- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes FUP-Net for coronary artery segmentation. Its FH-Mamba2 module separates smooth and detail features, using Mamba2 for long-range structure and convolutions for local vessel details. Its UPA module uses prediction uncertainty to weight target-domain features when updating semantic prototypes, followed by conditional domain alignment. The paper reports results on JSPH-ICA, DCA1, and ARCADE, including segmentation, boundary, cross-domain, and component-ablation evaluations.
Critical strengths
-
The frequency-aware component has a useful ablation. Adding frequency separation to the Mamba2 variant improves Dice by 2.19, 3.24, and 2.11 percentage points across the three datasets (Table 3). This provides evidence for processing smooth vessel structure and local detail with different operators.
-
The evaluation reports results across three ICA datasets using both region-overlap and boundary metrics. This breadth helps assess whether the reported improvements extend beyond Dice alone, subject to clarification of the training protocol below.
Critical weaknesses
-
The supplied implementation appears inconsistent with the paper’s central unlabeled-target adaptation claim. Section 4.2 and Eq. (15) state that target-domain images are used without segmentation labels. Yet the supplied data.py requires target training masks, and train.py computes a segmentation loss using those masks and adds it to the total objective (loss_t, lines 297–330). Appendix C also describes experiments without UPA as supervised training “on each dataset,” which conflicts with Section 4.2’s source-only description. If the supplied training code generated the DCA1 and ARCADE results, their gains cannot be interpreted as evidence for adaptation using unlabeled target data. This uncertainty directly affects the paper’s main empirical claim.
-
The contribution of uncertainty weighting is not sufficiently isolated. In Table 3, UPP+UPA improves over UPP+ProtoDA by 0.62 Dice points on DCA1 and 1.17 on ARCADE, without uncertainty estimates for these differences. The full-model comparison changes multiple adaptation components at once. Moreover, Table 1 lacks adaptation baselines with clearly matched access to target-domain data, limiting attribution of the reported cross-domain advantage.
Questions for authors
-
Were target-domain ground-truth segmentation masks used to train any model reported in Table 1? Please identify the exact code version and configuration used for those results and explain why the supplied training code includes loss_t computed from target masks. If the reported models used target labels, please state that setting explicitly; if they did not, please provide the corresponding unlabeled-target training code.
-
For each Table 1 method, what labeled source data and target data were available during training and model selection? Please provide comparisons against adaptation baselines with the same data access.
-
With FH-Mamba2 and the other adaptation components held fixed, what is the effect of removing only the uncertainty weighting from UPA? Please report variability or paired uncertainty for this ablation.