- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GeoDuet, a dual-branch model combining Euclidean local geometry and Lorentz-based atomic connectivity for metal–organic framework (MOF) property prediction. The two graph-level representations are fused through attention. GeoDuet achieves strong performance on gas adsorption and accessible surface area prediction, supported by component ablations and geometric analyses.
Critical strengths
1. Effective Integration of Complementary Representations
The combination of periodic local geometry and building-block-aware atomic connectivity is well motivated and provides a coherent representation for MOFs.
2. Strong Empirical Performance
GeoDuet achieves the lowest reported MAE across the evaluated CH₄, CO₂, and Ar adsorption conditions. Additional surface-area experiments and geometric analyses further support the practical value of the approach.
Critical weaknesses
Insufficient Isolation of Hyperbolic Geometry's Contribution
As acknowledged by the authors, the contribution of hyperbolic geometry to predictive performance has not been sufficiently isolated. Table 6 shows that incorporating building-block features provides a substantially larger improvement than introducing the Lorentz branch. Moreover, the primary component ablation is restricted to CH₄ adsorption at 4.5 bar, whereas the main benchmarks cover multiple gases and pressure conditions. This makes it difficult to assess whether the contribution of the Lorentz branch generalizes across different prediction settings. Broader ablation studies, including a Lorentz-only configuration and a matched Euclidean–Euclidean baseline, would provide stronger evidence for the independent contribution of hyperbolic geometry.
Questions for authors
1. Comparison with Existing Hyperbolic GNNs
Have the authors considered comparing GeoDuet with representative hyperbolic GNN architectures under the same MOF prediction settings? Such comparisons would help clarify the advantages of the proposed approach.
2. Attention-Based Fusion
Given that attention is applied to only two graph-level representations, could the authors clarify its advantage over simpler fusion strategies, such as concatenation followed by an MLP?
3. Implementation Details
Could the authors provide more details on the message-passing functions (, , , and ), the incorporation of geometric edge features, and the construction of building-block descriptors?
2 comments
Q3. Message passing, geometry, and building-block descriptors.
For the Euclidean branch, let q_ij = [u_i; u_j; e_ij]. The message function is
f_E(u_i, u_j, e_ij) = sigmoid(BN(A_E(q_ij))) ⊙ B_E(q_ij),
where A_E and B_E are separate two-layer MLPs with SiLU activations. Messages are summed over neighbors; g_E adds the batch-normalized sum to u_i, followed by ReLU. Edge embeddings encode inverse distance, -0.75/r, using radial bases. Lattice-vector lengths and angles between edges and lattice vectors provide additional radial/spherical basis features for updating the edge embeddings.
For the Lorentz branch, neighboring features are combined by Lorentz concatenation. The message f_L is a channel-wise sigmoid gate multiplied by a nonlinear transformation of that concatenation. Both transformations use two Lorentz fully connected layers with intermediate Lorentz batch normalization and SiLU activation. The update g_L sums the messages, normalizes the aggregate, applies Lorentz batch normalization, and adds a residual connection; ReLU and a further normalization produce the next state.
Building-block descriptors follow the atom-to-unit assignment. Each atom receives a two-dimensional metal-containing/organic unit indicator and the mean of the 92-dimensional CGCNN descriptors within its unit. These descriptors are broadcast to constituent atoms, so message passing remains at the atomic level. The Lorentz input concatenates learned projections of the atom/type features and the block mean before norm clipping and exponential mapping.
Both branches use the periodic atomic-neighbor graph in the evaluated implementation. The Euclidean branch uses geometric edge embeddings; the Lorentz branch uses BB-aware node inputs and Lorentz transformations. We will add these explicit message/update definitions to Section 4 and clarify the feature construction and graph inputs in Figure 1.
Thank you for the suggestions. We added component comparisons for both CH4 and CO2, an existing hyperbolic-GNN reference, and attention-versus-MLP experiments. We provide the requested message-passing and feature-construction details below.
Component contributions across CH4 and CO2.
The new comparison includes the capacity-matched dual-Euclidean alternative. GeoDuet achieves the lowest test MAE among the evaluated variants on both adsorption tasks.
All models below were trained from scratch on the same 20,000 training structures, with 13,765 validation structures and 13,765 test structures, using seed 17. They have same layers. All models share a 50-epoch training schedule. Values are test MAE in mol/kg; BB denotes building-block features.
The dual-Euclidean model retains the graph inputs, BB features, and fusion mechanism while replacing the Lorentz branch; its parameters are within 0.2% of GeoDuet's at this scale. The results show a GeoDuet advantage on both CH4 and CO2. Comparing Euclidean only with Euclidean + BB under the same reference schedule also shows the benefit of building-block information. We will extend Table 6 with these explicitly defined feature conditions and report the full-data Euclidean result of 0.17770 as an atomic-feature reference.
Q1. Comparison with an existing hyperbolic GNN.
GeoDuet achieves lower test MAE than the adapted HGCN on both tasks. We used the reference HGCN implementation, with atomic and BB features, four hyperboloid convolution layers, tangent-space pooling, and a regression head. Both models use the same 20,000/13,765/13,765 train/validation/test structures and seed 17.
The results show that our method significantly outperforms HGCN, as we adapt hyperbolic networks to crystal material prediction tasks, enabling them to better capture the spatial structures of crystal materials.
Q2. Why attention over only two representations?
Attention learns input-dependent interactions between the Euclidean and Lorentz graph representations. With two representations, its role is to adapt their combination to each MOF. We tested this choice against concatenation followed by an MLP, including a parameter-matched MLP and a larger MLP.
The experiment trains fresh readouts on frozen full-data GeoDuet encoders with four layers and width 256, originally trained with attention fusion on 110,121 adsorption-labelled structures. Readout training uses 10,000 structures, with 13,765 validation and 13,765 test structures. The table reports mean ± sample standard deviation across three readout-initialization seeds, 17, 42, and 123. Each readout uses its stated training configuration; the configurations differ across readout types.
Attention achieves the lowest mean MAE on both targets, with essentially the same parameter count as the matched MLP and fewer parameters than the larger MLP. The gain is more pronounced for CH4; the CO2 means are close. Holding the final CO2 attention configuration fixed and adding two initialization seeds gives 0.33892 ± 0.00030 over five seeds. These results support attention as a parameter-efficient fusion module on the learned GeoDuet representations; the reported variability concerns readout initialization with the encoders held fixed.