- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CPGN, a graph neural network for crystal (and molecular) property prediction that augments the standard atom graph + line graph formulation of ALIGNN with a third "coordination polyhedron graph" . Polyhedra are extracted via Pymatgen's VoronoiNN, represented as nodes with 7 hand-crafted geometric/chemical descriptors (coordination number, bond-length distortion, bond-angle variance, volume proxy, mean bond length, electronegativity mismatch, coordination type), and connected by edges weighted by sharing type. The three graphs are processed by interleaved message passing, coupled by a "bidirectional cross-attention" in which each stream attends over the crystal-level mean of the other stream, followed by mean pooling, fusion, and multi-task heads (formation energy, band gap, stability classification). The paper reports results on MP 2018.6.1, JARVIS-DFT, QM9, with ablations framing CGCNN ALIGNN CPGN as progressively adding and , a scaling study over training-set sizes, inference/memory profiling, and a theoretical section.
Critical strengths
Writing is clear and easy to follow.
The evaluation benchmark follows mature baselines, and is well-covered on evaluation datasets.
Inductive bias is physically well-motivated.
Critical weaknesses
The headline SOTA claims rest on substantially under-tuned reproductions, and the paper's own appendix contradicts them. There is internal inconsistency on the single most important baseline number. See Tables 1, 11, 19 and the digits reported by ALIGNN's original article. Please check the implementation of ALIGNN thoroughly.
Given that your cross-attention has a single key, why does it need $0.326 * 4.85 $ M parameters? Have you compared it against (a) a small MLP injecting the pooled other-stream vector, and (b) per-atom-to-own-polyhedron attention?
The performance of this work is substantially outdated. All the compared methods are from 2018-2021. Please consider some up-to-date works, including PotNet (ICML23), ComFormer (ICLR24), Crystalformer (ICLR24), PDDFormer (IJCAI25), CrysLDNet (ICML26) and so on.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.
Official Comment by Area Chair dEJW
Dear reviewers,
Thank you very much for your time and effort in reviewing this submission. The authors have now submitted their rebuttal, and the discussion period is nearing its end. We would greatly appreciate it if you could take some time to carefully review the authors’ responses and share your assessment of whether your concerns have been adequately addressed. Thank you again for your valuable time and contributions to the review process.