- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Phy-DiffKAN to tackle age–stage physiological inconsistency in conditional sleep EEG generation. Phy-DiffKAN constructs a factorized physiological prior field comprising 12 interpretable coordinates and organizes age, recorded sex, sleep stage, and their pairwise interactions into six condition branches. Under the strict setting that all models are evaluated on the same subject-disjoint Sleep-EDF cohort with equal subject allocation across age strata, near-balanced recorded sex, and complete per-subject stage coverage, the Phy-DiffKAN achieved promising results.
Critical strengths
S1: The authors formulate age–stage physiological inconsistency in sleep EEG, which I found to be an interesting and potentially useful setting.
S2: The results are meaningful, revealing that similar overall generation quality can correspond to substantially different age–stage behaviors.
Critical weaknesses
W1: The experiment is limited to a small dataset. I would like to see how it performs on larger datasets. Sleep EEG is not rare, so testing only on a small number of subjects from a single dataset is questionable.
W2: I found it hard to understand the motivation for generating sleep EEG, because sleep EEG is easy to collect. And there are many sleep EEG datasets out there.
Questions for authors
What is the motivation to generate sleep EEG data?
What is the model performance for some large-scale sleep EEG datasets, like HMC and Dreem datasets?
Does the model performance largely depend on the number of channels in sleep EEG, as it may vary from one to many?
Author Response to Reviewer Gike
Author Response to Reviewer Gike
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback and for recognizing the value of the age–stage inconsistency problem and our physiology-guided conditioning framework.
1. Dataset Scale and Generalization (W1)
We acknowledge that the original evaluation uses only 30 subjects from Sleep-EDF. To further investigate generalizability, we plan to extend our experiments to the HMC dataset and evaluate the proposed framework on an additional sleep EEG cohort.
2. Motivation for Sleep EEG Generation (W2 and Q1)
Our goal is not to replace conventional EEG acquisition, but to investigate controllable generation of physiologically conditioned sleep EEG. By specifying age, recorded sex, and sleep stage, our framework aims to generate signals under controlled conditions. Potential applications include controlled data augmentation, systematic evaluation of conditional generation models, and analysis of demographic-related physiological variations. We will clarify these motivations and potential applications in the revised manuscript.
3. Evaluation on HMC (Q2)
We plan to conduct additional experiments on the HMC dataset to evaluate the applicability of Phy-DiffKAN beyond the original Sleep-EDF setting. The experimental cohort and evaluation protocol will be determined according to the available demographic annotations and sleep-stage labels.
4. Influence of EEG Channel Number (Q3)
We plan to investigate different EEG channel configurations on HMC, including two-, three-, and four-channel settings where supported by the available recordings. The two-channel configuration will serve as a reference to distinguish dataset-related differences from the effects of channel number.
We sincerely appreciate the reviewer's suggestions. These additional evaluations will help clarify the applicability and limitations of Phy-DiffKAN beyond the original Sleep-EDF setting.