- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces Molweaver, which jointly models target pockets, molecular sequences, and 3D coordinates. This considers autoregressive-based generation for molecular sequences and flow matching-based generation for 3D coordinates. This further studies PPO and Flow-DPO for target-specific online optimization. The authors evaluate Molweaver on ligand pose prediction and pocket-conditioned molecule generation, showing competitive performance and consistent improvements with model scaling from 60M to 500M parameters.
Critical strengths
-
Practical target-specific optimization. The paper considers an online fine-tuning method given a target using relatively cheap labels. This can be a new practical recipe for adapting binder generative models to new targets.
-
Strong performance and consistent scaling benefits. The model achieves competitive or superior performance against models with expensive architectures, e.g., Pairformer in UniMol2, with consistent improvements as model size increases, supporting the potential of scalable approaches for SBDD.
Critical weaknesses
None
Questions for authors
-
During inference, the model is optimized for each target pocket using PPO and DPO. How much computational budget does this require? Can the authors comment on the computational cost with respect to the baselines?
-
How does the model perform without PPO and DPO? I was wondering about some ablations that show how much they contribute to the performance.
2 comments
Thank you for detailed clarification. I'd like to maintain my positive assessment.
Response to reviewer `HBMt`
We sincerely thank the reviewer HBMt for the positive assessment of our work and for recognizing the practical value of target-specific optimization and the consistent improvements with model scaling. We have also made the edits to the paper with the changes highlighted in blue. We address the questions below.
Q1: Computational cost of target-specific PPO and Flow-DPO optimization
We thank the reviewer for asking us to clarify the computational budget. We have added the optimization protocol in Section 5.2 and added computational cost estimates in Appendix B.5. PPO and Flow-DPO each run for 200 optimizer steps with batch size 8, using examples shuffled across all 100 evaluation pockets. Within each stage, model parameters are shared across pockets. Each stage therefore involves 1,600 pocket-example appearances, averaging 16 appearances per pocket.
For Molweaver-500M, the estimated model-optimization cost across both stages is 11.4 EFLOPs in total, corresponding to an amortized cost of 114 PFLOPs per pocket over the 100-pocket evaluation. These estimates exclude reward evaluation and inference-time sampling. CPU-based evaluation of Vina Score and Vina Dock rewards remains the main computational bottleneck.
Q2: Performance without PPO and Flow-DPO
We have added ablation experiments in Appendix B.5 (Table 7) to examine the individual contributions of PPO, Flow-DPO, and auxiliary-property pretraining using Molweaver-60M.
Table: Ablation of PPO, Flow-DPO, and property-aware pretraining for Molweaver-60M (Appendix B.5, Table 7). Vina Score and Vina Dock are reported as mean values, and strain as the median.
The ablation results show that PPO primarily improves molecular generation by steering the model toward molecules with more favorable docking scores, drug-likeness, and synthetic accessibility. Adding Flow-DPO further improves pose quality and physical plausibility, leading to higher PB validity, lower ligand strain, and fewer clashes, while also improving direct Vina scores.
We additionally observe that including auxiliary-property prediction during pretraining improves QED, SA, and Vina Dock scores compared with pretraining without this objective. These results demonstrate the complementary roles of PPO in optimizing molecular properties, Flow-DPO in refining ligand poses, and property-aware pretraining in improving downstream molecular-generation performance.
We hope these clarifications and additional ablations address the reviewer's questions.