- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes DualGS, a coarse-to-fine training paradigm for both geometry and appearance modeling. It aims to tackle the problem that traditional methods perform well only in a single task, such as surface reconstruction or appearance modeling. The authors propose a dual-branch Gaussian splatting framework that initializes with a strong surface reconstruction baseline, like 2DGS, to provide accurate geometry initialization. They also propose a cross-branch supervision strategy to encourage the Gaussians to learn geometry and appearance modeling more effectively. Experiments over several datasets, including surface reconstruction and novel view synthesis tasks, demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical strengths
-
This paper is well presented and easy to follow.
-
The idea is easy to understand and effective to deal with the problem that previous methods only focus on a single field.
-
The proposed method shows superior results to previous methods.
Critical weaknesses
-
The idea is straightforward. Training a two-branch of Gaussian Splatting method means we need to train the Gaussians two times. The trainig iterations is doubled. Although the results demonstrate it is useful, I don't think the idea is novel and over the bar of ICLR.
-
In line 240, how do the authors obtain the normal ? Do the authors compute the normal first from some pretrained methods or just from the dataset itself, or using the rendered normal? What is the difference between this normal and methioned on the above?
-
I strongly suggest the authors move the ablation studies in the main paper. It would be better for readers to understand which part of the proposed method is significant.
-
I do not think the proposed scheme is elegant, since it needs to switch to a specific part of Gaussians for better performance. How to combine the advantage of the proposed two-branch gaussians is deserved for research.
Questions for authors
-
The multi-view consistency loss has already been proposed by MVGS[1]. I am curious whether this can further improve the rendering quality of the proposed method.
-
Have the authors tried other tasks different from surface reconstruction, like relighting [2] and reflective object reconstruction [3]
[1] Mvgs: Multi-view regulated gaussian splatting for novel view synthesis
[2] GS3: Efficient Relighting with Triple Gaussian Splatting
[3] Ref-gs: Directional factorization for 2d gaussian splatting