W1. The core claim of dynamic anchoring is incorrect as stated. FlowEdit's target input is already a function of the current state ZtFE. Substituting Z^tsrc=(1−t)Z0src+tNt into Eq. 5 gives
Z^ttar=ZtFE+t(Nt−Z0src),
whereas Eq. 6 gives
Z^ttar=(1−t)ZtDA+tNt=ZtDA+t(Nt−ZtDA).
The change is therefore only a re-weighting of the current state, with the source-latent offset removed. It is not a move from a static anchor to a dynamic one.
The paper also criticizes anchoring Ztsrc to Z0src, but then applies its change to Zttar. The source branch stays anchored to Z0src. As the paper notes, the two velocity fields now see different noisy inputs. This weakens the noise-cancellation argument inherited from FlowEdit, so Vtar−Vsrc is no longer a pure edit direction. The "manifold-consistent / online manifold alignment" interpretation is an intuition with no analysis or measurement behind it.
W2. The blending section mischaracterizes prior work and overclaims.
- Eq. 12 is wrong for Blended Latent Diffusion, which re-noises the blended background latent to the same noise level as the inpainted foreground. Eq. 12 uses the clean latent. With this corrected, Eq. 13 is essentially the Blended Latent Diffusion scheme, so the claimed contribution largely disappears.
- "Strictly preserves unmasked pixels" is not guaranteed. Blending happens at the noise-construction stage, but the ODE still updates the whole latent.
- No unmasked-region error or boundary-specific metric is reported to support the seam-free claim.
W3. The enhanced ODE integration lacks novelty and is not compared fairly. It is a standard Heun / predictor–corrector sampler. Table 2 compares 10 predictor–corrector steps, which need 2 evaluations each (about 20 evaluations), against 40-step Euler. The fair comparison is Euler at about 20 steps, plus other higher-order solvers. It is also odd that 4× more Euler steps gives 3.8 dB lower PSNR, which suggests the solver changes the effective edit strength, not only numerical accuracy. The "2.2× speedup" is a runtime comparison for one configuration, not an accuracy-matched one.
W4. Baselines and evaluation do not support the claim that inversion-free is better.
- Missing methods. No other inversion-based or inversion-free method is compared. FlowEdit, the direct parent, is absent, as is the trivial locality fix of FlowEdit with a masked velocity.
- Outdated baselines. Blended Diffusion, BrushNet and PowerPaint are SD1.5/SD2.1 U-Net methods run with default settings, while DynaFill uses an SD3 flow-matching DiT. This confounds backbone with method.
- Inconsistent reporting. The text promises "six approaches" and discusses FlowChef and SD1.5 Inpaint, but Table 1 shows four baselines.
- Preservation-biased metrics. PSNR, SSIM and LPIPS measure similarity to the source. The paper does not say whether metrics cover the full image or the masked region, and the benchmark masks are not described. DynaFill also uses a tuned target CFG of 12, while the baselines use defaults.
- Task scope. The method needs a source prompt and an intact source image, and the examples are object swaps (wolf→cow, pizza→cake). The task is closer to mask-guided editing than to inpainting.
W5. The ablations are inconsistent with the paper's explanations. The paper says the fixed anchor "preserves excessive information from the original latent and limits the semantic transition". Yet the fixed anchor has the higher CLIP-Score (29.77 vs 29.48) and worse perceptual scores. The same pattern appears in the solver ablation (CLIP 30.35 vs 29.48), which suggests a preservation-versus-edit-strength trade-off, not a strict improvement. Some differences are tiny (e.g., FID 68.13 vs 68.04) and no variance is reported. The text cites a sofa→chair example that does not appear in Fig. 4, which shows umbrella→parasol instead.
W6. The paper reads as incomplete.
- The explanation of inversion-based and inversion-free editing is limited and confusing.
- There is no algorithm section, and implementation details are sparse.
- The FlowEdit notation (ZtFE, Ztsrc, Zttar) is copied without clear explanation, and FlowEdit is not credited where it is introduced, which makes these terms confusing.
- There are minor typos (e.g., lines 31, 41, 64).