- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the impact of deterministic simulator template constraints on intra-class diversity within conditional diffusion models. The authors derive the variance-shrinking behavior of optimal denoising estimates and provide a recurrence relation for the covariance of the reverse sampling process under linear Gaussian assumptions. Through generative experiments using synthetic data as well as the PTB-XL and MIMIC-IV-ECG datasets, the study examines the effects of template accuracy, constraint strength, and various coupling strategies. The results demonstrate that fixed template constraints reduce generative diversity and increase distribution divergence; furthermore, neither improving template accuracy nor sampling templates independently and randomly is sufficient to mitigate these effects.
Critical strengths
The key conclusions are supported by robust controlled experiments. The authors examine the roles of template accuracy, constraint strength, and losses related to morphology and leads; for primary comparisons, they employ a mutually exclusive partitioning of patients and exclude the test patients from the template cohorts. Validation using both synthetic data and two ECG datasets further strengthens the credibility of these conclusions.
Critical weaknesses
- Theoretical analysis offers only limited quantitative explanation for practical diffusion models. The accuracy of multi-step covariance recursion depends on ideal conditions such as Gaussian distribution and overall optimal denoiser, while in real ECG experiments, this recursion significantly underestimates the degree of contraction (in Section 5.1). Consequently, current theoretical frameworks primarily account for the general trend of contraction, yet they remain insufficient for predicting the actual magnitude of contraction in trained models.
- This paper focuses on the fixed-template squared-error constraint used in SE-Diff, analyzing its impact on generation diversity. However, practical simulator-guided methods employ a variety of constraint forms, ranging from residuals of physical equations to adaptive constraints that depend on the generated samples themselves. Although the paper explicitly defines the scope of its conclusions, it lacks a systematic comparison of these diverse constraint types. Consequently, it fails to clarify which constraint designs can enhance physical consistency while preserving intra-class diversity, thereby limiting the paper’s utility as a guide for the development of practical methods.
Questions for authors
-
In the real ECG experiments, the multi-step covariance recursion underestimates the observed contraction. What explains this discrepancy?
-
Table 2 shows that improved diversity and reduced distributional discrepancy do not consistently translate into higher downstream classification AUC. How do the authors interpret this mismatch, and what does it imply about the task relevance of the variation recovered by alternative constraints?
-
Beyond the SE-Diff-derived experimental settings, could the authors provide evidence from another diffusion method that incorporates simulator-based constraints to assess whether the observed contraction generalizes across methods?
Thank the author for the additional experiments and clarifications. The residual and PPG experiments help clarify when contraction occurs. As the authors note in the abstract (last sentence), the results “do not establish that simulator priors or sample-dependent constraints are ineffective in general.” My concern remains how far the proposed design guidance extends to other forms of simulator guidance. I will therefore maintain my original score.