- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents CoLight-GS, a 3DGS-based reconstruction framework that couples bright-domain structural supervision with dark-domain observation fitting through a fixed invertible tone map. Experiments on RealX3D and LOM verify the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical strengths
-
This paper proposes to use a invertiable tone mapping function for low-light novel view synthesis that aims to reconstruct a scene with normal exposure with exposed dark observations, which is interesting. Based on the model design, several regulations and supervisions are proposed as well.
-
Experiments on two datasets verify the effectiveness of the proposed method. Especially, this model does not require any pretrained models, e.g, monocular depth estimation.
Critical weaknesses
-
Overall, the paper is not well written and hard to follow. For example, the motivation is not well written, and readers may have a whole picuture about why and how the model is designed. Additionally, related works are not fully discussed, where the authors list several methods for each topic without clarifying the differences and connections between the proposed method and the previous methds. From my point of view, section related work is a good place for authors to clarify the motivation and values of the proposed methods while the authors neglects this part instead.
-
Low-light images are typically constrained by poisson-gaussian photon shot and read noise, limited dynamic range and non-linear CRF (i.e., sRGB domain). In this case, dark shadows in low-light images are heavily quantized and corrupted by sensor noise. The fixed tone mapping function does not take this feature into account and may amplify the nuse and quantization. In addition, the paper does not provide any noise modeling, denoising modules, or dequantization strategy.
-
Actually, in real-world cameras, CRF for each channel is a bit diiferent. However, the authors use an identical tone mapping function for all the channels.
-
In RealX3D, setting a = 0.8 with q* = 0.05186 yields g* = 31.03. Why was a = 0.8 chosen? Ground-truth normal-light test images in RealX3D typically have their 90th percentile luminance around 0.8. Selecting a = 0.8 essentially peeks at the target distribution to manually calibrate the global scene exposure.
Questions for authors
-
Since is an elementary monotonic curve applied to 8-bit display sRGB images, how does your method avoid fitting and amplifying Poisson-Gaussian noise and quantization banding in dark shadow areas? Did you observe noisy floaters in regions where low-light sensor noise was amplified?
-
In Tab. 2, Shared Gain + Inverse-Only achieves 18.10 dB PSNR, which is identical to the full model's 18.10 dB PSNR. Given that the canonical branch contributes 0.00 dB to PSNR, what evidence is there that dual-domain coupling provides a meaningful radiometric constraint rather than simply adding a second SSIM term?
-
How were the threshold value of 32 and the target mean of 0.49 determined for LOM? Were these parameters tuned directly on the 5 evaluation scenes? How would a user set these parameters on an uncurated, unseen capture?
-
Why was set to 0 on LOM? Does enabling on LOM reduce NVS metrics? Please provide the quantitative results of the proposed method on LOM with with different values.
-
Since T_g applies the exact same curve across all RGB channels independently, how does CoLight-GS handle scenes where low illumination causes severe chromatic shifts or white balance errors?