- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3(+1)
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents DuET-MD, a training-free steering method for rare event sampling using frozen, pretrained generative MD surrogates. DuET-MD adopts a dual-clock particle inference scheme, which first generates candidates from a guided proposal using biasing potentials during the reverse diffusion process, and then resamples the predicted structures in the outer loop. This formulation enables sampling from low-density regions of the original proposal distribution with theoretical guarantees, while also preserving the dynamical behavior of the pretrained MD surrogate. Experiments on protein folding and cryptic pocket opening tasks show consistent improvement over the complete-frame Nested-SMC control method in rare-event sampling.
Critical strengths
- Rare-event sampling is a critical challenge in generative molecular dynamics and cannot, in principle, be fully addressed by models that learn only finite-lag transition dynamics. This work presents a training-free method to address this problem and achieves consistent improvements across experiments, making it a valuable contribution to the field.
Critical weaknesses
- The manuscript, particularly the Method section, could be substantially improved in terms of writing and clarity, as the current presentation is difficult to follow. For example, (i) The abstract and introduction both refer to the term "clocks", which is neither standard terminology in the field nor clearly defined before Eq. (2). This makes the presentation difficult to understand. (ii) The symbol in Eq. (2) is not explicitly defined, although it can be inferred from the context that it denotes the random variable associated with the reverse diffusion process. (iii) The term "checkpoint" first appears in Line 216 but is never explicitly defined. Since this concept is important for understanding the discussion in this paragraph, the authors should provide a clear definition when it is first introduced. (iv) Line 217 uses , whereas Eq. (2) uses . My understanding is that the subscript denotes one of the internal particles, while denote the physical time and the diffusion time, respectively. Mixing these different subscripts without clarification can easily cause confusion, so the notation should be defined and used consistently.
Questions for authors
- My main concern is the issue of readability and clarity of presentation mentioned in the Weakness section. I believe the authors should carefully revise the manuscript, after which I would be willing to reconsider and potentially raise my score.
- Sections 4.2 and 4.3 are central to the proposed method, yet it is still difficult to accurately understand the overall inference procedure from the textual description alone. Given that the main text has not yet reached the page limit, I would suggest adding a workflow diagram or pseudocode in the Method section to help readers better understand the working pipeline.
- Line 701 is the first place where the guidance strength is introduced. Based on Section 4.2, it looks like the guided proposal is constructed using the gradient of the biasing potential during generation. However, I could not find a clear description elsewhere in the manuscript of how specifically enters the inference procedure. I believe the authors should provide a more explicit explanation and revise the manuscript to improve the clarity of the presentation.
- I noticed that Enhanced Diffusion Sampling [1] also performs rare-event sampling by applying a Feynman-Kac corrector to the diffusion model. Could the authors provide a comparison between this prior work and the proposed method in terms of methodology and experimental performance?
- In Table 2, for the PRMT6 case, the improvement in the fpocket DS metric is limited and even appears to be worse than that of the frozen model. Could the authors provide a case-specific analysis to explain why this occurs?
References
[1] Xie, Y., Winkler, L., Sun, L., Lewis, S., Foster, A., Jimenez-Luna, J., Hempel, T., Gastegger, M., Chen, Y., Zaporozhets, I., Clementi, C., Bishop, C. M., & Noé, F. (2026). Enhanced diffusion sampling: Efficient rare event sampling and free energy calculation with diffusion models. In ICML 2026 Workshop on Structured Probabilistic Inference & Generative Modeling.