- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies point-cloud semantic segmentation in high-aspect-ratio (HAR) scenes, focusing on long-range semantic inconsistency and class confusion near attached components. Building on PTv3, the authors propose HASP-Net, which employs geometry-consistent ordered support chains for long-range context aggregation, geometry-guided local refinement, and semantic contrastive learning. The authors also introduce HAR3D-Seg, combining newly collected transmission point clouds with public railway and vascular datasets, along with two structural evaluation metrics, SCS and CAS. Experiments across the three scene types report improved segmentation performance, supported by ablation studies and inference-efficiency comparisons.
Critical strengths
-
The Long-range Track Module organizes local geometric cells into ordered support chains and aggregates context using arc-length and reliability weighting. This design effectively incorporates the geometric prior of elongated structures and provides a meaningful structural inductive bias for HAR segmentation.
-
The authors collect and annotate large-scale UAV-LiDAR transmission point clouds and combine them with public railway and vascular datasets to construct HAR3D-Seg. The additional SCS and CAS metrics provide useful complementary perspectives on structural continuity and local class discrimination.
Critical weaknesses
-
While the ordered support chains are tailored to HAR scenes, the framework largely combines established techniques, including geometric propagation, attention-based refinement, gated residual updates, and contrastive learning. Its methodological distinction from existing structure-aware methods remains unclear. Moreover, the ablations do not fully support the intended mechanisms. In Table 6, Long-range alone improves mIoU but not SCS (1.83 to 1.82), while Interface alone reduces CAS (1.00 to 0.95). Interface+CL also achieves higher CAS than the full model (1.08 vs. 1.03). These results leave the individual contributions and interactions of the proposed modules insufficiently explained.
-
PTv3 uses spherical crops of up to 120,000 points, whereas HASP uses scene-wide samples of up to two million points. These differences may affect both accuracy and efficiency. Notably, HASP(Base) already achieves substantially higher OA than PTv3 (95.50% vs. 78.06%), despite slightly lower mIoU (Table 3). The inference-efficiency comparison also involves different cropping and voting pipelines. Thus, matched-protocol comparisons are needed to better isolate the benefits of the proposed method.
Questions for authors
-
In Table 6, Long-range alone does not improve SCS, whereas adding it to Interface+CL increases SCS from 1.84 to 1.92. How do the authors explain this interaction? Why does Interface alone reduce CAS, and why does Interface+CL outperform the full model on CAS? Could a CL-only control clarify these effects? Additionally, how do the authors explain the relatively low SCS in the Rural railway subset and the modest improvements on attached components?
-
Could the authors compare PTv3 and HASP under matched sampling and inference protocols? How much of the reported accuracy and efficiency improvement remains when both methods use the same scene-wide sampling configuration?
-
What cell sizes, minimum track lengths, and distance-decay scales are used for each dataset? How are these parameters adapted to normalized vascular coordinates? Are they determined by a unified scaling rule or tuned separately, and how sensitive are the results to these settings? Cross-scene ablations or comparisons with conventional geometry-aware graph propagation would help clarify the method's generality.
-
Could the authors provide further validation of SCS and CAS, such as underlying correctness ratios or sensitivity to reference-construction thresholds? Given the relatively small mIoU gains on railway scenes, could additional statistical evidence be provided to establish the robustness of these improvements?
4 comments
Reviewer Response: Unresolved Evidence Gaps on Ablation, OA Protocol, and Methodological Novelty
Thank you for the authors’ response. I appreciate the clarification on the structural inductive bias for HAR scenes, the unified benchmark, and the structural metrics.However, the following issues remain:
In Table 6, the CAS of Full is lower than that of IR+CL, and this has still not been directly explained. The authors explain the improvement in SCS brought by LR, but do not explain why adding LR to IR+CL reduces CAS from 1.08 to 1.03. It is insufficient to explain the coexistence of SCS and mIoU solely by “increased coverage but a shorter longest correct segment”; a direct account of the CAS drop is needed. In addition, the discrepancy in Table 3 between HASP(Base) OA of 95.50% and PTv3 OA of 78.06% has not been addressed. Please clarify whether this discrepancy is caused by the sampling protocol, cropping/full-scene evaluation, class imbalance, or the OA denominator setting. If the protocols differ, the OA difference should not be attributed directly to the method itself. I acknowledge the new benchmark and metrics constructed by the authors, and I support their contribution to model evaluation in this field. However, the advantages of HASP itself across multiple benchmarks are not pronounced, and the explanation of its negative effects remains insufficient. Mechanistically, through the authors’ response and further reading of the paper, I now better understand the novel combination of structural aggregation and contrastive supervision, but I still do not consider this to constitute the main methodological novelty.
I am not inclined to raise my score at this time.
Clarifications on CAS regression, OA differences, and methodological contribution
Thank you for the follow-up comments. We have added class-level and visual analyses in Appendices D.2 and D.3.1 to explain the CAS decrease and the OA difference directly.
- CAS decrease from IR+CL to Full. To investigate this decrease, we conducted additional class-level evaluations and visual comparisons using the same reference pairs. Table 14 identifies ground wire and optical cable as the main contributors. Their correct-pair ratios decrease from 0.35666 to 0.31788 and from 0.82946 to 0.80212, accounting for 98.94% of the net mX decrease from 0.66026 to 0.64355. This corresponds to the CAS decrease from 1.08 to 1.03 in Table 6.
A possible explanation is that LR’s shared anchor-level context changes the features used by IR in locally ambiguous regions, where ground wires and optical cables can resemble nearby conductors. Figure 16 shows six ground-wire and four optical-cable endpoints correctly classified by IR+CL but misclassified as conductors by Full. Correct pairs decrease from 8/8 to 0/8 and from 8/8 to 1/8, respectively, because one incorrect endpoint can invalidate multiple pairs. These results locate the CAS decrease primarily in local confusion between nearby line classes, while Table 6 shows that adding LR improves overall mIoU from 61.22% to 62.27% and SCS from 1.84 to 1.92.
-
OA difference between PTv3 and Base. The original configurations use different spatial sampling. PTv3 uses spherical training crops capped at 120,000 points, while Base uses scene-wide samples capped at two million points. Appendix D.3.1 reports a comparison of saved predictions on the same points across 100 scenes, yielding 78.20% OA for PTv3 and 90.39% for Base. Table 17 shows ground recall increasing from 36.82% to 88.11%, vegetation recall from 85.44% to 91.51%, and tower precision from 28.16% to 88.29%. One possible explanation is that scene-wide sampling preserves terrain and structural context that small crops may lack. Ground and vegetation dominate the point population, so their improved recognition strongly affects OA. Figure 18 illustrates fewer ground-to-vegetation and vegetation-to-tower errors. Across these scenes, vegetation-to-tower errors decrease from 66.11 million to 3.28 million points.
-
Methodological contribution. Although previous studies have explored structural aggregation and contrastive supervision, HASP adapts their construction and interaction to HAR scenes, where long, closely spaced structures coexist with small attachments. As explained in Appendix D.1, CurveNet learns guided walks and CurveCloudNet uses sensor scan polylines, while HASP constructs axial chains or surface supports from input geometry. Along axial chains, LR separately aggregates left, right, and whole-chain context, providing distant structural evidence when local observations are sparse or ambiguous. Superpoint Graph propagates region-level descriptors, whereas IR retains individual query features and combines them with the LR-updated local context and their difference. This allows nearby points to receive different corrections even when they share structural context, helping distinguish attachments from surrounding wires or supports. Unlike CBL’s contrastive supervision of boundary features, our CL directly supervises the fused query-context representation used to generate corrections, encouraging class separation where local aggregation may mix evidence from neighboring classes. Thus, the distinction lies in how geometric supports, pointwise correction, and contrastive supervision work together to address long-range continuity and local semantic ambiguity in HAR scenes.
Reply to the Authors: Further Explanation of Performance Degradation and Score Adjustment
Thank you to the authors for providing further explanation regarding the performance degradation caused by certain mechanisms. The additional evidence also makes the results in the paper more convincing. I am raising my score from 2 to 3.
Response to Reviewer oXVd
Thank you for the constructive comments. We clarify our contributions, module interactions, evaluation protocols, and structural metrics.
Methodological contribution. Earlier methods use structural aggregation and contrastive supervision, but HASP combines them differently. CurveNet learns walks on kNN graphs and CurveCloudNet uses sensor scan polylines, while HASP reconstructs axial chains or surface supports from geometry, separating left, right, and whole-chain context along chains. Unlike Superpoint Graph's region-level propagation, IR combines individual query features, local context, and their difference for pointwise correction. Unlike CBL's boundary-feature contrast, CL supervises the fused query–context features that generate corrections.
Module interactions and CL-only. LR's shared anchor context can recover missed regions but also disturb correct predictions and interrupt continuity. Figure 13 shows correct coverage increasing from 12 to 16 m while the longest correct segment decreases from 12 to 8 m, explaining why higher mIoU can coexist with lower SCS.
IR's geometric query selection can include already-correct points. Ambiguous features may cause incorrect updates because gating controls magnitude rather than class decisions. In Figure 14, four ground-wire points are misclassified as conductors, reducing correct pairs from 30/84 to 23/84. Both endpoints must be correct, so CAS can decrease despite semantic gains.
CL-only reaches 59.82% mIoU and SCS/CAS of 1.79/0.96 in Table 6, with class results in Table 12. With IR, CL supervises fused correction features to resolve ambiguity, recovering three V-insulator tip points in Figure 15. Table 6 shows CAS increasing from 0.95 to 1.08 when CL is added to IR and SCS from 1.84 to 1.92 when LR is added to IR+CL, supporting their complementary roles.
Computational cost. Standard PTv3 uses repeated crop-based inference and voting, while our optimized pipeline processes scene-wide inputs without either. Table 20 reports Full's 61.59% mIoU and estimated 769.72 s/scene, with PTv3's measured 653.22 s/scene as the cost reference. The optimized pipeline achieves 62.27% mIoU in Table 3 and 2.673 s/scene in Figure 6. LR and IR add computation, while the optimized pipeline reduces redundant inference. This overhead represents a reasonable trade-off for improved accuracy and continuity.
Rural continuity and small attachments. Table 17 shows lower rail continuity for HASP than PTv3 at 0.66500 versus 0.67988, but higher wire continuity at 0.98554 versus 0.95337. Figure 17 shows rail-to-track-bed errors leaving a 14 m longest correct segment. Higher rail IoU therefore need not improve continuity.
Small attachments can be geometrically ambiguous. For example, V-insulator arms resemble suspension-insulator segments, so IR may disturb correct LR predictions. Table 6 reports V-insulator IoU of 85.55%, 73.69%, and 81.34% for LR, Joint, and Full. Figure 16 shows three arm endpoints recovered with CL. Despite partial recovery relative to LR, Full improves several attachment classes and raises average attachment IoU by 1.12 points over Base in Tables 14 and 15, supporting the combined modules' effectiveness.
With the same backbone and inputs, the graph baseline uses three aggregation hops over up to 16 neighbors within 12 m, then local aggregation and gated updates. Table 13 reports Joint/graph mIoU of 61.17%/61.05% and mAcc of 72.14%/68.73%. LR separates directional context, while IR uses feature similarity and geometry for pointwise correction. This combines structural evidence with local discrimination, consistent with higher mean class recall.
Tables 4 and 16 and Appendix D.3 report railway gains. HASP improves mIoU by 0.44, 0.34, and 0.50 points over PTv3 on Urban, Rural, and Plateau. Table 16 also shows higher mAcc and overhead-line IoU across all subsets, supporting the benefits of structural context.