- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CTKAN, which introduces recurrent updates to spline activities before aggregation in Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks. The method is evaluated on four medical image segmentation datasets and shows improvements over U-KAN and several other variants.
Critical strengths
The idea of updating spline activities before aggregation is interesting. The paper is clearly presented and includes several useful ablation studies. I also appreciate the comparisons with one-shot modulation and post-KAN recurrence, which help explain the proposed design.
Critical weaknesses
-
My main concern is the dataset splitting protocol. The paper states that the datasets are split at the image level. For ACDC, images from the same patient may appear in different subsets, while CVC-ClinicDB contains correlated frames from the same video sequences. The paper does not clearly explain whether patient-level or sequence-level separation was enforced. This could substantially affect the reliability of the reported results.
-
Although the authors provide several useful ablations and the implementation of the proposed mechanism, it remains unclear whether the additional gains come specifically from recurrent state evolution or from increased adaptive computation. A stronger non-recurrent baseline with comparable parameters or inference cost would make the contribution more convincing. The synthetic experiment also shows that a simple pre-aggregation MLP can solve the constructed task, which raises questions about the necessity of the recurrent mechanism.
Questions for authors
-
Were the ACDC and CVC-ClinicDB datasets split at the patient and video sequence levels, respectively? If not, can the authors provide results with group-disjoint splits?
-
Can the authors compare CTKAN with a parameter-matched or latency-matched non-recurrent adaptive KAN?
-
Could the authors provide the dataset split assignments and training scripts to support reproducibility?