- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a training-free framework for efficient inference-time scaling in image inpainting. The method has three main components: (1) mask-aware initial noise construction, which shares background noise across Best-of-N candidates while varying noise in the target region; (2) a so-called anchor-cached background KV cache, which runs one anchor trajectory fully and reuses its background key/value states for later candidates while recomputing only the target region plus a small boundary band; and (3) a token-aware temporal velocity cache, which progressively removes stabilized dynamic tokens from active computation to be reused in their latest velocity predictions. The method is evaluated on EditBench and BrushBench using FLUX.1 Fill, and the reported results show near-Best-of-N quality with a substantially lower normalized compute cost, corresponding to speedups of roughly 4.4x-4.6x over standard multi-candidate scaling.
Critical strengths
The strongest aspect of the paper is its simplicity and being practical. The proposed modifications are training-free and can be applied at inference time to a strong pretrained inpainting model. The decomposition into shared background trajectories, reusable background context, and I find the adaptive temporal reuse to be intuitive, and the reported efficiency gains are quite substantial: the method reduces normalized compute to about 0.21-0.23 of vanilla Best-of-N while largely preserving its quality. This makes the method potentially useful in settings where multi-candidate inpainting is otherwise prohibitively expensive
Critical weaknesses
-
The novelty of the background-KV component is rather limited and is not positioned sufficiently against very close prior work. In particular, KV-Edit (ICCV 2025) already caches background K/V states and, during denoising, processes only foreground tokens while concatenating their current K/V with cached background K/V. At the attention-computation level, I find it to be very close to the proposed Anchor-Cached Background KV mechanism. The main distinction I can tell is how the reusable background trajectory are obtained: KV-Edit obtains it from inversion, whereas this paper aligns Best-of-N candidates using shared background noise and takes the K/V states from an anchor candidate. LazyDiffusion also predates this work and establishes the broader idea of spending iterative computation only on the masked region, while retaining the global image context. Neither KV-Edit nor LazyDiffusion appears to be discussed or cited. As a result, I view the main novelty as the adaptation of this idea to cross-candidate inference-time scaling through background-trajectory alignment, rather than the background KV-cache mechanism itself. This, to me, substantially weakens the claimed novelty.
-
It is not clear how the Token-Aware Temporal Velocity Cache handles tokens that have stopped changing. The paper says it skips these tokens and reuses their previous velocity predictions. But what happens to their keys and values in each attention layer? Other tokens still need these to attend to the skipped tokens. Do they keep the old keys and values, remove the tokens from attention, or do something else? These choices can affect speed, memory use, and image quality. The paper should explain this so others can reproduce the method and understand the reported savings.
Questions for authors
Clarification 1: When a dynamic token is declared stable by the Token-Aware Temporal Velocity Cache and removed from the active set, what then happens to that token's K/V states in every subsequent transformer block and denoising step? Are its most recently computed per-layer K/V states cached and concatenated with the K/V of active tokens, or is the token removed entirely from the attention context? If it is removed, please specify the resulting attention sequence and justify why the lost dynamic-token context is safe. If stale K/V is retained, please include this cache in the method description and in the memory/compute accounting. This answer could materially affect my assessment of both soundness and efficiency.
Clarification 2: Please clarify the technical novelty of the Anchor-Cached Background KV mechanism relative to KV-Edit. My reading is that both methods compute queries only for the editable/dynamic tokens while providing cached background K/V as attention memory; the main difference appears to be the provenance of the cache (an inversion trajectory in KV-Edit versus an aligned anchor candidate here). If there is a more fundamental difference, explaining it and positioning the contribution relative to KV-Edit and LazyDiffusion would materially affect my assessment of novelty.
5 comments
Response to Reviewer 4HNZ (2/3)
R1 (2/2) : Identical observed backgrounds do not necessarily imply identical intermediate computational states across different generation candidates. In standard Best-of-N, each candidate independently samples the full initial noise. Even when candidates share the same input image and editing instruction, their background tokens may follow different intermediate denoising trajectories. Consequently, directly reusing the background K/V states of one candidate for other independently sampled candidates may introduce mismatches in intermediate features and degrade generation quality.
To address this issue, we propose Reuse-Oriented Structured Sampling Coupling, implemented through Mask-Aware Initial Noise Construction. Specifically, we share the initial background noise across candidates while retaining independent noise sampling within the masked region. This design has two closely related properties. First, the marginal distribution of each candidate's initial noise remains standard Gaussian. Second, the joint sampling correlation structure across candidates is explicitly modified to improve the alignment of background denoising trajectories while preserving independent stochastic exploration within the masked region.
Building upon this design, a fully computed Anchor Candidate provides reusable background K/V states for subsequent candidates, while tokens near the mask boundary remain dynamically computed to maintain contextual consistency between the generated content and the observed background. Furthermore, Token-Aware Temporal Velocity Cache reduces redundant computation for stabilized tokens within the masked region, allowing the overall framework to reduce both cross-candidate spatial redundancy and within-candidate temporal redundancy.
We further conduct experiments to evaluate the practical impact of the above technical differences. Specifically, we evaluate two configurations of KV-Edit [1] under our image inpainting setting: KV-Edit/dev uses FLUX.1-dev, the original backbone adopted in the KV-Edit paper, whereas KV-Edit/Fill adapts the KV-Edit method to FLUX.1-Fill-dev, enabling a direct comparison with our method under the same pretrained backbone.
Table R4. Quantitative comparison with KV-Edit under the image inpainting setting.
| Method | CLIP ↑ | HPS2.1 ↑ | HPSv3 ↑ | PickScore ↑ | VQA ↑ | ImageReward ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| KV-Edit/dev | 30.0883 | 0.2409 | 2.5343 | 21.1906 | 0.8416 | 0.5010 |
| KV-Edit/Fill | 30.1938 | 0.2537 | 4.8333 | 21.5761 | 0.8701 | 0.8074 |
| Ours | 30.0780 | 0.2588 | 5.5138 | 21.7470 | 0.8772 | 0.8361 |
These results demonstrate that, under the evaluated image inpainting setting, our method achieves better overall generation quality than the adapted KV-Edit baseline, even when both methods use the same FLUX.1-Fill-dev pretrained backbone. This further validates the practical effectiveness of our approach and provides direct empirical evidence of its performance advantages over existing background K/V reuse methods.
In summary, we emphasize that the core technical contribution of our work is neither the KV Cache operation itself nor merely a change in the source of cached background K/V states. Instead, we propose a training-free joint sampling and computation-reuse mechanism that preserves the marginal distribution of each candidate's initial noise. By explicitly controlling the cross-candidate sampling correlation structure, our method transforms intermediate background computational states that would otherwise be difficult to share reliably across candidates into effectively reusable computational resources, while preserving independent exploration within the masked region.
References
[1] Zhu et al., KV-Edit: Training-Free Image Editing for Precise Background Preservation, ICCV 2025.
[2] Nitzan et al., Lazy Diffusion Transformer for Interactive Image Editing, ECCV 2024.
Response to Reviewer 4HNZ (3/3)
W2: It is not clear how the Token-Aware Temporal Velocity Cache handles tokens that have stopped changing. The paper says it skips these tokens and reuses their previous velocity predictions, but what happens to their keys and values in each attention layer?
Q1: When a dynamic token is declared stable by the Token-Aware Temporal Velocity Cache and removed from the active set, what then happens to that token's K/V states in every subsequent transformer block and denoising step? Are its most recently computed per-layer K/V states cached and concatenated with the K/V of active tokens, or is the token removed entirely from the attention context? If it is removed, please specify the resulting attention sequence and justify why the lost dynamic-token context is safe. If stale K/V is retained, please include this cache in the method description and in the memory/compute accounting. This answer could materially affect my assessment of both soundness and efficiency.
R2: Frozen tokens stop participating in query-side computation but remain accessible through cached per-layer K/V states. We apologize that the current manuscript does not clearly describe the handling of frozen tokens, which may have caused confusion. When a dynamic token is declared stable and removed from the active set, it stops participating in subsequent Query computation but is not removed entirely from the Attention Context.
Specifically, we retain the token's most recently computed Key and Value states in each Transformer Block and reuse them throughout the remaining denoising steps. Although frozen tokens no longer undergo fresh feature computation, their cached K/V states remain available to other active tokens, preserving the necessary contextual information. For the frozen token itself, we reuse its latest Velocity Prediction from the last step in which it was active, without executing further Transformer Forward passes for that token.
In terms of efficiency, this design reduces computation by shrinking the number of active Queries and associated feature updates, while retaining frozen tokens as attention context. Additional memory overhead mainly comes from caching their per-Transformer-Block K/V states, which are reused rather than recomputed in subsequent steps.
Manuscript revisions. In the revised manuscript, red marks changes to the original content, and blue marks newly added content.
To address W1/Q2, Section 2 (page 3) adds KV-Edit and LazyDiffusion and distinguishes their editing/reuse settings from cross-candidate Best-of-N sampling coupling; Section 3.2 (page 4) and Appendix G.1 (page 21) state the unchanged per-candidate Gaussian marginal and altered cross-candidate correlation.
To address W2/Q1, Appendix C (page 16), in the paragraph "Noise construction and anchor cache," clarifies that active queries attend to the step-aligned anchor text/background states, current active-token K/V, and retained last-active per-block K/V of frozen tokens. Frozen tokens remain in the attention context and reuse their last active-step velocity prediction.
Response to Reviewer 4HNZ (1/3)
We thank the reviewer for acknowledging the practicality and substantial efficiency gains of our training-free method, and for highlighting the need to clarify both its novelty relative to closely related work and its handling of stabilized tokens.
R1 (1/2) : Our key contribution is not merely to identify reusable computation, but to design the sampling process to make computation reusable. We thank the reviewer for pointing out KV-Edit [1] and LazyDiffusion [2], which are closely related to our work. We would like to clarify that our contribution goes beyond simply exploiting existing computational redundancy. Instead, we explicitly design the joint sampling structure across different candidates to actively create reusable intermediate computational states while preserving the diversity required for candidate exploration.
KV-Edit [1] supports image editing by constructing and reusing source-image-related background computational states, whereas our method actively establishes cross-candidate background computational reusability through structured sampling coupling. Specifically, KV-Edit primarily focuses on background preservation during image editing. It obtains background K/V states associated with the source image through an inversion-based editing process and uses them as attention context for foreground generation. Its computation reuse mainly relies on caching and utilizing existing background states, rather than treating sampling correlations across different generation trajectories as design variables to actively establish consistency among cross-candidate intermediate computational states. In contrast, we move the consideration of computation reuse to the initial noise sampling stage. By explicitly controlling the cross-candidate sampling correlation structure, we improve the alignment of background denoising trajectories, enabling reliable reuse of background computation that would otherwise be difficult to share directly across candidates. More importantly, this design preserves the marginal distribution of each candidate's initial noise while retaining independent stochastic exploration within the masked region, allowing candidate diversity and computation sharing to be achieved jointly.
LazyDiffusion [2] reduces redundant computation through a specially designed and trained model architecture, whereas our method requires neither additional training nor modifications to the pretrained model architecture and instead actively establishes computational reusability through structured sampling coupling. Specifically, LazyDiffusion employs a specially designed and trained Encoder–Decoder architecture to separate global image context encoding from iterative generation within the masked region, thereby reducing redundant computation at the architectural level. In contrast, our method operates directly on existing pretrained models and incorporates computation-reuse considerations into the initial noise sampling process. By explicitly controlling sampling correlations among candidates, we actively establish relationships between their background trajectories, enabling effective reuse of otherwise repeated background computation and thereby reducing inference costs.
References
[1] Zhu et al., KV-Edit: Training-Free Image Editing for Precise Background Preservation, ICCV 2025.
[2] Nitzan et al., Lazy Diffusion Transformer for Interactive Image Editing, ECCV 2024.