- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4(+1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
EffGS proposes three mechanisms: frequency-aware guidance, local density control, and adaptive elementary scale modulation, which can be extended to city-level scenarios. EffGS highlights the specific image structure through density control combined with spatial details at different stages of training, modifies the density control by distinguishing primitives beyond the sampling coverage and primitives with effective projected footprints, and changes the spatial support area by adjusting the Gaussian effective scale in the optimization process. EffGS achieves high reconstruction quality, efficient training and real-time rendering performance through these three mechanisms.
Critical strengths
EffGS proposes a universal acceleration framework, which not only has comparable rendering quality and training efficiency in small scenes, but also has good performance in large scenes.
Critical weaknesses
- The EffGS components are partially coupled, and the existing ablation experiments cannot effectively isolate the actual contributions of each component.
- The author should add the comparison of FastGS-big, and also add FastGS in the same budget experiment for comparison.
- The image on the right side of Figure 2 is ambiguous. According to the definition in the appendix, it is a high-frequency corresponding difference diagram. The content illustrated in the figure is that effgs has greater high-frequency error, which is contrary to the author's proposition.
- The author claims that the experimental configuration is consistent with 3DGS, but the data in Table 1 are basically from FastGS papers.
- The Gaussian number of EffGS in large scenes is significantly higher than that of FastGS, while it is close to that of FastGS in Mip-NeRF 360, Deep Blending and Tanks & Temples datasets. Does this mean that EffGS has been targeted optimized in large scenes?
- Both and are learnable parameters, but the regularization term $R_\gamma $ can change when is constant.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.