- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SpecGS is a single-GPU large-scale 3D Gaussian Splatting framework that allocates Gaussian capacity using image-space frequency evidence. It controls training resolution according to the Adaptive Convergence Trigger (ACT), and enhances high-frequency rendering quality with DoG supervision in the final stage. On four main urban scenes, SpecGS achieves competitive results with significantly less Gaussian count and GPU costs.
Critical strengths
- Favorable quality–memory trade-off. Against the common Table 2 baselines (CityGaussian, 3DGS, and CityGS-X), SpecGS reduces the four-scene average Gaussian count by 43.0% (8.56M→4.88M) and peak memory by at least 47.2% ($\geq$20.68→10.92 GB), while improving average PSNR by 0.36 dB, SSIM by 2.84%, and LPIPS by 12.65%. The considerable memory reduction allows city-scale optimization on one A5000, where several baselines exceed 24 GB.
- The components are meaningfully ablated. Table 4, Table 5, and Figure 6 provide detailed quantitative and qualitative validation of each module, which sufficiently support the model design choices.
Critical weaknesses
- The method design is heuristic and involves complex hyperparameter settings, involving γ of Frequency–Spatial Support Coupling, η of Frequency-Guided Densification, intermediate training resolution, ACT saturation threshold, and so on. It deserves a discussion of generalization ability and how to adjust the hyperparameters when applied to a custom dataset.
Questions for authors
- Why does SpecGS underperform standard 3DGS by 1.51 dB PSNR on Sci-Art despite all core ablations being conducted on that scene? Which content triggers failure, and is it related to misleading high-frequency responses?
Thanks for the authors'effort in resolving my concern. I do appreciate additional experiments regarding robustness to hyperparameter settings and enhanced ablation settings. I would like to improve the rating slightly, yet no intermediate score exists. Thus, I still recommend weak acceptance.