- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes iBright-GS, which builds on the fast reconstruction pipeline of i3DGS to reconstruct 3D scenes with normal brightness using only low-light multi-view images. The authors first reconstruct the scene geometry using the original dark images. They then combine several techniques, including image brightening, curve/LUT enhancement, per-Gaussian gain adjustment, and multi-view consistency, to generate brighter training targets. These targets are used to optimize a separate set of SH0 coefficients for normal-brightness appearance, while keeping the reconstructed geometry fixed. Experiments on LOM and RealX3D show that the method achieves higher average PSNR than previous low-light 3DGS methods while requiring substantially less runtime.
Critical strengths
-
The related work is well discussed, the figures are clear, and the writing is easy to understand.
-
The authors evaluated their method on both the LOM and RealX3D benchmarks for low-light 3D reconstruction, achieving promising results and outperforming some recent state-of-the-art methods.
-
The authors conducted sensitivity analyses on the bright-appearance learning schedule and hyper-parameters, along with ablation studies of individual components, allowing readers to clearly understand which aspects contribute to the method’s strong performance.
Critical weaknesses
-
The method mainly combines i3DGS with a separate DC color coefficient and distills pseudo-labels generated by 2D image enhancement into 3D. However, distilling 2D enhancement results into 3D is not fundamentally new. The overall approach also relies on several components, including curve/LUT, a brightening branch, per-Gaussian gain, exposure lock, and multi-view loss, which makes it difficult to identify the core technical contribution. In addition, the speed advantage largely comes from the underlying i3DGS framework rather than from a novel contribution of this paper.
-
On the LOM benchmark, RetinexGS actually achieves better SSIM and LPIPS scores than the proposed method. Looking at the results scene by scene in Table 4, the proposed method performs worse in 4 out of the 5 scenes.
-
As a minor suggestion, Table 3 could be split into separate results for LOM and RealX3D to help readers compare the performance more intuitively, since the two datasets feature different lighting conditions.
Questions for authors
-
If η is not used during inference, what determines the overall brightness of the test images?
-
Could the authors include two additional baselines: “2D enhancement + i3DGS” and “i3DGS + post-processing enhancement” to better demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method?
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and additional experiments. The new w/o Full Teacher baseline provides stronger evidence for the benefit of the proposed bright-signal construction. I also appreciate the additional implementation details and related-work discussion. The first major concern is largely resolved and I am getting more positive about this work.
My main remaining concern is the novelty relative to i3DGS and brightness calibration. Since the online and unordered reconstruction capabilities are largely inherited from i3DGS, I think it is important to clarify whether bright Gaussian renderings are available during incremental reconstruction or only after the final finetuning. The additional timing results are helpful, but do not fully clarify this distinction. I also have a remaining question about brightness calibration. The authors' explanation is helpful, but since Eq. (17) normalizes the rendering during training but not at inference, it is still unclear to me how the absolute brightness scale of the unnormalized output is maintained.