- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces DecFlowEdit, a training-free and inversion-free image editing method, that is based on the FlowEdit paper. The authors identified that there is a coupling between guidance strength, editing localization, and effective semantic changes. Therefore, they propose to use an estimation of the intended editing region using the velocity difference between the target and the source without the CFG, and leveraging the original CFG parameters as the editing itself, i.e. the estimated editing region is a mask multiplied elementwise by the original velocity difference of FlowEdit. The authors show their method’s effectiveness on the PIE-Bench leveraging 3 models (SD3, SD3.5 and FLUX), especially for source image preservation.
Critical strengths
- The results obtained are nice.
- The observation of the CFG is simple and nice.
- The presentation is clear.
Critical weaknesses
- The method uses additional NFEs than other methods. While the trend is to reduce the computations (such as FireFlow [1], UniEdit [2], and FlowAlign [3]), the authors suggest increasing the total computations to achieve better results. It would be interesting to see a matched-budget NFEs comparison between all methods.
- A user study would be beneficial to assess the method.
- The observation regarding the CFG is nice and simple. However, by reading the Abstract and the Introduction I expected that the method would also be simple and utilize as a mask only the velocities difference, while in practice the method utilizes some other ``engineering’’ parts and hyperparameters (such as and in Eqs. 2 and 4).
- It would be interesting to see the sensitivity of the hyperparameters for other resolutions than (PIE-Bench), e.g. FlowEdit benchmark ().
- Many competing methods are missing in the quantitative comparison (Table 1) on FLUX model and in the qualitative comparison, such as UniEdit [2], FireFlow [1], etc.
- There are only 4 qualitative comparisons (Figure 1). To assess the method ability and versatility to edit other types of editing, e.g. style modification.
- Many other methods already utilize masks in the FlowEdit algorithm such as [4], [5], [6], reducing the novelty of the DecFlowEdit. A comparison to inversion-free methods such as [4-6] would be beneficial to assess the method.
The manuscript presents very solid and visually compelling results, demonstrating that the proposed modifications to FlowEdit lead to practical improvements. However, the conceptual and technical delta relative to FlowEdit remains primarily incremental. Because the contribution is essentially an effective refinement rather than a foundational new framework or a substantial technical leap, to my opinion, it may not meet the bar for the main conference track. I think that the strong empirical findings and practical insights would make this a good contribution to a workshop.
[1] Deng, Yingying, et al. "Fireflow: Fast inversion of rectified flow for image semantic editing." (ICML’25)
[2] Jiao, Guanlong, et al. "Uniedit-flow: Unleashing inversion and editing in the era of flow models." (ICLR’26)
[3] Kim, Jeongsol, et al. "Flowalign: Trajectory-regularized, inversion-free flow-based image editing." (ICLR’26)
[4] Cui, Haowang, et al. "SAM-Flow: Source-Anchored Masked Flow for Training-Free Image Editing." (arXiv’06.26)
[5] Chen, Jili, et al. "SMART-Edit: Spectral Mutual Attention Refinement and fusion for precise training-free image editing." Pattern Recognition (2026)
[6] Vu, Trong-Tai Dam, and Vinh-Tiep Nguyen. "MaskFlow: Attention-Guided Localized Editing for Rectified Flow Models." 2026 International Conference on Multimedia Analysis and Pattern Recognition (MAPR). IEEE, 2026.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.