- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes NeMeS, a promptless dual-branch memory architecture for coronary angiography vessel segmentation. The key idea is to exploit a pre-contrast frame as annotation-free negative memory: a proposer branch performs causal vessel segmentation using temporal memory, while an anchor-conditioned suppressor branch identifies structures that are already present before contrast injection. Their predictions are combined through the multiplicative gate $ P = \sigma(L_A)\left(1-\sigma(L_B)\right), $ so that the suppressor can attenuate vessel-like distractors but cannot introduce new positive predictions.
The method is trained on a large in-house coronary angiography dataset and evaluated on the full in-domain test set, a device-cluttered hard-case subset, and two external datasets, XACV and MOSXAV, in a zero-shot setting. The authors additionally provide anchor ablations, a parameter-matched random-anchor control, device-specific false-positive analysis, synthetic distractor experiments, temporal-change evaluation, and feature probing. The reported results show improvements over CNN-, ViT-, temporal-, and SAM2-based baselines, particularly for device-heavy cases and cross-domain evaluation.
Critical strengths
- Using the pre-contrast frame as negative memory is well motivated by the acquisition process itself: nonvascular anatomy and interventional devices may already be present before coronary opacification, whereas the target vessels emerge after contrast injection. This provides a natural mechanism for distinguishing true vessels from vessel-like distractors and directly targets an important failure mode of existing segmentation systems.
- Beyond standard Dice-based comparisons, the paper evaluates hard cases, two external datasets without target-domain fine-tuning, device-specific false positives, anchor perturbations, a parameter-matched random-anchor model, synthetic distractor rejection, temporal-change accuracy, and representation probing. In particular, the substantial reduction of device false positives on MOSXAV provides convincing evidence that the anchor is useful for the failure mode targeted by the paper.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological contribution appears highly specific to the coronary angiography acquisition protocol, and the current experiments do not establish that ``negative memory'' is a sufficiently general learning principle. NeMeS relies on the availability of a pre-contrast frame that contains approximately the same anatomical scene and devices but lacks the target contrast-filled vessels. This is a strong task-specific source of supervision. Once such a reference is available, the proposed architecture mainly consists of a second SAM2 branch conditioned on this reference and a multiplicative suppression gate. It is therefore unclear how much of the contribution represents a general architectural principle rather than an effective exploitation of a domain-specific acquisition cue. This is particularly important for ICLR, where broader methodological implications would substantially strengthen the contribution.
- The experiments do not sufficiently establish that the proposed dual-branch memory architecture is necessary compared with simpler ways of exploiting the same pre-contrast information.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors compare NeMeS against simpler methods that have access to exactly the same pre-contrast anchor, for example $ x_t-x_a, \qquad [F(x_t);F(x_a)], $ a registration/subtraction-based baseline, or a single-branch SAM2 model with anchor-conditioned cross-attention? Such comparisons would materially clarify whether the gain arises from the proposed negative-memory decomposition or simply from making the pre-contrast reference available to the model.
- How generally is the required pre-contrast anchor available in real clinical acquisitions, and what happens when the reference is substantially mismatched because of table motion, catheter manipulation, projection changes, patient motion, or residual contrast from a previous injection? The current contrast-level perturbation experiment addresses vessel opacification, but does not fully characterize these clinically plausible anchor failures.
- The paper reports two-sided paired -tests with . What is the statistical unit used in these tests---frame, sequence, or patient? Since multiple annotated frames can belong to the same sequence or patient, treating individual frames as independent observations could substantially underestimate uncertainty. Please clarify the pairing strategy and, preferably, report sequence- or patient-level confidence intervals.
- How was the in-house ``hard-case'' subset of 190 sequences determined? Was the criterion defined prospectively and independently of model predictions, and was the selection performed without inspecting the comparative performance of NeMeS and the baselines? A reproducible definition is important because the hard-case analysis constitutes a central part of the paper's motivation and claimed advantage.
- The random-initialization probing experiment is interpreted as evidence for an architectural inductive bias. However, the dual-branch representation has explicit access to both the target and anchor, whereas the single-branch SAM2 representation does not contain the same information. Can the authors provide an input-matched control in which both architectures receive the same anchor and target information but differ only in the proposed negative-memory organization? This would more directly support the architectural-inductive-bias claim.