- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
VERSA is a compact volumetric segmentation architecture combining spatially routed bidirectional axis-wise RWKV propagation with anisotropic convolutional context. Its prediction head shares convolutional shell responses across nested support experts and combines them through class/spatial routing and disagreement-modulated refinement. The paper evaluates the method across 12 datasets and studies its modules in other architectures. The main contribution is a specific, efficient organization of existing contextual modeling components with broad empirical support.
Critical strengths
-
Useful and compact architectural integration. The two routing stages address complementary choices: how context propagates and which supports inform a prediction. Shared projections and shell responses keep the model compact at 3.67M parameters, while module insertion experiments support usefulness beyond the proposed backbone.
-
Broad empirical support. Dice improvements across 12 datasets are reinforced by same-candidate aggregation controls, five-seed comparisons on two datasets, five-fold COVID evaluation, paired case-level statistics, and external LiTS evaluation. These complementary checks support the practical value of the combination, even though not every mechanistic interpretation is fully isolated.
Critical weaknesses
None that presently outweigh the demonstrated architectural and empirical contribution. Uniform-axis controls do not separate spatial adaptation from learned static calibration, and the support-geometry comparison changes parameter sharing. These qualify attribution rather than invalidate the complete system; additional fine-grained ablations are not prerequisites for acceptance.
Questions for authors
Clarifications that could affect the scope of the assessment:
- Please state the specific technical distinction from the closest volumetric U-RWKV design discussed in Section 2. The novelty of the concrete routing organization matters more than claiming directional propagation itself is new.
- Please clarify validation/checkpoint selection and patient-level partitioning across methods. The existing results support weak acceptance; this question concerns whether the comparative protocol supports that interpretation, not a presumption that it is compromised.
4 comments
2. Please clarify validation/checkpoint selection and patient-level partitioning across methods. The existing results support weak acceptance; this question concerns whether the comparative protocol supports that interpretation, not a presumption that it is compromised.
We thank the reviewer for raising this point. The per-dataset train/test counts are already reported in Table A.1 (Appendix of the manuscript). Here, we clarify how these fixed partitions were used for validation and checkpoint selection. For every method, we used the same fixed patient-level (or subject-level) train/test partition. Within the training partition, we created a deterministic 90/10 train/validation split at the patient/subject level before patch extraction, rather than at the patch or slice level. The resulting patient-level split was identical for VERSA and all baselines in the controlled comparison. We evaluated the validation set every 2,000 Steps and selected the checkpoint with the highest foreground Dice. The selected checkpoint was then frozen and evaluated on the test set. Therefore, all methods (except nnU-Net) in the controlled comparison used identical patient partitions, preprocessing, validation frequency, checkpoint-selection criterion, random seed, and 320,000 Steps training budget. nnU-Net was evaluated using the official nnU-Net protocol while retaining the same patient-level data partition. The complete data split, including the training, validation, and held-out test cases was therefore consistent with that used for VERSA.
We hope that the clarified distinction from U-RWKV and the additional details on patient-level splitting, validation, and checkpoint selection have addressed your remaining questions. If so, we would sincerely appreciate it if you would consider increasing your rating in support of our work.
Thank you for clarifying the distinction from U-RWKV and the patient-level split and checkpoint selection protocol. The direct U-RWKV comparison strengthens the evidence for VERSA as a complete system. The learned static weighting control was especially helpful: it shows that a global axis preference accounts for part of the gain, with spatial adaptation providing a further improvement on the tested task. Together with the four-way ablation, this addresses my main concerns. I remain at weak acceptance, with greater confidence in the contribution of the two-stage design.
Thank you for recognizing our clarifications and the strengthened evidence for VERSA. We are pleased that the direct U-RWKV comparison, learned static weighting control, and four-way ablation addressed your concerns and increased confidence in our design. We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful assessment and constructive feedback.
1. Please state the specific technical distinction from the closest volumetric U-RWKV design discussed in Section 2. The novelty of the concrete routing organization matters more than claiming directional propagation itself is new.
We thank the reviewer for asking us to clarify this distinction. As shown in Table R16, the key distinction is that U-RWKV relies on fixed, spatially shared tri-axis propagation and fusion, whereas VERSA introduces explicit, input-dependent routing of propagation axes and receptive supports according to spatial location, together with class- and location-conditioned routing of prediction experts.
Table R16: Technical distinction between U-RWKV and VERSA.
To verify that this organization matters, we added a direct comparison with U-RWKV (Table R17) on 12 public benchmarks using matched preprocessing, data splits, and evaluation metrics. VERSA improves IoU and Dice on all 12 datasets and reduces HD95 on 11 of 12 datasets. Our controlled ablations (Table 4 and Table 9 in the Manuscript) provide additional evidence for the routing interpretation. These results indicate that the gains arise from adaptive routing and support selection.
Table R17: Quantitative comparison with U-RWKV on 12 public 3D segmentation benchmarks.