- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MolField, which models molecules as continuous implicit neural fields in 3D space and explores learning with functions and their parameters as molecular representations. The method combines canonical coordinate construction, structured weight tokenization, and a conditional hypernetwork to generate molecular field parameters, and adopts either field querying or parameter-based read-out depending on the task. The authors evaluate the framework on tasks including dynamic molecular surface modeling, molecular property prediction, and generation. The results show that the framework has advantages in dynamic surface modeling and on some molecular property prediction tasks, offering valuable empirical support for applying continuous neural fields to molecular representation learning.
Critical strengths
The paper combines continuous neural field modeling with hypernetworks, offering an inspiring perspective for molecular representation, and its novelty is commendable. The framework design is coherent, performing relatively well on dynamic surface modeling and some property prediction tasks, and the module ablation and pretraining comparison lend some support to the effectiveness of the overall framework.
Critical weaknesses
(1) The research motivation still needs to be further specified. Taking the continuous physical properties of molecules as the starting point is reasonable, but the correspondence between the specific limitations of existing 3D molecular representations and the expected benefits of this work's choice of a geometric field and parameterized representation could be made clearer. The current discussion of the limitations of existing models is fairly general; it would be helpful to specify more concretely in which aspects of information modeling or task settings these models are constrained, and which problems the continuous field representation can specifically alleviate, thereby strengthening the link between the research motivation, method design, and expected benefits.
(2) The attribution of the method's gains still needs to be strengthened. The paper's central claim is that representing molecules as functions is itself a valuable paradigm. Although the authors provide component-wise ablations that lend some support to the effectiveness of the complete framework, all of these ablations retain the function-based representation framework and only remove components within the paradigm. They can therefore only indicate whether individual components matter, but cannot answer the core question of whether the function-based representation itself yields any benefit. We suggest adding targeted comparisons to clarify the specific contribution of field modeling to the downstream gains.
Questions for authors
(1) In Table 1, only DSR is a domain-specific (molecular) method. The paper cites HyDiF (described as "closest to us") and MoE-DSR but does not include them in the comparison. Could the authors explain why? Is it due to the lack of public code or an inability to reproduce them?
(2) In Dynamic Surface Modeling, z is formed by "concatenating the molecular embedding with the time step," but the main text does not explain how this embedding is obtained. "A learned embedding" is ambiguous. Could the authors specify its construction and dimensionality?