- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents a pipeline for robust blood vessel segmentation in X-ray angiography. To this end, the paper proposes training a decoder to reconstruct blood vessel segments while jointly minimizing multiple objective functions, including vessel prediction, region prediction, centreline, and structural membership. The experiments are performed on three different benchmarks—XACV, DCA1, and XCAD—and the results are compared with those of multiple existing works. The experimental results demonstrate superior performance compared to existing methods across multiple metrics.Segmentation of blood vessels in X-ray angiography has significant importance in clinical practice. Making such a pipeline robust and reliable would be crucial for its adoption in clinical practice. The experimental results look competitive compared to those of existing methods.
Critical strengths
1.Segmentation of blood vessels in X-ray angiography has significant importance in clinical practice. Making such a pipeline robust and reliable would be crucial for its adoption in clinical practice.
- The experimental results look competitive compared to those of existing methods.
Critical weaknesses
-
While reading the paper, I observed that its design choices are not well justified. As the objective function consists of multiple components, including objective functions for vessel prediction, region prediction, etc., it is important that the significance of each component is motivated and explained properly. Moreover, the hypothesis also needs to be supported by rigorous experiments, which this paper lacks.
-
I also observed that the related works are quite narrow. Additionally, the references are not properly cited in the table summarizing the performance comparison (please see Table 4).
-
The pipeline is evaluated on only a single clinical problem. Therefore, it is also hard to tell how the proposed method would generalize to other domains. As ICLR is a venue of broader interest in AI and machine learning, I am unsure how large the audience at ICLR interested in this paper will be.
-
The diagrams are also unclear; in particular, the fonts are not clear. Moreover, mapping important components in the figures to the equations in the paper would enhance the readability of the paper.
-
There are no ablation studies for the individual objective functions. Without such studies, it is difficult to understand the role of each component in the pipeline, and it would also be hard to draw any conclusions.
Questions for authors
- How does each component of the objective function impact overall performance?
- Does this pipeline also generalize to datasets other than X-ray angiography datasets?