- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PI-Dir-STGCN for traffic flow forecasting. The method combines directed graph convolution with a physics-inspired conservation constraint based on the Lighthill–Whitham–Richards traffic flow model. It also predicts traffic flow, occupancy, and speed jointly, with the goal of improving forecasting accuracy while encouraging physically consistent predictions.
Critical strengths
-
Incorporating traffic flow conservation into graph-based forecasting is a reasonable direction. The use of road direction information is also relevant to the physical characteristics of traffic networks.
-
The paper includes several ablation experiments, such as STGCN-Multi, Dir-only, and PI-only, which help examine the contributions of the additional inputs and individual components. Reporting conservation error is also useful.
Critical weaknesses
-
The forecasting performance is not competitive with the stronger baselines. In Table 1, the proposed method obtains MAE values of 23.36 and 18.73 on PeMS04 and PeMS08, respectively, while STAEformer achieves 18.23 and 13.58. These are substantial differences. Moreover, Table 3 shows that the improvement over STGCN-Multi is only 0.31 and 0.32 MAE on the two datasets. This raises questions about the practical value of the proposed physics-informed and directed-graph components.
-
The physical formulation needs stronger justification, As I see, the paper uses occupancy as a proxy for traffic density and introduces routing weights to describe traffic flow between connected nodes, however, it is unclear whether the resulting graph-based discretization consistently represents the underlying conservation law, particularly at intersections involving merging or diverging traffic streams.
-
The experimental evaluation is limited to two datasets, it gives the relatively small improvement over the matched STGCN-Multi baseline, more extensive experiments would be necessary to establish that the proposed physical constraints offer consistent benefits.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors provide a more rigorous derivation of the graph-based conservation constraint, including its treatment of road intersections, boundary conditions, and physical units?
-
Why does the proposed method perform substantially worse than STAEformer on both datasets? What is the practical advantage of PI-Dir-STGCN compared with stronger existing forecasting models?
-
Can the authors evaluate the proposed method on additional datasets and provide results across multiple random seeds, particularly for the comparisons with STGCN-Multi?
3 comments
Please Respond to the Authors’ Rebuttal
Dear Reviewer 9RXX,
The discussion period ends in a few hours. Could you kindly check the authors’ responses and let us know whether your concerns have been addressed?
Thank you!
Best regards, The AC
Thanks for the rebuttal
Thank you for the rebuttal. After reviewing the concerns raised by the other reviewers, I have decided to maintain my original score.
We provide a rigorous mathematical reconstruction, verify conservation via a minimal network, and demonstrate practical superiority through multi-seed and plug-and-play experiments.
We deeply appreciate your meticulous review and constructive feedback. R1:We have thoroughly rewritten Section 3.2.3 and Appendix A.1 to address your concerns.Units: We introduce a learnable node-specific scalar c_i to convert occupancy to density, and a global scalar α to dynamically absorb dimensional discrepancies. Intersections and Boundaries: We explicitly define the closed-boundary assumption and clarify that remaining residuals stem from unmonitored ramps. Furthermore, we designed a minimal closed-network verification experiment (new Section 4.6). A 4-node network with diverging/merging flows proves that our routing ratios sum to exactly 1.0, guaranteeing structural flux conservation (internal residual = 0.0) at arbitrary intersections. R2: We acknowledge in the revised text that STAEformer (MAE 18.23/13.58) is the most accurate pure data-driven point estimator. However, pure data-driven models suffer from severe physical inconsistency (high CE) and error accumulation. The practical advantage of PI-Dir-STGCN is its physical reliability and long-horizon stability. More importantly, our proposed physical module is universal: we have integrated our LWR residual into a multivariate STAEformer (STAEformer-Multi) to demonstrate the universality of our method, and presented this in 4.2. Specifically, after incorporating the LWR loss, the MAE on PeMS04 dropped from 20.80 to 19.73, and on PeMS08 it decreased from 15.17 to 14.88. Meanwhile, under a unified evaluation metric (using unscaled, inverse-transformed raw predictions without α), the Conservation Error (CE) also demonstrated a consistent decline (from 0.135 to 0.112 on PeMS04, and from 0.101 to 0.097 on PeMS08).We clearly maintain in Table 1 that the original STAEformer (yielding MAEs of 18.23 and 13.58) remains the most accurate pure data-driven point estimator. Our newly added paired experiment is specifically designed to answer what benefits are gained when applying the physical loss to the exact same multivariate backbone: it acts as an effective plug-and-play regularizer that not only improves macroscopic physical consistency but also enhances point-prediction accuracy by mitigating overfitting. R3:We have updated Table 3 to report the mean and standard deviation across 3 random seeds (42, 1024, 2026) to ensure rigorous comparison, particularly against STGCN-Multi. While time constraints during the rebuttal period prevent us from evaluating entirely new datasets, we believe the current comprehensive evaluation on two major benchmarks (PeMS04 and PeMS08) with multi-seed runs sufficiently validates our claims.