- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents MOLGRID, an explicit, fixed-size 3×N×N symmetric tensor encoding of a molecule (built from SMILES in milliseconds, no 3D input) with three chemically meaningful channels: through-bond coupling via shortest-path products of bond-type attenuations and normalised bond orders, Gasteiger charges (per-atom on the diagonal, pairwise products off it), and stereochemistry (R/S and E/Z). Feeding this "image" to a chemically pretrained DINOv2-B yields competitive results on seven scaffold-split MoleculeNet tasks (leading reproduced D-MPNN, MolFormer-XL and ECFP4-RF on five of seven each, and 3D Uni-Mol on ESol). The paper's main scientific claim is analytical: because every cell has a fixed chemical address, retraining after scrambling the atom-pair assignments (against an atom-relabelling control) shows which register each property reads. Across nine properties, only the HOMO–LUMO gap depends on which atom pair carries which coupling (+5.7 pp pair excess, positive on all ten seeds), solvation tasks depend most on per-atom charges, and only BBBP reads stereochemistry — consistent with an additivity-based prediction that additive properties read atoms while delocalised ones read pairs. Chemical pretraining improves 25/28 backbone–task pairs without changing the reading pattern.
Critical strengths
Outstanding practicality: SMILES input only, millisecond-level construction, bit-level accuracy, and no need for 3D conformations; as an image, it can directly reuse visual backbones such as DINOv2 and SigLIP; it is compatible with 12 backbones spanning three orders of magnitude; it outperforms 5 out of 7 baselines, and ESol outperforms Uni-Mol.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The intervention analysis is not tied to MOLGRID itself. This process is, in principle, applicable to any explicit molecular representation; the paper does not demonstrate that MOLGRID’s specific encoding produces more reliable or informative results than simpler explicit encodings; when performance is merely “competitive,” the unique contribution of the encoding to the core findings remains unclear.
W2. The comparisons fail to isolate the contribution of the encoding. Table 3 simultaneously alters the architecture, initialization, and pretraining; SI Table 13 shows inconsistencies in training set size and splitting, so improvements cannot be attributed solely to input representations.
W3. No controlled ablation for key components: the path product in Ch0 was not compared to the direct adjacency matrix or shortest-path distance; the three pre-training objectives and courses were not decomposed individually; the claim that “pre-training does not alter reading patterns” was only supported by a before-and-after comparison in SigLIP/ESol.
W4. Unclear boundaries in the argumentation: The path product involves intermediate atoms yet corresponds to a two-body term; the approximation is not explained; the in-depth argumentation does not apply to Transformer/MACE-class architectures; the path product is insensitive to key-type sequences and selects the first path among parallel paths, yet sensitivity has not been evaluated.
W5. The report lacks rigor: The denominators for the number of failures (278) and the success rate (93.05% ⇒ 1,390) in Table 2 are inconsistent; there is no physical explanation for qᵢqⱼ; and terminology is ambiguous in multiple places (“chemistry,” “ImageNet-initialized,” “nearly independent”).
Questions for authors
Q1. Given the same backbone, initialization, and budget, by how much does the Ch0 path product improve distance accuracy compared to the direct adjacency matrix and shortest path distance? How insensitive is it to key-type sequences, and how sensitive is it to selecting the first path among parallel paths?
Q2. What are the respective contributions of the three-objective pretraining and the complexity course? Please provide individual ablation results.
Q3. Before and after DINOv2-B chemical pretraining, are the nine-property intervention plots (Fig. 5a) consistent? Please provide before-and-after comparisons for at least gap, ESol, and BBBP.
Q4. Can the MolSight comparison in Table 13 be replicated under the same molecular partitioning, teacher information, and pretraining conditions?
Q5. Why do the path descriptors correspond to the two-body terms in Equation (2) (even though they include intermediate atoms)? Does the denominator for the 278 failures in Table 2 match the 93.05% success rate?