- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes LCD-GS, a 3DGS variant for HDR novel view synthesis trained directly on native HDR images. It argues that vanilla 3DGS's spherical harmonics entangle luminance with chromaticity, and proposes a luminance-chromaticity decomposition. Experiments on synthetic HDR-Syn-8S and a new real-world iHDR-4S dataset show gains over 3DGS and HDR-NVS baselines, plus luminance editing.
Critical strengths
The paper identifies that vanilla 3DGS's spherical harmonics entangle luminance with chromaticity, causing underfitting under HDR supervision. The proposed decomposition adds only one scalar per primitive and integrates without architectural change, with consistent gains over 3DGS. This matters because native HDR 3D reconstruction is increasingly relevant.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper operates in a linear HDR color space but does not compare against methods [1,2,3] addressing HDR in linear RAW color space. While the paper's input differs from Bayer RAW in data form and capture pipeline, both carry linear HDR radiance. These RAW-based solutions may also be effective for the paper's input setting. Specifically, LE3D [1] explicitly states that Spherical Harmonics (SH) is unsuitable for RAW linear color space and replaces it with a tiny Color MLP. The absence of any comparison to these methods, and of any discussion of whether their solutions transfer to linear HDR color space, leaves it unclear whether the proposed luminance-chromaticity decomposition is necessary or merely one of several viable fixes to the same SH problem.
-
HDR-GS [4] is trained with HDR supervision on synthetic data in its original design, but it is unclear from the paper whether Table 2 evaluates it with HDR supervision or under the LDR-only protocol. This ambiguity should be clarified. For GaussHDR [5], it reconstructs HDR without native HDR ground truth. The paper evaluates GaussHDR without providing HDR supervision in Table 2. A fair comparison would train HDR-GS and GaussHDR with HDR supervision (in -law). Additionally, if HDR supervision is available, Table 3 (iHDR-4S) could include both HDR-GS and GaussHDR for a more complete comparison, which the paper currently does not provide.
[1] Xin Jin, Pengyi Jiao, Zheng-Peng Duan, Xingchao Yang, Chongyi Li, Chun-Le Guo, and Bo Ren. Lighting Every Darkness with 3DGS: Fast Training and Real-Time Rendering for HDR View Synthesis. NeurIPS 2024.
[2] Ben Mildenhall, Peter Hedman, Ricardo Martin-Brualla, Pratul P. Srinivasan, and Jonathan T. Barron. NeRF in the Dark: High Dynamic Range View Synthesis from Noisy Raw Images. CVPR 2022.
[3] Shreyas Singh, Aryan Garg, and Kaushik Mitra. HDRSplat: Gaussian Splatting for High Dynamic Range 3D Scene Reconstruction from Raw Images. BMVC 2024.
[4] Yuanhao Cai, Zihao Xiao, Yixun Liang, Minghan Qin, Yulun Zhang, Xiaokang Yang, Yaoyao Liu, and Alan L. Yuille. HDR-GS: Efficient High Dynamic Range Novel View Synthesis at 1000x Speed via Gaussian Splatting. NeurIPS 2024.
[5] Jinfeng Liu, Lingtong Kong, Bo Li, and Dan Xu. GaussHDR: High Dynamic Range Gaussian Splatting via Learning Unified 3D and 2D Local Tone Mapping. CVPR 2025.
Questions for authors
How to conduct chromaticity-level editing such as white balance adjustment?
Thanks for the responses. I still think a fair comparison against GaussHDR should be using HDR supervision. Since its color representation is HDR color + HDR-to-LDR tone-mapping, you can remove the tone-mapping, render HDR images from HDR Gaussians, and directly supervise the HDR Gaussians with HDR GT images. Similarly, you can train GaussHDR and HDR-GS on iHDR-4S dataset in above manner. Besides, I want to know why the performance differences between different activation functions are so large in Table R9 and Table 5, especially for HDR-Syn-8S dataset.