- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces MontageFlow, a flow-matching framework for physically valid, high-fidelity clinical EEG generation. The authors observe that bipolar EEG recordings satisfy exact linear identities: summing channels along two chains with shared endpoints must give identical signals, so the sixteen channels lie in a fourteen-dimensional subspace. They show that state-of-the-art generators violate these identities, yet existing metrics fail to detect this, and propose the montage index to quantify it. MontageFlow enforces validity by construction, projecting both the Gaussian source and the predicted velocity onto the constraint matrix's null space via a closed-form projector; the decoder is a 1-D DiT-B transformer conditioned on timestep, class label, and a window-level latent physiological vector. This latent, produced by a causal-Transformer encoder and sampled at generation from a class-conditional rectified-flow prior, preserves low-energy transients and heavy-tailed amplitudes that oversmoothing erases. Across TUSZ, TUEV, and TUAB, MontageFlow improves TS-FID by 1.7–2.5× over the strongest baseline while achieving a montage index of exactly zero; ablations show that latent conditioning and training through the projector each contribute substantial gains.
Critical strengths
++This work has a certain degree of innovation and is relatively interesting. The corresponding experimental results also verify the effectiveness of the algorithm.
++This paper is well written and easy to follow.
++The ablation experiments in the experimental section also verify the effectiveness of each design. The analysis of experimental results corresponds to the motivation in the introduction section.
Critical weaknesses
-- I recommend that the authors add a discussion of the model's limitations and directions for future research.
-- Although the overall analysis in the experimental section responds to the motivation, I still recommend that the authors conduct further detailed analysis on the content of the ablation part, so that scholars can better understand the relevant details.
Questions for authors
See Weakness
2 comments
RES
I will maintain my current score for this submission.
Limitations and future work
We thank Reviewer HNcg for finding the core observation "original and important" and the projector "elegant and parameter-free." We also appreciate the reviewer’s recognition that validity and fidelity are complementary rather than competing.
Limitations and future work. We will add this section to the paper:
Furthermore, we will revise the paper with the new empirical results, ablations and analyses run during the rebuttal. We thank the reviewer again for supporting this work.