- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes RASM, an iterative framework for left ventricle segmentation from cardiac MRI. RASM progressively refines the segmentation through parameter-shared state transitions, adaptive anatomical feature refinement, and multi-stage deep supervision. Experiments on the ACDC dataset show improved segmentation and boundary accuracy over the evaluated baselines.
Critical strengths
-
Clear and practically motivated iterative refinement framework. The paper addresses a meaningful limitation of one-pass segmentation by explicitly refining intermediate predictions through parameter-shared state transitions. The overall design is intuitive and well aligned with the challenges of ambiguous cardiac boundaries.
-
Consistent empirical improvements with reasonable efficiency. RASM achieves the best results among the evaluated baselines on ACDC across both overlap and boundary metrics. The ablation studies also show consistent gains from the proposed components.
Critical weaknesses
-
The formulation is not technically convincing. The paper defines the segmentation state as a probability map, e.g., , and then updates it as . Under this formulation, even when the predicted residual is zero, i.e., , the state still changes because in general. This seems inconsistent with the claimed residual/self-correcting interpretation, where a zero correction should ideally preserve the current prediction. Relatedly, the stability statement in Section 5.1, which claims that implies , does not directly follow from the stated update rule. The convergence discussion in Section 5.3 is also weak: applying a shared transition operator for a fixed number of iterations guarantees termination, but does not by itself establish convergence. This issue directly concerns the mathematical consistency of the proposed iterative mechanism and is therefore a major factor in my negative overall assessment.
-
The empirical evidence is not yet sufficient to support the claimed novelty and generality of the framework. The experiments are limited to binary LV segmentation on a single dataset, ACDC, with 100 subjects under five-fold cross-validation. This is relatively narrow for a method presented as a general iterative segmentation paradigm. In addition, the comparison set mainly includes U-Net, UNet++, TransUNet, Swin-Unet, MISSFormer, and nnU-Net, while more recent segmentation baselines are not evaluated. The strongest gain over Swin-Unet is also modest in Dice. This limits my confidence that the proposed framework offers a broadly meaningful improvement beyond the specific benchmark considered, which further contributes to my weak-reject assessment.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors clarify the intended interpretation of the update , especially since is already a probability map and a zero residual still changes the state?
-
What is the key technical distinction between RASM and standard recurrent/iterative refinement methods, and which specific component justifies the terms “reasoning,” “memory,” and “self-correction”?
-
Can the authors provide stage-wise results for within the same refinement trajectory to directly demonstrate that successive iterations consistently correct previous segmentation errors?