- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GEMIA, a conditional Flow Matching method for EEG generation that combines a patient-balanced structured source with time-domain supervision. The source models cross-spectral structure and amplitude separately, while the objective combines capped velocity-L1 regression with channel-scale, multi-scale increment, and waveform-correlation losses. The method is evaluated against six generators on four patient-disjoint TUH protocols using fidelity, downstream utility, structural diagnostics, and sampling-step comparisons. GEMIA achieves the lowest mean TS-FID across the four protocols and maintains favorable TS-FID with fewer sampling steps.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is clear and the paper is easy to follow.
- The paper addresses the important problem of generating realistic multichannel EEG and proposes an interpretable division between population-level source statistics and sample-level supervision.
- GEMIA consistently achieves the lowest mean TS-FID among the compared methods across the four protocols.
Critical weaknesses
- All four evaluation protocols are drawn from the TUH corpus family and use a common 16-channel bipolar montage. Robustness to external datasets, alternative montages, or different acquisition devices is not evaluated. This limits the evidence for the method’s applicability across heterogeneous EEG recording settings. The authors should test this method on more datasets.
- Though the results is better, I hope the authors can provide more detailed ablation and comparison with JET. To me the novelty is not sufficient enough, as JET already provide a framework of flow matching plus EEG specific regularizations.
- Can the authors provide detailed downstream experiment settings? The TUEV balanced accuracy in Table B3 is specifically low.
- To better understand the generation quality, the authors can provide direct visualizations of generated signals and real signals. It can better show the transient events like spikes of generated signals.
- Additional comparisons of Hjorth parameters would also help assess temporal characteristics beyond spectral similarity.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weakness.
3 comments
I sincerely thank the authors for providing additional experiments and clarification. However, since the gains come mainly from the auxiliary losses rather than the structured source, my concern about novelty relative to JET remains, so I will keep my score.
Thank you to Reviewer r8Wm
Dear Reviewer r8Wm,
Thank you very much for your time and patience throughout the review and the follow-up discussion. Your suggestions on external data, a more detailed ablation and comparison with JET, the downstream setting, waveform visualizations, and Hjorth parameters led us to add several analyses and to understand the boundaries of our contribution more clearly. Your comments also helped us describe the relationship between the structured source and the auxiliary objective more precisely; we will make this distinction clearer in the revised manuscript and keep the trade-off discussion honest. We sincerely appreciate your rigorous review and your help. We wish you all the best.
— The GEMIA authors
Response to r8Wm: external data, matched JET/DiT comparison, downstream protocol, and waveform/Hjorth analyses
We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and for the concrete requests.
1. External data (data breadth). For data breadth, four external datasets with the same Gaussian-vs-GSE control (same J3 objective, matched within dataset):
iEEG is protocol-verified (train-only scaling; two seeds improve strongly, one ties). ISRUC/HMC are exploratory (amplitude scale fitted on all selected subjects); EEGMAT is a single-run control.
2. Novelty relative to JET. Contribution: patient-shared spectral structure in the source + an objective that exploits it. (i) GSE covariance root preserving within/cross-channel correlation vs isotropic Gaussian. (ii) Equal patient weight (each window 1/(P n_p)). (iii) Capped velocity-L1 bounds endpoint-error amplification near t=1. (iv) Auxiliary per-channel log-scale, multi-lag increment and waveform correlation vs the real target; not TV.
Three-seed ablation (TUSZ v1.5.2):
Source effect 3.04% under capped loss, 61.13% under the full objective, auxiliary-term effect 84.45% with GSE fixed. Across the four corpora, source effect under the full objective is 16.25-61.13%, cap-only -14.36% to +34.11%, and auxiliary effect 6.70% (TUAB) to 84.45% (TUSZ1.5.2). The source benefit is objective-dependent (the co-design claim). GEMIA has the lowest TS-FID among the four configurations in all 12 corpus-seed comparisons.
3. Matched JET/DiT comparison. Full source x objective ablation over three seeds on four corpora (per-seed table in supplement): JET and GEMIA use the same backbone, data loader and per-corpus budget, differing only in source and objective; DiT-FM is a same-protocol FM baseline with a DiT backbone. Three-seed TS-FID:
GEMIA beats JET and DiT-FM on all four corpora (JET paired reductions 63.2/55.6/26.1/4.7%); log-PSD favors GEMIA 4/4, ACF 2/4.
4. Downstream setting. TUEV: 6-class, 5-s windows, disjoint patient-wise splits; generator uses all training patients. Classifier real data = fixed 10% patient subset (seed 4407; 25 patients, 6,207 windows); synthetic added per class at synthetic:real 0.5; frozen CBraMod + linear head, AdamW, 50 epochs, batch 256, checkpoint by real-validation AUROC; three paired seeds (0/2025/2026). Test is held-out patients only; Table B3 is mean±sd over these runs.
5. TUEV BA (why it is low). Real-only 0.210; WGAN-GP 0.233; EEG-GAN 0.226; DDPM 0.222; MEG-GPT 0.209; JET 0.218; DiT 0.216; GEMIA 0.222. Test supports [567,4677,1998,329,2204,19646]: background dominates and rare classes are scarce in 5-s windows, so every classifier—including Real-only—predicts mostly the two majority classes (per-class recall behaves similarly). Low BA is a property of this low-patient protocol, not GEMIA-specific; we make no class-level claim. WGAN-GP/EEG-GAN have TS-FID 734.6/954.2 vs 316.6.
6. Waveforms (spike/transient) and Hjorth. We completed direct visual comparisons (real / GEMIA / JET / DiT) on four corpora: full-window raw waveforms (no crop/y-limit), a z-scored view, and zoomed panels around the largest-amplitude transient (fixed rule, not expert labels); real/generated are not pointwise pairs. In these windows GEMIA retains sharp spike-like transients; JET/DiT appear smoother. The rebuttal form does not support figure uploads, so the figure and window list will be in the camera-ready (available by email if the AC permits). Hjorth (single-seed; mobility/complexity, real/GEMIA/JET/DiT):
TS-FID/log-PSD gains do not imply uniform time-domain gains: GEMIA complexity is higher than real on all corpora; we report this trade-off openly. The TUAB JET row uses the matching 28-epoch pool.
We appreciate your assessment of whether these controls address the concerns about novelty, ablation granularity, and the time-domain/Hjorth trade-offs.