- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes OU-WSP FM, a conditional flow-matching framework for ICU time-series generation. The main idea is to replace a standard isotropic Gaussian source with a structured endpoint composed of an OU-inspired autoregressive anchor and a context-adaptive Fourier residual. The model is evaluated on MIMIC-III and MIMIC-IV using downstream forecasting utility, statistical fidelity, and blood-pressure consistency. The paper reports clear improvements over Gaussian flow matching and several generative baselines, particularly in downstream forecasting and spectral fidelity.
Critical strengths
The strongest aspect of the paper is the structured source design. Instead of relying on an uninformative Gaussian endpoint, the method injects temporal information from the observed context before the learned flow transformation begins, which is well motivated for ICU signals. The empirical results are also encouraging: OU-WSP substantially improves over Gaussian FM in downstream forecasting, while the fidelity analysis shows improvements in autocorrelation and spectral metrics. I also appreciate that the authors do not claim that blood-pressure consistency emerges automatically from the generator, and instead explicitly distinguish raw generation from deterministic clinical repair.
Critical weaknesses
The largest weakness is the mismatch between the strength of the main empirical claims and the reliability of the underlying evaluation pipeline. The appendix indicates that the original preprocessing may use future information within the 48-hour window, while the corrected context-only protocol is evaluated only through a narrower source/calibration analysis and does not reproduce the key GRU/TCN downstream results. In addition, some reported fidelity comparisons are affected by inconsistent post-processing: for example, the Gaussian fidelity rows correspond to BP-filtered samples, while post-processing is not uniformly matched across methods. These issues do not invalidate the proposed modeling idea, but they weaken the evidence that the reported gains can be attributed cleanly to OU-WSP under a consistent conditional-generation setting.
Questions for authors
The main question I would like the authors to clarify is whether the headline downstream forecasting improvements remain when the entire preprocessing and generation pipeline is rerun under the strictly context-only protocol described in Sec. 4.6 and Appendix B. At present, the additional analysis helps diagnose the source and calibration behavior, but it does not directly validate the primary forecasting result under the corrected information boundary. I would also like clarification on how the authors intend Table 2 to be interpreted given that post-processing is not uniformly matched across methods, since this affects whether the table should be viewed as a direct fidelity ranking or only as a pipeline-level comparison.
2 comments
Thank you for the careful review and constructive guidance
Dear Reviewer XnMA,
Thank you for your careful reading and for the constructive feedback. We are grateful that you recognized the structured source design, the motivation for injecting temporal information from the observed context, and our explicit distinction between raw generation and deterministic BP repair.
Your two main concerns — whether the headline gains survive a strictly context-only pipeline, and how Table 2 should be interpreted under non-uniform post-processing — were central to our revision. They directly led us to run the full context-only GRU/TCN evaluation and the matched-policy fidelity analysis, and to state the evaluation boundary more clearly than in the original submission. Even though we did not have the chance to continue the discussion, your review shaped how we present the evidence and where we draw the claims.
Thank you again for your time and for helping us make the paper more rigorous. We will carry these points into the revision.
Sincerely, The authors
Response to Reviewer XnMA: Context-Only GRU/TCN Results and Matched Post-Processing
We appreciate the reviewer’s careful reading and the chance to clarify both points. We completed the context-only downstream evaluation, added a three-seed spectral analysis, and a released-TSFlow comparison.
Q1. Downstream evaluation under the context-only protocol
C1 is the completed context-only evaluation, not a narrow source/calibration diagnostic: it covers GRU and TCN on both cohorts (four combinations), all sources, and observed-target scoring. There is no test/validation leakage: generator fits and synthetic training contexts use training-split windows only; validation and test contexts are never used to fit generators or construct synthetic training data. The appendix's 48-hour concern is within-window lookahead in the original imputation, not cross-split leakage; the context-only rebuild removes it. Each synthetic source supplies 6,000 pairs; three repeats are downstream initializations for a fixed generated set. OU-WSP achieves the lowest observed Total among synthetic sources on MIMIC-III (2.1952 GRU, 2.2128 TCN, versus 2.2153/2.2188 for Gaussian FM); across the four combinations it is 0.01%–0.91% below Gaussian FM and 1.54%–2.34% above Real on MIMIC-III. The 22.0%–27.2% comparison used a different protocol; retained as history.
Q2. Fidelity under matched post-processing
R2 reports one matched protocol: 256 held-out contexts × 8 samples, no BP repair or filtering, with output calibration stated per row. OU-WSP has the lowest mean log-PSD discrepancy on both datasets (0.1875 vs 0.2447 on MIMIC-III; 0.1539 vs 0.2119 on MIMIC-IV). Same-backbone rows are three-seed means; TSFlow is one sampling realization.
Spectral evidence and residual increment
R1 reports log-PSD by seed. OU-WSP is lower than Gaussian FM in all six combinations, with mean reductions of 23.4% and 27.4%. Relative to the OU-only control, the reductions are 8.1% and 2.4% (MIMIC-III 3/3 seeds, MIMIC-IV 2/3).
Comparison with adapted TSFlow
We adapted released TSFlow to 24-hour ICU contexts and the 51,200-update recipe. Under C1, OU-WSP is 3.28%–4.18% lower than native TSFlow and 3.56%–4.62% lower than TSFlow+Cal(0.5) across the four combinations.
Tables
Table C1. Context-only evaluation, observed-target Total (Total = MASE+ND+NRMSE; lower is better; three downstream initializations for a fixed generated training set per source).
Table R1. Spectral comparison by dataset and generator seed (log-PSD discrepancy; lower is better).
Table R2. Matched-policy fidelity (256 contexts × 8 samples; lower is better).