- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduced a sophicasticated framework named Denoising Papangelou Score Matching (DPSM) for generating spatial patterns of multiple elements. The authors presented the mathematical development of the method, and used a series of geometrical patterns to illustrated the properties of the proposed framework. They also claimed that experiments were done on real biological data and showed some benchmarking metrics, but they didn't really present what were the biological data and what were the generated results. The proposed framework may have some potential in certain spatial generation tasks. But the biological scenario is poorly defined and the claims and conclusions on the biology side of the story are unjustified. Given that the title, abstract, introduction and discussion are all toward a paper that aimed at solving biological tasks, the submission cannot be a strong candidate for publication.
Critical strengths
The mathematical framework seems to be strong with the series of theorems proving its properties.
Critical weaknesses
The link of the mathematical framework will real biological situations is weak or absent. The method may be used for generating toy simulation data, but its use on real biological problems is absent.
Questions for authors
What is the definition of the biological task of "generating cellular spatial organization"? What is the use or potential use of such generation? What are the assumptions you need to make on the biological data to justify the principle of DPSM, and how well they are met in different biological organs/tissues? How do you evaluate the generated results in the biological sense? What are the biological significances of the metrics used in the experiments?