- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes EGMNet to address the long-term memory modeling problem in breast ultrasound video segmentation. The method consists of three modules: EME, which is based on continuous-time analytical updates; GMA, which is based on recursive least squares; and CMC, which is designed to reduce redundant tokens. Experiments demonstrate that this method achieves superior segmentation performance on the BUV-1K and BUV2022 datasets and exhibits certain advantages in terms of robustness and efficiency.
Critical strengths
1.The research problem is of practical significance. This paper addresses issues such as the temporary disappearance of lesions, changes in appearance, and long-term temporal consistency, demonstrating a clear research motivation.
2.The experimental results are competitive. The method achieved good segmentation performance on both datasets and demonstrated advantages in certain boundary metrics and video memory usage.
3.The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive. The authors provide module ablation, noise robustness, and temporal visualization experiments, which preliminarily validate the effectiveness of the overall framework.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The method’s independent innovation is not sufficiently clear.
EME’s continuous-time analytical update bears a strong resemblance to existing EFLA methods; GMA primarily employs the classical RLS algorithm; and CMC is closely related to common token compression strategies. It remains unclear where EGMNet’s core methodological innovations lie compared to these existing techniques. We recommend further clarifying the technical differences and including targeted comparative experiments.
W2. Some mathematical derivations and complexity analyses require further refinement.
It remains unclear whether GMA, after introducing additional coefficients into the standard RLS update, still corresponds to the exact optimal solution for the defined least-squares objective. Furthermore, Eq. (16) in CMC exhibits an issue with inconsistent matrix dimensions, and the computational complexity analysis in the appendix may have omitted operations related to . We recommend that the authors further review the mathematical derivations and clarify the actual computational cost.
W3. Direct experimental validation of the core mechanism is lacking.
The paper emphasizes that EME can prevent the accumulation of memory errors and improve re-recognition capabilities after lesion disappearance. However, the existing experiments primarily demonstrate final segmentation performance and noise robustness, without directly measuring long-term memory drift or the speed of target recovery. Furthermore, Figure 8 uses video splicing from different patients to simulate lesion disappearance and reappearance, which still differs from real clinical scenarios. We recommend supplementing the work with quantitative validation using real-world temporal events.
Questions for authors
1.What are the specific algorithmic differences between EME and existing EFLA methods?
2.Does the GMA update strictly satisfy the defined least-squares optimization objective? Could you further explain the related complexity analysis?
3.Could you provide experiments that directly quantify the accumulation of memory errors and the recovery rate for lesion re-identification?
Response to Reviewer
We thank the reviewer for the comments. We have clarified the implementation details and added additional comparisons in our response. We would appreciate it if the reviewer could confirm whether these clarifications address the main concerns.