acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Trust, but Verify Temporal Memory: Procedure-Consistency Firewall for Surgical Video Segmentation

Abstract

Temporal memory provides valuable context for online surgical video segmentatio, but most existing methods assume that the previous states remain relavant to the current scene. We find that this assumption can break under procedural context shifts. When the query memory is obtained from an incompatible procedural context, harmful temporal information can corrupt current predictions and recursively damage future states. Estimating memory utility with a generic indicator of does not fully resolve this problem, as such utility gate tends to be overly conservative and rejects useful history. Motivated by these observations, we propose a **Procedure-Consistency Memory Firewall** and a **Trustworthy Memory Writer**. The Procedure-Consistency Memory Firewall is a annotation-free, inference-time mechanism that compares the current frame procedure distribution with the provenance distribution attached to temporal memory. The Trustworthy Memory Writer determines whether the resulting state is sufficiently reliable to update trusted memory, limiting dirty context from propagating forward. Across a controlled suite of temporal interventions, our firewall selectively targets provenance mismatch rather than broadly suppressing temporal context. Our method clean performance under clean conditions while improving robustness under core stress by 6.31% and worst-case Dice by 32.77%, with the largest gain under cross-procedure mismatch. These results suggest that robust temporal reasoning depends not only on remembering the past, but also on verifying whether the memory is suitable before reuse and propagation.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
video segmentation, endoscopic surgery video

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_Af2NOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper asks when a surgical segmenter should trust the memory it is carrying. The gate is Jensen-Shannon divergence between the context distribution predicted from the current frame alone (surgical procedure on ATLAS, surgical phase on CholecSeg8k) and the distribution stored with the memory when it was admitted. The writer commits a decoded state only when a calibrated quality score passes. The authors present these two checks as a new provenance axis for temporal memory.

Critical strengths
  1. Holding the current frame fixed and changing only the memory is a clean way to ask whether the history, not the image, causes the error.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The provenance signal is the model's own context prediction, not a record of where the memory came from. To be fair, on ATLAS that prediction is discriminative enough for the swap: in Table 2 the gate fires on most cross-procedure reads (84.20%) and stays under 5% for every other intervention, with 0.24% on clean history. My concern is CholecSeg8k, where the context is surgical phase. The Discussion itself notes that phase labels are coarse provenance under gradual transitions, and adjacent phases change legitimately within one video, so this is where the gate is most likely to fire on valid history. Yet no trigger rates are reported for CholecSeg8k, and its test split is two videos (1,040 frames in 13 clips, Appendix A.1), so the second dataset cannot show that the separation holds when the context changes inside a procedure.
  2. Table 5 puts JS divergence (+6.17 Dice) between hard argmax (+6.10) and the ground-truth procedure label (+6.34). Almost all of the gain therefore comes from noticing that the predicted procedure changed, and the choice of divergence matters little. The memory readers in Section 2 already weight or admit stored states by match or uncertainty: STM weights reads by correspondence, and DMNet populates its global memory by uncertainty and frame similarity. The firewall applies the same kind of compatibility test to a procedure classifier's output, so the novelty rests on the choice of signal rather than on the mechanism.
  3. The contribution of the Trusted Memory Writer is not isolated. Section 4.4 reports that at the chosen threshold, write blocking and image-only recovery give the same cross-procedure gain, with recovery adding 0.14 clean Dice (31.77 to 31.91). I could not find a result for the firewall without the writer: Table 2 and the ablations all use the combined system. It is therefore unclear what the writer, listed as a separate contribution, adds beyond a reset to the image-only state.
  4. The transfer to other architectures is shown where the failure barely matters. In Table 8 the cross-procedure swap costs the native query memory 10.00 Dice (31.53 to 21.53), but only about 1.7 Dice for ConvGRU (28.52 to 26.79) and TMANet (28.04 to 26.31). The firewall recovers those small losses, which shows it does no harm, but it is weak evidence that provenance control is a general need for temporal segmenters rather than a fix for one model that relies heavily on propagated queries.
  5. The cross-procedure swap is the only intervention where the method matters; the others in Table 2 change Dice by at most 0.20. The paper describes the swap as a mechanism test and lists naturally occurring state failures as future work, so it shows no setting in which the targeted failure arises without being injected.
Questions for authors
  1. The writer's quality vector (Eq. 8) already uses class confidence, margin, entropy, and similarity between the current state and memory, while Table 5 compares only procedure-based criteria. Could the authors report a read-time gate built from these features, or from plain feature similarity between the current frame and memory, under the same threshold calibration? This would show whether the gain requires the predicted context distribution specifically.
  2. Could the authors report CholecSeg8k trigger rates on clean history, ideally broken down near phase transitions, and the result of the firewall without the Trusted Memory Writer?
Reviewer_BNJrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper examines a failure mode in temporal-memory-based surgical video segmentation, in which previously stored information can become harmful when incompatible with the current procedural context. The authors distinguish between memory quality and provenance compatibility and propose a Procedure-Compatibility Memory Firewall (PCMF) to prevent the use of mismatched historical information.

The firewall compares predicted procedure or surgical-phase distributions using Jensen–Shannon divergence and switches to an image-only prediction when a sufficiently confident mismatch is detected. A Trusted Memory Writer controls which newly generated states are retained for subsequent frames.

The method is evaluated on ATLAS-120K and CholecSeg8k using controlled memory interventions and several temporal architectures. The results show improved robustness to cross-context memory substitution, with little effect on segmentation performance under clean conditions.

Critical strengths
  1. An interesting and well-motivated problem.

The distinction between memory quality and contextual compatibility is a useful perspective on temporal segmentation. A memory state may contain reliable information but still be inappropriate for the current frame. This is particularly relevant in surgical videos, where changes in anatomy, instruments, and procedural context can affect the usefulness of previously stored features.

I also appreciate the separation between memory reading and writing. Associating provenance with the actual trusted memory state, rather than the most recent frame, is a sensible design choice that avoids inconsistencies when memory updates are rejected.

  1. Controlled evaluation with encouraging robustness results.

The experimental protocol is a strength of the paper. By modifying historical memory while keeping the current frame and segmentation target fixed, the authors can directly examine how incompatible temporal information affects predictions.

The improvement on ATLAS is notable: cross-procedure Global Dice increases from 21.53% to 28.59% for the query-memory model, while clean performance remains nearly unchanged. The evaluation across different temporal architectures also provides evidence that the approach is not restricted to a single memory representation.

The paired video-level bootstrap analysis is appreciated, as it accounts for correlations between frames within a video. The reported confidence intervals strengthen the empirical evidence for improvements under controlled cross-context interference.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The connection between the controlled interventions and naturally occurring temporal failures remains unclear.

My main concern is the practical significance of the evaluated failure mode. The largest improvements come from deliberately replacing historical memory with states from a different procedure or surgical phase. I understand that the authors present these interventions as a way to isolate the effect of incompatible memory, rather than as a direct simulation of clinical deployment. Nevertheless, it is unclear how often such mismatches occur in normal online segmentation.

In a continuous surgical video, memory is typically obtained from preceding frames of the same sequence. Changes in the surgical phase or scene appearance may be gradual, and previously observed information can remain useful despite these changes.

Table 2 illustrates the issue. Cross-procedure memory substitution produces a substantial gain of 7.06 Dice points, whereas the improvements under other perturbations, including query permutation, visual occlusion, and frame gaps, are much smaller. This supports the effectiveness of the proposed mechanism against a specific type of mismatch, but it leaves open the extent to which it improves robustness under naturally occurring conditions.

An analysis of real surgical-phase transitions, abrupt scene changes, or accumulated memory errors would make the practical contribution more convincing.

  1. Procedure-level consistency may not adequately capture memory relevance.

I have some reservations about using procedure or phase identity as the main indicator of memory compatibility. Two frames from the same procedure may show substantially different anatomy, instruments, or viewpoints. Conversely, frames from different procedural contexts may share relevant visual information.

The proposed compatibility measure, therefore, does not necessarily reflect whether a particular memory state will actually help the current segmentation. This is especially relevant for long sequences, where substantial changes may occur without any change in procedure identity.

The authors acknowledge that procedure and phase labels provide relatively coarse provenance information, but the evaluation does not fully investigate the consequences of this assumption. I would like to see an analysis of within-procedure scene changes and cases where the firewall accepts memory that is contextually consistent but visually irrelevant.

  1. The incremental contribution of the proposed components needs clearer experimental support.

The firewall uses a relatively simple context-consistency criterion followed by memory rejection. While the design is reasonable, its advantage over straightforward context-aware memory-reset strategies is not fully established.

In Table 5, the hard-argmax criterion already achieves a 6.10-point improvement under cross-procedure interference, compared with 6.17 points using Jensen–Shannon divergence. The JS-based criterion substantially reduces unnecessary triggers on clean data, which is useful, but the difference in segmentation performance is small.

I am also not entirely convinced that the experiments isolate the benefit of the Trusted Memory Writer. The writer estimates the reliability of the decoded state before updating memory, but it is difficult to determine how much of the reported improvement is attributable to this learned component rather than to the firewall and image-only recovery.

A clearer comparison with firewall-only protection, writer-only filtering, and simpler procedure-aware memory resets would help establish the necessity of the full framework. This matters for assessing the methodological contribution beyond the demonstrated robustness to incompatible memory.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors evaluate PCMF around naturally occurring procedure or phase transitions without manually substituting historical memory? How often does the firewall activate during ordinary inference, and does it improve recovery from actual segmentation errors?

  2. How does the method behave when the procedure identity remains unchanged but the visual scene changes substantially? Does agreement between procedure distributions reliably indicate that stored memory is useful for the current frame?

  3. Could the authors provide a direct comparison of the full framework against firewall-only protection, writer-only filtering, and a simple procedure-aware memory reset? This would help clarify which components are responsible for the observed gains in robustness.

  4. Equation (6) uses confidence thresholds to control memory rejection. What happens when the procedure classifier is confidently incorrect? It would be useful to report false acceptance and rejection rates, particularly near ambiguous surgical-phase transitions.

Reviewer_goxjOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a temporal memory management framework for surgical video segmentation, combining a provenance-consistency firewall and a trusted memory writer. Numerous experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the method that authors propose.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses the problem of temporal memory contamination in surgical video segmentation, where unreliable historical information can propagate errors across frames. This research question is very interesting, which is the most significant factor why I like this paper.

  2. The paper evaluates the framework under temporal stress conditions, aiming to assess robustness beyond standard segmentation accuracy.

  3. Although some weakness of writing in the following methodology and experiments parts, authors introduced their research questions and motivation very clearly.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Provenance-consistency firewall: Similar provenance distributions do not necessarily imply compatible scene states. For example, two surgical frames may look nearly identical while subtle changes in instrument–tissue interactions make historical memory misleading.
  2. Ablation of Trusted Memory Writer: Does the paper provide an ablation study isolating the contribution of the Trusted Memory Writer? Further ablation study should be conducted to verify the effectiveness of this component.
  3. Reliability of the Trust Score: The learned trust score may not reliably reflect actual segmentation quality, particularly under distribution shifts.Technical
  4. Minor: writing should be improved more to let readers capture the core ideas in a very short time. But this can not be a big problem.
Questions for authors

See in weakness part

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.