- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces Moonwalker, a framework designed to learn accurate inversion steps in diffusion models by incorporating a LoRA adapter specifically within the forward inversion trajectory to minimize DDIM errors. The proposed adapter is trained in a self-supervised manner on model-generated outputs using a combination of trajectory matching, cycle consistency, and CFG loss terms. The authors assess their approach across various tasks, including image reconstruction, image editing, audio editing, and style transfer.
Critical strengths
- The paper is well-written and easy to understand, though its organization could be enhanced (see weaknesses).
- The qualitative style transfer results look promising.
Critical weaknesses
- Evaluation of the image reconstruction experiments (sections 4.2 and 5.2) relies exclusively on synthetic inputs derived from ReCap-COCO captions, benchmarking strictly against standard DDIM inversion. Testing on authentic, real natural images is required to verify robustness of the method. Additionally, key baselines such as ReNoise [1], PreciseInv [2], and FlowOpt [3] are omitted from the comparison.
- For the image editing evaluations on PIE-Bench (sections 4.3 and 5.2), the paper lacks comparisons with relevant diffusion approaches (e.g., DDPM Inversion [4], CycleDiffusion [5], Null-Text Inversion [6]) as well as flow-based methods (e.g., FireFlow [7], FlowEdit [8]).
- The motivation for training an optimization-based LoRA module remains questionable, especially since training-free alternatives like DDPM Inversion yield comparable or better audio editing outcomes without the associated computational overhead.
- Qualitative editing results are restricted to merely four examples. Furthermore, visible artifacts emerge in the edited outputs, such as in the cake in Figure 2 (bottom-right panel).
Minor Issues:
- In section 3.3 title, check whether "Edition" ought to be corrected to "Editing".
- Section 5.2 lacks a reference regarding quantitative comparison using FLUX on PIE-Bench, alongside a complete lack of visual qualitative figures for FLUX.
- The organization of Section 3 is somewhat confusing - section 3.3 feels misplaced in the middle and might be better placed at the beginning as an overview or positioned at the end.
[1] Garibi, Daniel, et al. "Renoise: Real image inversion through iterative noising." (ECCV’24)
[2] Zuo, Jing, et al. "Precise diffusion inversion: Towards novel samples and few-step models." (NeurIPS’26)
[3] Ronai, Or, et al. "FlowOpt: Fast Optimization Through Whole Flow Processes for Training-Free Editing." (arXiv’25)
[4] Huberman-Spiegelglas, Inbar, et al. "An edit friendly ddpm noise space: Inversion and manipulations." (CVPR’24).
[5] Wu, Chen Henry, and Fernando De la Torre. "A latent space of stochastic diffusion models for zero-shot image editing and guidance." (ICCV’23).
[6] Mokady, Ron, et al. "Null-text inversion for editing real images using guided diffusion models." (CVPR’23).
[7] Deng, Yingying, et al. "Fireflow: Fast inversion of rectified flow for image semantic editing." (ICML’25).
[8] Kulikov, Vladimir, et al. "Flowedit: Inversion-free text-based editing using pre-trained flow models." (ICCV’25)
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.