Major weakness 1: The ablations do not clearly identify the contribution of each design choice.
The comparison between the whole-view baseline and TopoSculpt establishes the benefit of the overall refinement procedure. Table 2 also shows that removing the integrity-preservation objective generally degrades segmentation quality. These are useful experiments, but they leave several proposed components coupled together.
First, the integrity-preservation objective combines prediction consistency and skeleton-based structural overlap. Removing the entire objective does not reveal whether the gains come primarily from the consistency term, the skeleton term, or their interaction. A controlled comparison of topology correction alone, correction with consistency, correction with skeleton preservation, and correction with both would make this contribution clearer.
Second, the curriculum changes both the frequency of persistent homology computation and the strength of the preservation objective. Its effects on optimization quality and computational cost are therefore difficult to separate. Comparisons against dense recomputation and fixed sparse recomputation, with preservation weights controlled, would help establish what the schedule contributes.
Finally, the whole-view baseline is already strong. On ATM, clDice increases from 86.27 for the patch-based Dice+CE baseline to 90.48 for HVModel, before reaching 92.27 with TopoSculpt. The HVModel comparison therefore usefully demonstrates the additional benefit of refinement. However, comparisons with alternative topology objectives under the same whole-view setting would better establish the advantage of the proposed objective over existing alternatives.
Overall, although Appendix G provides theoretical motivation for the design choices, the experiments establish the effectiveness of the complete framework more clearly than the separate empirical contributions of the preservation components and curriculum choices.
Major weakness 2: The computational efficiency and practical resource requirements are insufficiently characterized.
The method uses a lightweight network, but parameter count alone does not establish memory efficiency for 3D segmentation. Whole-region processing can require substantial activation memory, particularly when refinement performs backward passes through the network. The relevant cost depends on input dimensions and resolution as well as model size.
The refinement procedure also introduces substantial additional computation relative to a standard forward pass. The reported configuration performs 90 optimization updates per test image, together with skeleton-related operations and periodic persistent homology computations. Although the proposed schedule reduces the number of persistent homology computations, the remaining optimization updates still incur computation.
The manuscript does not provide enough measured evidence to assess this tradeoff. Reporting the experimental hardware does not establish the minimum hardware requirement, and reducing persistent homology evaluations does not by itself quantify end-to-end acceleration.
Minor weakness 1: The empirical scope of the topology prior is limited.
The explicitly described settings emphasize a target of one connected component: this is the intended airway topology, and the selected CoW cases satisfy this condition. This is a reasonable and useful setting because many anatomical structures are expected to be connected. I therefore regard it as a limitation of demonstrated scope rather than a major validity concern. Nevertheless, the authors should state the exact prior used for every dataset, particularly CTCA, and qualify generality claims accordingly.
Minor weakness 2: Limited characterization of incorrect reconnections.
The improvements in clDice, branch detection, tree-length detection, and surface accuracy, together with the qualitative examples in Appendix C, provide meaningful evidence that refinement improves segmentation quality beyond reducing connected-component errors. Nevertheless, these results do not fully characterize whether refinement occasionally introduces anatomically incorrect connections. Different branching arrangements can share the same connected-component count, and a short false bridge may have a limited effect on aggregate metrics. A targeted analysis of unsuccessful reconnections or representative failure cases would strengthen the anatomical interpretation of the results. I regard this as a remaining evaluation limitation rather than evidence that the reported improvements are merely topological or anatomically invalid.