finally, we directly transfer the PIE-Bench-calibrated schedule to all 450 held-out MagicBrush edits, without target-dataset calibration. Both schedules use the same 6/14 allocation and differ at four refresh positions, primarily testing cross-dataset refresh-placement transfer.
The frozen schedule achieves LPIPSAll = 0.08947, compared with 0.08889 after MagicBrush recalibration and 0.32024 for uniform scheduling. The paired LPIPSAll difference is +0.00058 (95% CI [−0.00077, +0.00194]).
However, frozen transfer incurs a small but detectable masked-PSNR degradation (−0.1645 dB, 95% CI [−0.2847, −0.0421]), and some individual edits exhibit larger errors. Thus, the results support practical placement transfer under the evaluated configuration, but do not establish statistical equivalence or universally lossless transfer.
Conclusion. Our additional experiments identify an empirical regularity underlying DARTCache: temporal variation is consistently nonuniform but structurally host-dependent. Quadratic TVE retains substantial predictive ability across the evaluated datasets and backbone families, while the component ablations demonstrate practical scheduling benefits with host-dependent contributions. These results support the applicability of the original TVE planning principle across the evaluated settings, without assuming universal temporal profiles or performance guarantees.
Response to Reviewer 7zpq: Overview of Generalizability Evaluation
We thank the reviewer for highlighting the need to establish the generalizability of DARTCache beyond calibration-coverage stability.
We agree that demonstrating stable calibration curves within a single dataset is insufficient to establish a generalizable planning principle. To address this concern systematically, we conduct additional experiments across different datasets, editing pipelines, and model architectures, organized around four complementary questions:
Temporal Regularity: Do temporal variation profiles exhibit common properties across settings, and which characteristics are dataset- or host-dependent?
Objective Generalization: Even when temporal profiles differ, does Quadratic TVE remain predictive of actual cache-induced fidelity degradation?
Planning Effectiveness: Does TVE-based refresh placement and stage allocation consistently translate into practical fidelity improvements across editing frameworks?
Schedule Transfer: Can a schedule calibrated on one dataset remain effective on another without recalibration?
These evaluations progress from characterizing temporal dynamics to validating the scheduling objective, its practical effectiveness, and its transferability.
Our central finding is that generalizability does not require identical temporal profiles across models. Instead, temporal variation exhibits a common nonuniform structure, while its detailed distribution is host-dependent. Quadratic TVE remains informative for scheduling across the evaluated settings, supporting a host-adaptive planning principle rather than a universal fixed schedule.
We present the detailed evidence in two parts:
The corresponding experiments have also been incorporated into Appendix D.5 of the revised manuscript.