- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 1(−1)
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a novel method for 3D HDR novel view synthesis, specifically achieved through pseudo-supervision via a 2D HDR reconstruction approach, a Base-Gain HDR representation, and Prior-Constrained CRF modeling.
Critical strengths
- It seems to have a very good effect.
- The motivation for constructing the entire module is clear.
Critical weaknesses
- The implementation appears somewhat engineering-oriented, and the current approaches are quite common, with no particularly novel findings. For example, 3D base-gain extends the 2D approach to 3D, and closed-loop design, which already exists in Mono-HDR-3D, is also incorporated.
- The performance of the HDR-supervised model drops significantly without supervision. This raises the question of whether all observed gains stem from the pretrained model. If a model with limited generalization capability were used instead, would performance decline substantially? It is worth noting that datasets of a similar scale are typically quite small.
Questions for authors
1.The substantial gain is largely attributed to the pretrained HDR supervision. If this HDR model were replaced with one not trained on this domain, how would the model’s performance change? Is the current comparison fair, given that this pretrained prior has been utilized? Moreover, this is not a widely used prior in the conventional sense. 2. What is the innovative contribution of the Base-Gain representation? It appears to be a straightforward extension of a conventional gain diagram. I do not seem to have a thorough understanding of its core novelty. 3.The monotonic CRF approach had already appeared by 2017. The authors' contribution relative to prior work lies not in merely applying a similar method to 3D or other domains—such straightforward application is largely an engineering task—but rather in the specific innovations they introduce.
5 comments
Response to Reviewer 5TVd (2/4)
W2 & Q1: Performance with a weaker or out-of-domain HDR prior
In short: weaker HDR priors do not erase our superiority; with the four priors we test (Table 3, Appendix A.4), PriorGS beats the strongest baseline in 47 of 48 comparisons. All four priors, IntrinsicHDR included, are already out-of-domain: none was trained or fine-tuned on our benchmarking datasets, and since each was trained on different data, our advantage does not stem from a domain-matched prior. Details follow.
Thank you for raising this point.
-
Weaker priors. Appendix A.4 (Table 3) replaces IntrinsicHDR with three other single-image HDR models: ExpandNet (2018), DeepHDR (2020), and GMNet (2025). With every prior, PriorGS outperforms the strongest baseline on all 12 metrics of Table 3, with a single exception: PSNR on HDR-Plenoxels-Real with GMNet (16.9 vs. 17.7 dB), where PriorGS still wins in SSIM and LPIPS. Prior quality matters mainly on real scenes (e.g., 19.4–24.3 dB PSNR on HDR-NeRF-Real across priors, all above the best baseline’s 16.3 dB), whereas on synthetic scenes all four priors lie within 1.4 dB HDR-PSNR of each other. Consequently, PriorGS’s superiority is not tied to IntrinsicHDR, and our framework can directly benefit from other existing or stronger future HDR reconstruction models.
-
Out-of-domain priors. We use each model’s public weights without fine-tuning, and no benchmarking dataset, including the HDR GT of synthetic scenes (L298–299), is involved in training any prior. ExpandNet and DeepHDR were even released before either benchmark existed. Moreover, each prior was trained on a different selection of scenes and capture settings: synthetic indoor renders and multi-illumination photos (IntrinsicHDR), HDRTV videos and mobile-phone captures (GMNet), and two separately collected sets of HDR photos and videos (ExpandNet, DeepHDR). Although HDR datasets are small, as the reviewer notes, priors trained on such different data all keep PriorGS ahead of the baselines on scenes they never saw; hence, our advantage does not stem from a prior trained on a similar domain.
Q1: Fairness of the comparison + not a widely used prior
In short: we believe the comparison is fair, as all methods receive the same single-exposure LDR views and no HDR GT; our prior only adds zero-shot knowledge from a pretrained 2D model, as is common practice in 3D reconstruction. Details follow.
Thank you for this question.
- Fairness. All methods, including PriorGS, train on the same single-exposure LDR views without HDR GT (L298–299). The frozen 2D model processes only these views, so it adds learned knowledge rather than additional observations of the scene. Likewise, methods using pretrained depth/normal priors in sparse-view NVS and surface reconstruction (e.g., MonoSDF [1], FSGS [2], DNGaussian [3]) are routinely compared against baselines without such priors.
- Not a widely used prior. Supervising a 3D representation with a pretrained 2D model is standard practice [1–3]; our prior is its HDR counterpart. HDR priors are less common than depth/normal priors because HDR reconstruction is a more specialized task.
[1] Yu, Zehao, et al. "Monosdf: Exploring monocular geometric cues for neural implicit surface reconstruction." NeurIPS 2022.
[2] Zhu, Zehao, et al. "Fsgs: Real-time few-shot view synthesis using gaussian splatting." ECCV 2024.
[3] Li, Jiahe, et al. "Dngaussian: Optimizing sparse-view 3d gaussian radiance fields with global-local depth normalization." CVPR 2024.
Response to Reviewer 5TVd (3/4)
W1.1 Our novel findings
Thank you for raising these points, which help us clarify our novelty. PriorGS is built on three novel findings about single-exposure HDR-NVS:
-
Novel Finding 1: Using single-exposure LDR views as the only source of direct supervision leaves HDR reconstruction underconstrained (L050-052).
This motivates the need for learned LDR-to-HDR reconstruction priors to guide HDR recovery (first contribution). Accordingly, prior-free methods fail at recovering HDR radiance although they reproduce the LDR views faithfully (Fig. 1).
-
Novel Finding 2: Anchoring the scene to reliable LDR views while allocating dedicated capacity to less reliable HDR extension improves robustness to cross-view pseudo-HDR inconsistencies (L101-106).
Our base-gain representation (second contribution) realizes this with modeling HDR radiance as an LDR base supervised by LDR views and extended to HDR through a 3D gain field. In contrast, direct HDR encoding of equal capacity suffers severe color and geometry artifacts (Table 2(c); Figs. 2, 7, 16). The 3D gain field also enables 3D HDR appearance editing (Figs. 6, 13, 14).
-
Novel Finding 3: CRF modeling in single-exposure HDR-NVS faces a fundamental dilemma: the CRF must be learned per scene from a single exposure, yet generalize to unseen exposures beyond the narrow supervised range (L077-081).
Existing methods sacrifice one side or the other: flexible CRFs adapt but overfit the observed exposure, while fixed CRFs avoid overfitting but lack scene adaptability (Table 1 vs. 4; Figs. 5, 10). We address this dilemma by regularizing CRF modeling (third contribution) with a learnable prior that constrains the response beyond the supervised range while adapting to each scene, consistently outperforming flexible and fixed alternatives (Table 2(f)–(h); Figs. 11, 18).
W1.2 Research significance of PriorGS
While PriorGS builds on established components, its research significance lies in what it reveals about single-exposure HDR-NVS. Our novel findings above contribute knowledge in two ways:
- they diagnose why existing approaches fail; and
- they show how these failures can be addressed, from which our implementation is derived and is therefore knowledge-driven rather than engineering-oriented.
This knowledge is not specific to PriorGS or even to single-exposure HDR-NVS: it extends to 3D reconstruction from degraded observations guided by learned 2D priors, where the same challenges of underconstrained recovery and inconsistent per-view priors arise.
W1.3 How our closed-loop design differs from Mono-HDR-3D’s
Thank you for pointing this out; we will update the related works section to better present the distinction. As our contribution list reflects:
We do not claim closed-loop reconstruction as a standalone novelty: our novelty lies in incorporating learned LDR-to-HDR priors into HDR recovery, with the closed loop designed specifically to make this incorporation more reliable.
Although structurally similar, the two loops differ in motivation and role:
- Mono-HDR-3D (Mono-HDR-GS in our paper) uses its loop as a substitute for the HDR supervision it lacks, yet the loop alone leaves HDR recovery underconstrained (Figs. 1, 4).
- PriorGS uses its loop as a complement to imperfect pseudo-HDR supervision, anchoring the prior-guided HDR to the reliable LDR views at both ends.
Our ablations reflect this distinction: the loop without the prior falls far short (Table 2(a)), while adding the loop to the prior further improves reconstruction (Table 2(b); Figs. 7, 15).
Response to Reviewer 5TVd (1/4)
We thank Reviewer 5TVd for the constructive comments and for recognizing the clear motivation and strong performance of our method. We hope our responses could address all the concerns.
W2 & Q1: All gains may stem from the pretrained HDR prior
Thank you for this question. We agree that removing the HDR prior causes a large drop (Table 2(a)); this is consistent with our finding that single-exposure HDR-NVS is underconstrained without such a prior (Figs. 1, 4). However, three pieces of experimental evidence show that our gains do not stem from the HDR prior alone:
(1) Performance w/o the prior (Table 2). Even after prior drop, PriorGS (Table 2(a)) outperforms all baselines (Table 1) on HDR-NeRF-Real in every metric and on HDR-Plenoxels-Real in SSIM and LPIPS.
(2) New prior-matched baseline. We additionally trained HDR-GS with the same prior (IntrinsicHDR pseudo-HDR targets) as PriorGS, all else unchanged. We chose HDR-GS as it has the strongest HDR recovery in Table 1 (main paper) among baselines that natively support HDR supervision. With the HDR prior now shared, the two differ in our base–gain representation, closed-loop reconstruction, and prior-constrained CRF. PriorGS still significantly outperforms HDR-GS + Prior in all comparisons:
We will add this new comparison to the paper.
(3) Existing ablations (Table 2). Every variant that keeps the prior but removes or replaces one of our components (Table 2(b), (c), (f–h)) is worse on all six metrics.
Further results. In part 4 of our response to Reviewer EB8P (W3 & Q4), a stronger same-prior baseline also trails PriorGS on every metric across all datasets and tasks.