- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper targets the scarcity of experimentally resolved molecular-glue (MG) ternary complexes. It begins with binary protein–ligand structures, partitions a single protein chain into two components under secondary-structure and fragment-length constraints, and retains synthetic ternary complexes whose contact statistics match distributions derived from the MG-PDB reference set. The resulting resource contains more than 100 000 structures. The authors compare ligand properties, interaction profiles, and buried-surface-area statistics against experimental complexes, then train the diffusion generator TSeaDiff on the synthetic data. On held-out, locally perturbed synthetic pockets, TSeaDiff yields protein–ligand interaction (PLI) profiles closer to the MG-PDB reference than the evaluated baselines.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is well founded. Experimentally resolved MG ternary structures remain limited (MG-PDB contains 221 complexes), and a substantially larger structural resource can support pre-training and hypothesis generation for ligand-mediated protein–protein interfaces.
- The construction pipeline is described with sufficient detail for understanding. Source filtering (BioLiP2 small-molecule subset, ligand size 10–74 heavy atoms, contact-coverage threshold, exclusion of short contacts suggestive of clashes or covalent linkage), protein-chain partitioning constraints, and MG-PDB-referenced contact selection are all specified.
- Evaluation examines multiple structural descriptors rather than size alone, and the authors explicitly note that the proxy metrics do not establish molecular-glue activity in biological systems and that the partitioned protein components are not guaranteed to fold independently.
Critical weaknesses
- The principal similarity analysis is partly circular. Synthetic structures are retained precisely because their contact patterns match the MG-PDB reference distribution; the same reference is then used to quantify how closely the synthetic set resembles experimental complexes. Agreement is therefore expected by construction, even if the partitioned fragments do not recapitulate the biology of genuine MG assembly. A held-out portion of the experimental reference would substantially strengthen the claim.
- Structural validation of the synthetic complexes remains limited. Partitioning one continuous protein chain into two fragments can generate an interface between sequence-contiguous regions that do not exist as separate chains in nature. The paper itself states that the resulting components are not guaranteed to fold independently. Independent checks of fragment foldability, interface stability, steric clashes at the newly created interface, and post-construction relaxation would be required before the structures can be treated as realistic ternary hypotheses; if a substantial fraction fail such filters, the usable size of the resource should be reported.
- The generator is assessed only on synthetic pockets drawn from a held-out partition of TSea and on proxy metrics (clash rate, valid yield, Vina scores, PLI-profile distance, HDR99 inclusion). Because the training distribution was deliberately constructed to imitate the reference, a favorable PLI-profile distance may partly reflect the selection rule rather than genuine generalization. Evaluation on experimentally resolved MG ternary complexes, ideally with baselines trained under matched data budgets, is needed to establish practical utility.
Questions for authors
- Can the MG-PDB reference distribution used for contact-based selection be fitted on one subset of the experimental complexes and the similarity statistics evaluated on a disjoint held-out subset?
- Which independent structural or energetic checks demonstrate that the partitioned fragments and the interfaces between them are physically plausible (e.g., predicted folding propensity, interface energy after relaxation, clash statistics)?
- How does TSeaDiff perform when conditioned on experimental MG ternary pockets, relative to baselines trained on comparable quantities of data?
3 comments
Response to Reviewer Wmvd Part 2/2
Response to Weakness 2/ Question 2
Thank you for highlighting this. We perform independent fragment prediction, binary and ternary complex prediction, and post-construction relaxation.
Fragment structure recovery. We use ESMFold2 to predict each fragment independently. Among 212,175 fragments, 135,792 (64.00%) achieve TM-score against their corresponding reference conformations. For 42,363 candidates, both fragments meet this criterion when predicted separately, representing 39.80% of the full 106,436-candidate resource.
Complex and interface recovery. We additionally predict two-protein AB complexes and ABL ternary complexes. Among 89,813 systems evaluated under all three prediction conditions, the proportion of fragment chains achieving TM-score increase from 66.15% in separate monomer predictions to 79.76% in binary predictions and 83.86% in ternary predictions. Across 89,804 systems with interface measurements available for both binary and ternary predictions, median A–B interface C$\alpha$ RMSDs are 1.464 and 1.146 , respectively.
Relaxation and energetic assessment. We apply the same ligand-present relaxation protocol to TSea and MG-PDB and score A–B interfaces before and after relaxation, obtaining paired results for 64,565/106,436 and 208/221 complexes, respectively. Values below are medians, with scores shown before after relaxation and chain B RMSD measured after chain A alignment. Among successfully evaluated complexes, median structural adjustments are comparable between TSea and the MG-PDB reference.
| Metric | TSea | MG-PDB |
|---|---|---|
| Interface score (REU/100 ) | ||
| Chain B RMSD () | 1.52 | 1.52 |
| A–B contact retention (%) | 58.45 | 51.15 |
We do not perform a separate clash check during construction because partitioning the experimental complexes preserves the coordinates of all retained atoms and therefore introduces no new steric clashes at the A–B interface.
Together, these analyses provide complementary support for fragment conformational recovery, recovery of the proposed interface geometry, and local energetic compatibility.
Response to Weakness 3/ Question 3.
Thank you for raising this point. To assess performance beyond synthetic pockets, we evaluate TSeaDiff and the baselines on 88 experimentally resolved MG ternary complexes from MGBench, which are not included in TSeaDiff’s training data. For each model, we perform 20 generation attempts per structure and evaluate the generated molecules using the same protocol in the manuscript.
As shown in tables below, TSeaDiff achieves the lowest PLI-profile distance (0.155), the lowest clash rate (0.42%), and the highest HDR99 inclusion rate (99.43%) among the evaluated models. These results support the generalization of TSeaDiff from synthetic training pockets to experimentally resolved MG systems.
Regarding training-data scale, the TargetDiff and DiffSBDD baselines each use 100,000 protein–ligand training pairs, and their training datasets are comparable in size to that of TSeaDiff. Compared with these two baselines, TSeaDiff shows better performance on the MG-related metrics highlighted above, while maintaining a valid yield comparable to TargetDiff and higher than DiffSBDD.
For general molecular quality, TSeaDiff shows less favorable QED and synthetic accessibility than TargetDiff and DiffSBDD, while maintaining comparable molecular diversity and uniqueness. This may reflect the emphasis of TSeaDiff’s training data on ternary interaction compatibility, which does not necessarily translate into better general drug-likeness or synthetic accessibility. Improving these properties while preserving favorable ternary-pocket interactions is therefore an important direction for the future work.
Overall, the MGBench evaluation shows that TSeaDiff maintains favorable performance on MG-related computational metrics in experimentally resolved ternary pockets, relative to baselines trained on comparable amounts of data.
| Model | Clash (%) ↓ | Valid (%) ↑ | Full-pocket Vina | Weaker-side Vina | PLI dist. ↓ | HDR99 (%) ↑ | QED ↑ | SA ↓ | Diversity ↑ | Uniqueness (%) ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TSeaDiff | 0.42 | 80.0 | 0.155 | 99.43 | 100.00 | |||||
| PocketXMol | 0.45 | 88.5 | 0.222 | 98.33 | 99.60 | |||||
| TargetDiff | 5.02 | 80.6 | 0.179 | 87.39 | 100.00 | |||||
| DiffSBDD | 11.37 | 59.4 | 0.216 | 90.05 | 100.00 | |||||
| ODesign A/B | 8.29 | 90.5 | 0.344 | 77.28 | 99.94 | |||||
| ODesign merged | 8.63 | 90.3 | 0.335 | 82.50 | 99.94 |
Looking Forward to Your Feedback
Dear Reviewer Wmvd,
We have revised the relevant sections of the manuscript and posted point-by-point responses to your comments. We would appreciate your feedback on the revisions and our responses, and would be happy to clarify any remaining questions.
Thank you again for your time and consideration.
Best regards,
The Authors
Response to Reviewer Wmvd Part 1/2
Response to Weakness 1/ Question 1
We thank the reviewer for highlighting this limitation. Given the scarcity of experimentally determined MG ternary structures, our original construction uses the full MG-PDB reference to make the most of the available structural information. To address this concern, we reconstruct the synthetic dataset with disjoint experimental sets for reference fitting and evaluation, and reassess its similarity to experimental complexes. We also examine whether the reconstructed dataset retains its utility for downstream generation.
First, we separate the experimental complexes used for reference fitting from those used for evaluation. Specifically, we use MGBench, the predefined 88-complex subset of MG-PDB, as the held-out evaluation set. Excluding these 88 complexes from the 221-complex MG-PDB reference leaves 133 complexes for fitting the contact distribution. Feature standardization, KDE bandwidth selection, and HDR estimation are all based exclusively on these remaining 133 complexes. Using this refitted reference, we then select synthetic complexes while keeping the other construction criteria unchanged, obtaining 102,538 synthetic complexes.
We evaluate the resulting collection using the PLI/PPI profile definitions and fixed-pose Vina scoring protocol described in the manuscript. For each collection, we recompute PLI and PPI distances against MGBench and also report distances to the full MG-PDB reference to connect this analysis with the original results. As shown in the table below, the reconstructed collection achieves PLI/PPI distances to MGBench of 0.938/1.064, comparable to those of the original TSea collection (0.949/1.080) and lower than those of TernaryDB (1.454/1.370). Its Vina summaries likewise remain close to those of the original collection. These results indicate that the closer interaction-profile agreement with experimental MG complexes observed in our original analysis is maintained when the evaluation complexes are excluded from reference fitting.
Second, we assess whether the reconstructed dataset retains its utility for downstream generation. We train a new TSeaDiff model from scratch using the reconstructed dataset and perform 20 generation attempts for each of the 88 MGBench complexes excluded from reference fitting. For all models, we recalculate generation PLI distances using MGBench as the reference.
As shown in the table below, the retrained model achieves a PLI distance of 0.198, comparable to that of the original TSeaDiff (0.236) and lower than those of the other evaluated methods (0.326–0.460). Its weak-side Vina score and Vina centrality also remain comparable to those of the original TSeaDiff. These results support the retention of MG-relevant interaction characteristics in molecules generated using the reconstructed training data.
Together, these experiments show that TSea’s interaction-profile agreement is maintained against held-out experimental MG complexes that do not contribute to fitting the contact-selection reference. The downstream generation results further support the ability of the reconstructed dataset to capture MG-relevant interaction features that a generative model can learn.