- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces two new molecular representations, AtomGrid and GroupGrid. These are combined with three standard fingerprints, ECFP, AtomPair, and MACCS, and their prediction scores are fused through a lightweight gated model for downstream ligand-based virtual screening and molecular property prediction. I largely agree with the paper's high-level message that chemistry-aware representation learning deserves more attention than simply increasing downstream model complexity. However, I view the score-level fusion component as largely incremental, so I primarily evaluate the paper based on the soundness of the proposed algorithms used to construct AtomGrid and GroupGrid.
On this point, I have major concerns. The construction of both representations is described too vaguely to reproduce confidently from the manuscript alone, the provided code repository is currently inaccessible, and the paper does not provide sufficient representation-level ablation studies to validate the key design choices behind AtomGrid and GroupGrid.
Critical strengths
I really like and agree with the message delivered by the paper: "future molecular learning should place greater emphasis on chemistry-aware representation learning, not only on increasing downstream model complexity."
Critical weaknesses
- AtomGrid reproducibility and soundness are difficult to assess from the paper alone. The main text gives only a high-level description of the chemical environment types and coordinate construction, while the appendix still does not provide the exact atom-typing rules needed to reproduce the representation. The paper also does not include representation-level ablations for key design choices such as the covalent/electrostatic/dispersion channels, conformer dependence, atom typing, or E-state ordering. Since the provided code link is currently inaccessible, it is unclear whether AtomGrid can be faithfully reproduced or whether its reported gains are robust to these choices. This makes it difficult for me to assess the soundness of the proposed representation. A dedicated figure showing the full construction pipeline, or pseudocode specifying the exact steps and rules, would be very helpful.
- GroupGrid has a similar reproducibility and soundness issue.
- The paper appears to rely heavily on LLM assistance without sufficiently careful auditing. For example, the bibliography includes the entry “Johannes Klicpera, Janek Groß, and Stephan Günnemann… 2020. Author later published as Johannes Gasteiger.” The note “Author later published as Johannes Gasteiger” is highly unusual for a bibliography and suggests that AI-assisted text may not have been carefully reviewed.
- The abstract is presented in multiple paragraphs, making it read more like a mini introduction than a conventional conference abstract.
- The provided code repository link does not work.
- There appears to be a discrepancy between Table 2 and Table 11, which I understand to be the full version of Table 2. The discrepancies involve both the reported numbers and the methods/configurations shown. In addition, Table 2 in the main paper should report the full results with standard deviations.
- The paper lists GCN, GIN, GraphSAGE, GAT, GPS, SGFormer, MolBERT, ChemBERTa, MolFormer, Uni-Mol, and GraphMVP, but the sentence introducing them only names the models without individual references. The reference list contains some related papers, but from the manuscript text it is not clear which exact source or implementation corresponds to several of these baselines, especially GPS, SGFormer, MolBERT, ChemBERTa, and GraphMVP.
Minors
- The average AUROC of 5FP-Fusion in Table 2 is reported as 77.4, but the listed per-dataset values average to approximately 77.6.
Questions for authors
Were the baseline models re-implemented and evaluated on the same data splits as the proposed methods?