- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
ProbeGS introduces a densification method for resource-constrained 3D Gaussian Splatting that estimates new primitives' scales from local image-residual decay, refines their centers and colors, and lifts them to 3D using a depth backbone. Experiments on three benchmarks report improved reconstruction quality, particularly at a 100K Gaussian budget.
Critical strengths
-
This paper targets an important question: resource/budget-constrained densification. The key insight is that selecting a high-error location does not determine an appropriate primitive size. Estimating scale from the residual is a useful extension of error-guided insertion.
-
The low-budget improvements are meaningful. At 100K Gaussians, Table 1 improves Deep Blending PSNR from 29.44 to 29.94 dB over ConeGS and reduces Tanks & Temples LPIPS from the best baseline's 0.282 to 0.241.
Critical weaknesses
-
The free-shape ablation does not isolate the benefit of constraining shape. From Section 5.3, it seems that the authors change both the initialization, from the analytical field to a fixed isotropic default, and the parameters allowed to optimize. Thus, Table 2 cannot distinguish the value of the initialization from the value of keeping shape tied to the residual field.
-
The efficiency comparison with other residual-fitting approaches establishes a narrower result than a quality-cost comparison. Table 3 measures adapted fitters at the same proposal caps, but does not report the reconstruction quality they achieve under a matched time budget or a less frequent insertion schedule.
-
The comparisons do not fully establish the claimed state of the art under a limited Gaussian budget. Although Table 1 includes recent methods such as ConeGS and EDGS, SteepGS (https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.05587) is cited without a quantitative comparison, and Mini-Splatting2 (https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.12788) appears only at its native Gaussian counts. GS2(https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.01884) is another relevant compact-representation method not covered in the main comparison. The analytical scale/shape contribution also needs positioning against SAD-GS (https://vcai.mpi-inf.mpg.de/projects/SAD-GS/), which uses multiscale image structure for anisotropic densification, although its input-frequency guidance and larger native models differ from the proposed residual-guided insertion. Additionally, some of the baseline configurations need clarification. For example, the EDGS row enables densification, but original EDGS(https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.13204) is designed to eliminate it.
Questions for authors
-
Can you compare constrained and free-shape fitting with identical analytical initialization, proposal sampling, and optimization budgets? How much quality remains with K=0?
-
For Table 3, what quality do the adapted fitters, particularly AuGS, achieve at the reported runtimes or under the same total fitting budget?
-
Table 2 shows only a 0.01 dB loss from removing anisotropy at 100K, compared with 0.11 dB at 1M. Are these differences consistent across scenes or just random noise?