- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FCDC, a traffic forecasting model equipped with a delay-correction mechanism based on lags between nodes. FCDC determines the magnitude and the sign of a correction to the base forecast by taking into account the local history, the delayed evidence, and the base forecast itself. FCDC outperforms baseline methods on four real-world datasets.
Critical strengths
- S1: The idea of using lags to correct a forecast is interesting.
- S2: The effectiveness is confirmed on real-world datasets.
- S3: The authors release code for reproducing the experiments.
Critical weaknesses
- W1: The design rationale of the method is not sufficiently explained in the manuscript. In particular, I have the following questions.
- W1-1:Why is it necessary to separate the global prediction and the self (own-history) prediction to obtain the base forecast?
- W1-2: Why does the global prediction not use standard spatial attention and temporal attention?
- W1-3: Why do lags need to be used to correct the base forecast? It is also possible to build a single forecasting model that takes all lag information as input. The motivation of this work would be clearer if the authors explained why they consider such an approach insufficient.
- W2: The performance gains over the baselines and the ablation variants are not necessarily large. In particular, even the "Parameter-matched MLP", in which the proposed delay branch is entirely replaced with an MLP, is only about 1% worse than the full model (Table 2), although its mean performance is lower on all datasets. Moreover, the ablation variants would in most cases rank second best in Table 1. These results suggest that most of the advantage of the proposed method over the baselines in Table 1 is attributable to the base forecast, and that the contribution of the delay branch, which is the core of the proposal, may be small.
Questions for authors
- Q1: Please explain the experiment in Figure 2. What does the horizontal axis "condition-only shift" represent?
- Q2: What is the purpose of gating with ? It seems that only could lean the scale of the correction. Please explain the intention behind introducing the gate.
- Q3: The magnitude of the lag may vary with the time of day and with traffic conditions. Currently, a single is shared across all times. Consequently, the aggregation weights in Eqs. (5) and (6) are time-invariant. If the lag varies over time, and may be computed from incorrect lags. Is accounting for the time dependence of lags outside the scope of this work?