- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In this work the authors focus on the protein mechanical unfolding and propose a generative approach to reconstruct the unfolding trajectory using conditioned stochastic interpolation and directly enforcing the mechanical constraint of the problem and show how this customization of the solution to the problem at hand results in better generation compared to models built for generic thermodynamic motion instead. The paper contributes a new application space, as unfolding is not widely targeted by practitioners of generative MD despite its biological relevance, a new benchmark dataset, and a new approach to embed mechanical admissability into the model design.
Critical strengths
- Novel approach, bringing attention to an application area of biological relevance that has not been widely targeted by the community yet.
- Embedding the stationary state of the first residue, and the fact that protein monotonically extends into the design. Model shows success, the comparison to MD is sound.
- Significant effort in defining a benchmark and setting a baseline (altho it is not clear if the data is available)
Critical weaknesses
- The comparison to models that were not built for unfolding, especially for mechanical admissibility, does not make the most fair comparison although this may be acceptable given the limited baseline availability. However text should be crystal clear in the comparison.
- The design embeds the well known property of the physical system, an inductive bias, into the model and shows the gains in consistency thanks to having to represent a simplified space. Practically makes sense altho may need to be defended for generalizability. One option is to propose that every driven process gets its own model design, another option is to find flexible, generalizable representation of external drivers to biomolecule motion.
EDIT: see discussion. rating increased accordingly.
Questions for authors
It would be great to understand the data availability statement.
3 comments
Thanks to authors for their work. I have also been following the responses to other reviewers as well and am happy to see expanded literature, increased rigor in checking data leak in train/test sets, and generalizability claims. The ability to reconstruct the fine-grain conformation is a relevant question as well, let me extend my thanks to reviewer wk2x for that. I think the manuscript quality increased significantly. I hope to see an explicit mention of the zero-shot test on DysN-R3 wrt wetlab SM-FM result on branching probability, either in the appendix or main text in the camera ready version of the work.
I appreciate the added wording in the Conclusion about where this method can extend to (a driven process with affine boundary constraints and an ordered low dim reaction coord). I believe it will help the community to think more creatively about driven processes. The pulling experiment is perhaps the low hanging fruit here but given the impact and data generation effort, it is a good starting point.
I thank the authors also for adding the data availability statement.
I increase my score accordingly to a clear accept.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful follow-up, for reading our responses to the other reviewers, and for raising the score to a clear acceptance. Your comments throughout the discussion have substantially improved the manuscript, and we are grateful for your engagement. We hope our paper encourages the community to explore more driven molecular processes, and we are actively pursuing some of these directions ourselves. We also thank Reviewer wk2x for raising the question of fine-grained conformational reconstruction and generalization, which helped strengthen the paper.
Thank you again for your time, constructive feedback, and support of this work.
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the novelty of introducing generative modeling to a biologically important yet underexplored domain, the effectiveness of embedding mechanical constraints into the model design, and our significant effort in establishing an unfolding trajectory benchmark. We address your concerns below:
W1: Baseline Fairness & Clarity of Comparison: "The comparison to models that were not built for unfolding, especially for mechanical admissibility, does not make the most fair comparison although this may be acceptable given the limited baseline availability. However text should be crystal clear in the comparison."
Response: We thank the reviewer for this comment and appreciate the opportunity to clarify the extensive efforts we made to ensure a rigorous and fair evaluation. To our knowledge, no existing generative model targets structural trajectories of mechanical unfolding under a prescribed pulling geometry. We therefore adapted the strongest available general-purpose protein dynamics generators (MDGen, 4D-Diffusion, and TEMPO) under a strictly controlled protocol (Appendix F.4). To keep the comparison as fair as possible within this scope, all methods use the same dataset, protein-level splits, selected progress states, conditioning inputs, and evaluation pipeline. Furthermore, to eliminate any architectural differences across baselines and achieve a controlled comparison, we conducted a dedicated geometric representation ablation (Table 2) that holds the exact backbone architecture, training objective, and data fixed while varying only the generative coordinates.
More fundamentally, as analyzed in Remark 1, although unconstrained ambient-space models can in principle learn mechanical constraints from training trajectories that satisfy the constraints as interpolation noise vanishes (t→1), doing so from finite data diverts modeling capacity away from capturing unfolding dynamics, which both fails to guarantee admissibility and degrades overall structural and distributional fidelity. Consequently, our central claims do NOT rest on admissibility metrics, but are also supported by constraint-independent metrics that evaluate the quality of generated unfolding trajectories without directly measuring mechanical constraint violations. On these metrics, MechPath outperforms the strongest baselines by 27% on PA-RMSD (13.06 vs. 17.95), 25% on FPD (21.31 vs. 28.40), and 52% on PCA-JSD (0.13 vs. 0.27) (Table 1). We have modified Section 4.1 (Baselines) and Section 4.2 to make this scope crystal clear.
W2. Inductive Bias & Generalizability to Driven Processes: "The design embeds the well known property of the physical system, an inductive bias, into the model... Practically makes sense altho may need to be defended for generalizability. One option is to propose that every driven process gets its own model design, another option is to find flexible, generalizable representation of external drivers to biomolecule motion."
Response: We appreciate this valuable perspective and agree it is the right question for the broader direction of this work. Our view sits between the two options the reviewer outlines. The construction is not specific to unfolding. It applies whenever an external driver imposes (i) linear constraints on the system (e.g., fixed sites) and (ii) a monotone scalar progress along a reaction coordinate. In MechPath the driver enters only through the pulling specification π, via the covector cπ, the carrier bπ and the projection Pπ. The network architecture itself is driver-agnostic. As a result, changing the attachment residues or the pulling direction needs no architectural change, because these quantities are recomputed from π for each input. More broadly, our progress–conformation decomposition can potentially generalize to many other externally driven biomolecular processes where a driver imposes affine boundary constraints and ordered progress along a low-dimensional reaction coordinate. While our current benchmark focuses on a single constant-velocity terminal pulling setup to establish a clean baseline for protein unfolding, we have explicitly integrated this broader perspective into Section 5 Conclusion.
Q1: Data Availability Statement.
For the SMD benchmark, we will host the SMD datasets on Zenodo and Hugging Face Datasets under a CC BY 4.0 license immediately if the article is accepted and upon publication. We have added an explicit Data Availability Statement alongside the Reproducibility Statement in the revised manuscript to guarantee public access.