- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces FlowFocus, an inversion-free image editing framework that uses focused trajectory regularization to balance editing and source preservation (unedited region). Dealing with the current limitation of uniform regularization in the current inversion-free paradigm, it decomposes the editing velocity into semantic and state-induced responses, and uses their relative strengths to construct a continuous edit field for spatially and temporally adaptive control. Experiments on SD3 and SD3.5 report an improved balance between source preservation and text-image alignment, with ablations examine the effects of spatial adaptation and updating the edit field over time. Overall, it provides a spatially and temporally adaptive extension of existing global trajectory regularization for inversion-free image editing.
Critical strengths
- Good Motivation with a corresponding modification: Identifies the problem of uniform regularization in inversion-free editing and proposes a targeted and intuitive modification. The proposed change follows naturally from the motivation.
- Broad baseline coverage and organized experiments: Compares against a broad range of baselines. Experiments are well-organized, with hard metrics and user studies included.
Critical weaknesses
- Unconvincing qualitative results and source preservation: Some results in the paper show noticeable artifacts and unintended changes. Specifically, "add glasses", "marble wall to flower wall" in Fig. 1, red apple and dark bird in Fig. 3 are not satisfactory. Although the method is training- and mask-free, I still expect more reliable preservation of unrelated content in these relatively straightforward editing tasks. Since improving source / background preservation is the central motivation, these visible failures directly weaken the main claim. Overall, I do not find the qualitative results convincing.
- Limited contribution with insufficient validation of the core design: The paper lacks targeted analysis of whether this particular design is necessary. Can this problem be addressed using a simpler signal such as the velocity-difference magnitude at each spatial location? It would be helpful to include latent visualizations showing where uniform regularization suppresses necessary edits or fails to preserve unrelated content, how the proposed response maps identify these regions over time, and whether simpler signals can or cannot achieve similar results. Without stronger mechanism-level evidence or higher editing quality, I am not convinced that this single adaptive modification constitutes a substantial standalone contribution to training-free image editing.
Questions for authors
- Would it be possible to provide more targeted ablations to justify the necessity of the proposed design? Visualizations of the proposed response maps and comparisons with simpler alternatives would help clarify the actual benefit of this design.
- Why is the proposed method only evaluated on SD3 and SD3.5? As the two most relevant works FlowAlign and FlowEdit both have results on FLUX, putting methods with different backbone models in a single table does not provide a fully reliable comparison. Would it be possible to evaluate FlowFocus on FLUX and compare it with these methods under the same backbone?
- The large number of baselines is somewhat distracting. Although the paper includes recent methods, it also includes many older baselines that are less informative for evaluating the proposed contribution. As this field is evolving rapidly, more targeted comparisons would be helpful, with clearer explanations of why each baseline is included rather than simply providing a large number of comparisons. ChordEdit is a good example.
1 comment
- The goal of FlowFocus is not to enforce pixel-level preservation of every source detail, but to achieve a better balance between faithfully realizing the requested semantic change and preserving content that is unrelated to the edit. This distinction is important for text-guided image editing, where the target prompt generally does not specify a unique correct output. In many cases, a reasonable edit also requires local contextual adaptation so that the modified content remains visually coherent with the surrounding scene. From this perspective, we believe the qualitative results demonstrate a favorable preservation--editability trade-off compared with existing methods. For example, in Fig.3, FlowFocus performs substantial target-driven changes while avoiding unnecessary modifications to source attributes such as the woman's appearance and accessories or the car color and license plate, which are altered by several competing methods. Similar behavior is observed across the diverse editing examples in Fig.1 and the additional qualitative comparisons in the Appendix. We agree that no qualitative example alone can fully characterize editing quality; therefore, these visual comparisons are complemented by the quantitative preservation/alignment metrics and the human evaluation, which separately assesses editing accuracy and source preservation.
- We thank the reviewer for this comment, but respectfully disagree that the proposed design constitutes only a minor modification or that its effectiveness is insufficiently validated. FlowFocus is motivated by a specific limitation of existing trajectory-regularized inversion-free editing: source-consistency regularization is applied uniformly across spatial locations, despite the fact that different regions may require very different degrees of semantic modification. Our contribution is therefore not simply to introduce an additional spatial weight, but to derive a model-intrinsic, time-varying control geometry from the conditional flow responses and incorporate it into the trajectory-level optimal-control formulation. We also believe the current empirical evidence already supports the effectiveness of this design from several complementary perspectives. The component ablation in Table2 shows a clear progression from the inversion-free baseline to global regularization, fixed focused regularization, and the full adaptive formulation, demonstrating that both spatial focusing and temporal adaptation contribute to the final performance. Fig.5 further analyzes the influence of the focused-regularization strength, while the qualitative ablation in the Appendix illustrates how different degrees of spatial adaptation affect the resulting edits. Beyond these targeted studies, the quantitative comparisons, qualitative results, category-wise analysis, and human evaluation consistently show that FlowFocus achieves a stronger balance between source preservation and target-driven editing. We nevertheless appreciate the reviewer’s request for more direct validation of the particular design choice. We believe such experiments will make clearer that the gains arise from the proposed model-derived adaptive control.
- We will add the experiments on FLUX backbone for a complete comparison.
- We thank the reviewer for this comment, but respectfully disagree that the current comparison is outdated. Our evaluation includes a broad set of representative and recent text-guided image editing methods, with particular emphasis on inversion-free rectified-flow approaches that operate under a setting comparable to FlowFocus. This includes methods such as FlowEdit, FlowAlign, FIA, DRFS, and other recent flow-based baselines (2025, 2026), and we further report results across multiple backbones to reduce the influence of model-specific advantages. Regarding the additional method suggested by the reviewer, it is designed for one-step image editing and operates under a substantially different inference setting from ours. Its model architecture, sampling procedure, and computational regime are therefore not directly aligned with the multi-step rectified-flow editing setting considered in this work. A direct numerical comparison would not provide a fully controlled or necessarily fair assessment of the proposed method.